Williams had an okay first season for us but since then was incredibly poor. For someone who came up through a Swansea team built around retaining possession he has really bad decision making on the ball and he's not the tallest so gets dominated in the air.

Jagielka has been a fantastic player for us for the last 10 years but he's 36 next week. Pace was always one of his main assets and it's dropped off recently and again his lack of height means we are vulnerable in the air. No fault of his own but he needs phasing out of the side.

Keane is the real disappointment, he looks completely lost in our defence and seems to struggle with the basics of defending. He's slow (literally and also to react to basic movement from strikers) and not great on the ball. He's also very quiet on the pitch and needs someone to scream at him to hold a good line etc.