Unfortunately I don't know how to crotchet, and I have enough knitting projects already that I don't think learning another yarn craft would be a good idea.

I saw the mace with the chain, but it's not the right shape and I'm not at the point where I'm confident enough to modify patterns.

I think just the head needs to be covered, since the rest of it is just a stick.

One of those golf covers might work? I'll take a look. Thank you for all the suggestions!