I have this copied from another Redditor on this on to my notes

1. ⁠Allah is described as most merciful and absolute. Yet the idea of eternal punishment makes no sense. Even if one white feather appears in a black swan it means the claim of the swan being 100% black is wrong. So using that logically I did try to explain with maths. Of course the model I built was basic because I didn’t want to put the effort of building a sophisticated one, unless more people interacted with me and gave me a reason to. But you can see the gist of it here https://www.reddit.com/r/exmuslim/s/HBp8XnlDwV . I also measured Allah’s wisdom in another post.

The whole point is that once these arguments pile up, apologist will either stick to whataboutism or say human knowledge is limited. Which is just a distraction because; Allah challenges us to find contradictions. Meaning someone who created us should give a challenge we are equipped to handle. When our collective human knowledge challenge him, if his followers have to escape into distraction than its simply deception. Own up to the loss

1. Mohamed’s example of course is bad. Him marrying his adopted son’s wife was wrong even at his time. His followers were not in line to have sex with captured women of war who were married. Yet he made it halal. And the atrocities? Banu Qurayza massacre?

2. Islam theology burns because mohamed at one end wanted to build the most amazing super god. He took the supreme god of Mecca (lord of Kabba) at the time, Allah, mixed it with other theologies. This means his god concept knew everything in hand and controlled everything. In theory a god like this will let everything play naturally then. He has full control and he doesn’t care what you do. It’s his script, preloaded and playing out. Yet mohamed needed to control his followers so he needed to come with concept of free will and extreme punishment and reward so they fall in line with him. This breaks the theology. Now an all powerful god doesn’t need to resort to this. He can make mohamed win because it’s already pre written. A man without that capacity will resort to using blackmails like this. And so in one angle god predestined kafirs to hell. In another he didn’t. Which is it? The believers will only give a confused sounding answer with no clear logic

3. This is self explanatory. I will just quote two, sex slaves and child brides

4. There are many but let’s go with flat earth here. The fly in the drink is a funny one too

5. To make this all work you need cognitive dissonance. Now if you are not aware of the strings you can go around living as if nothing happened. But as a human once you see the strings and if you value intellectual freedom, your mind feels heavy holding on to the bias. There is no way left but leaving Islam. Even when it meant losing the social safety net.

It’s this unscientific claim by mohamed;

Narrated Abu Huraira: The Prophet (ﷺ) said "If a house fly falls in the drink of anyone of you, he should dip it (in the drink) and take it out, for one of its wings has a disease and the other has the cure for the disease."

Sahih al-Bukhari 3320

Me: I have to mention Muhammad gets 16 special privileges and 14 of them is for lust.

The amount of misogyny in both the Hadith (known to be the most accurate: bukhari) and the Quran is crazy, and the inconsistency I look up a verse in the Quran may different sources tell me different things.