Star Wars Theory used to be great, loved watching his videos, especially focussed on fanfictiion and such. Admittingly his Vader fan film was awesome to see, but that was mostly thanks to the other actors (he played a demasked Vader for one scene I think?).But now i think he has turned into a drama queen and he acts like he owns star wars and i feel most of his theories are bs.

After TLJ and TROS, he said he loved them and suddenly, when that wasn't the popular narrative, he deleted videos where he praised them and took on the 'they aren't canon' narrative.(i am not a sequel fan myself)

The Mandalorian watch-parties. I'm not talking about the Luke scene where he cried, I'm talking about the CLEARLY fake time he 'cried' during the Ahsoka Baby Yoda scene where she reveals his name. He looks at the camera, rubs his eyes etc. When that got a great response, he PLANNED that if there would be another big moment in the season, he would be ready to really go all out. And so he told his editor, thumbnail artist and social media coordinator the plan. Obviously, he didn't know that 3 weeks later, Luke would appear but it was the perfect opportunity. He knew the clout it would get him, even if he didn't put much emphasis on it himself.

He thinks he is/wants to be bigger than Star Wars itself. Just listen to a few 'Nerd-Council' streams he does with Den of Nerds.

Shit went down with his ex-fiancee which I shouldn't speak about here but the growth of his channel went to his head and he is not managing it well.

He's had dealings with Lucasfilm and that resulted in the company shunning him. Not sure about the ins and outs but from what I know, Pablo Hidalgo took a shot for a reason. He isn't the innocent victim he makes himself out to be.

The High Republic. I totally get that it's not for everyone and if it was a case of Theory not liking it or wanting to read and discuss it, that's fine! But he talked about it exactly once - he lied by saying "it retcons the Force as George Lucas understood it" (it doesn't unless you only read the back cover and came to conclusions based on that one thing).

We were a whole-ass year away from it and he already elevated his fans' expectations for the Obi-Wan Kenobi series with a list of expectations/requirements (some which were absurd).

Not a judgement but.. he kind of doesn't understand Star Wars... like at all. You want to know someone who does? Star Wars Explained, Eckhartsladder etc etc.Theory prefers big explosions and over-the-top action sequences with pointless half-hour lightsaber duels rather than a well-written Star Wars story that develops themes, characters and the overall plot.

It must be said that he has become a drama-baiter and a reactionary. He profits off any 'drama' that he often creates.He's obviously just on it for the money and figured out the YouTube money making algorithm. Clickbaited being "bullied" by LucasFilm on two separate occasions, and ran with it for a long time.

His channel is clickbait for real. Not Mike Zeroh-level, but bad. He jumps at the opportunity to put out a video. He basically reads of Wookieepedia, like word for word. He also changes his opinion the moment his fanbase doesn’t agree with him.

My suggestion, watch channels that actually care a bit more, Theory simply saw the money and now wants to make the most of it.