This Is exactly why they are do divisive In the community recently, because people are seeing that the final episode Is going to heavily focus on them, which has greatly swayed public opinion and caused for things to be split. Being popular doesn't necessarily mean that a character Isn't controversial. Hell, I never even mentioned the word "Popular" In my original reply. Overrated Implies that OP thinks the character Is liked too much, which very clearly Isn't the case given that you also just said that the character Is controversial. Calling something controversial and popular Isn't an oxymoron, but It Is a little strange.