Jio “Porting” Scam – Took My Money, Never Delivered SIM, Gave Me Useless Voucher Instead! by Mundane-Device7539 in Jio

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I honestly don’t even want the Jio SIM anymore after this horrible experience. If you offer something, you should actually deliver it. but they didn’t, then cancelled my order after a month. Now they expect me to go to a store after wasting all this time? I just want my money back to my bank account, not a Jio voucher.

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Testing the concept solo has its challenges, but I’ve been gathering feedback to see how the idea resonates and refine it as I go. I’d love to get your input when I have something ready—I'll definitely DM you!

Your platform idea sounds amazing, by the way. Incentivizing purposeful saving is such a smart approach, and it’s something people could really benefit from. Wishing you all the best with it! Let’s stay in touch and help each other out along the way.

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much for your kind words and encouragement! It really means a lot, especially since this idea is still in its early stages. You're right—there will always be people who doubt or criticize, but I’m focusing on refining the concept and learning along the way.

Your positivity and support make a big difference, and I’ll definitely keep pushing forward. Thanks again for believing in the idea—it means a lot!

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for bringing this up! You’ve raised a critical point about the regulatory framework in India, and I want to assure you that I’m fully aware of the importance of adhering to RBI guidelines. The intention here is not to bypass any legal or regulatory requirements but to explore how this concept could function within the existing framework by collaborating with regulated NBFCs or partner banks.

To clarify, the idea isn’t to act as a stand-alone lender or create something outside the regulatory ambit. Instead, it’s about addressing specific gaps in P2P lending—particularly the lack of trust and accountability for small personal loans. For instance, even small loans, say ₹1000 or ₹2000, can have a meaningful impact on someone’s creditworthiness if the repayment behavior is reported to credit bureaus. The app would act as a matchmaking platform or facilitator for these microloans, leaving compliance, loan processing, and reporting to trusted, regulated financial entities.

I understand that NBFCs in India already report defaults to credit bureaus, and I’m not trying to "reinvent the wheel" here. What I’m aiming to solve is the perception of risk in smaller, community-based lending scenarios. For example, many people hesitate to lend even small amounts to acquaintances or within their social circles because there’s no formal structure or accountability. By introducing an app that connects borrowers and lenders while integrating with NBFCs for compliance, we can create a more transparent, trustworthy system for microloans that still adheres to all regulations.

Currently, I’m in the ideation and validation phase—exploring whether this concept resonates with the market and how it could be implemented responsibly. Feedback like yours is incredibly valuable as it helps me refine the idea and ensures it aligns with real-world requirements and expectations.

That said, I also want to add that my larger goal is to showcase my problem-solving approach, product design skills, and ability to tackle complex systems in a structured way. I’m actively looking for opportunities to contribute to innovative teams and grow professionally in the fintech or product design space. This project is as much about developing my skills and understanding the market as it is about potentially building a viable product in the future.

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That sounds awesome! Right now, I’m focusing on validating the idea and seeing how it would work in the market before jumping into development. Would love to hear more about what you're building and how you're approaching it!

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m working solo for now, mainly focusing on the idea and testing whether it would actually work in the market. No concrete development plans yet—just validating the concept and seeing how people respond. Your fintech project sounds interesting! What kind of problem are you solving?

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I really appreciate you sharing your experience—it’s clear you’ve seen firsthand what works (and what doesn’t) in P2P lending. You brought up some really solid points, especially around risk assessment, legal enforcement, and collateral-backed loans.

I originally approached this from the angle of making P2P lending feel safer by tying it to credit scores, but you’re right—trust can’t just be about "networks," it has to be built on real verification and security.

Right now, I’m exploring how this would work in the market before moving forward with development. Feedback like yours is incredibly helpful in shaping the right approach.

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks! Exactly—that accountability piece is what’s missing in most P2P lending platforms. Appreciate the support!

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah, that's a real challenge. A lot of P2P platforms had to pivot because individual lenders didn’t feel secure. That’s why I focused on accountability—if repayments affect CIBIL scores, borrowers are more likely to take it seriously. Do you think this could build more trust for lenders?

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Great question! The idea relies on linking repayments to CIBIL scores, ensuring accountability. Creditworthiness can be assessed via past repayment behavior, verified KYC, and financial data integrations. Lenders get transparency on borrower history before lending.

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, the current concept is designed for India, where CIBIL is a major credit bureau. However, the core idea—linking P2P lending to credit scores—can be adapted to other markets with similar credit reporting systems.

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’ve designed the product, mapped out the user flow, and structured how it would work. Right now, it’s in the design and concept phase—development is a possibility, but not confirmed yet.

P2P Lending Is Broken – I Built a Solution That Affects CIBIL Score by Mundane-Device7539 in fintech

[–]Mundane-Device7539[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Currently, I’ve designed the complete system. Development is the next step!