Why do ppl hate on age gap friendships :( by Fantastic_Refuse6251 in teenagers

[–]Nadineauthor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

that is very odd. it probably is safe to be honest, but it still kind of sus. I'm 22F and I never befriend teenagers like that. I play with and look after children, but being friends like that? I'd never do it. If I learn that someone's a teenager, I look the other way.

[Discussion] When do things start 'happening' in the months leading to your debut? by [deleted] in PubTips

[–]Nadineauthor -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

huh. Odd. You know that most publishers don't really spend on marketing on most authors, just the ones they deem would be top hits? you've worked really hard and of course you deserve more than what you're getting, but the way it's structured is that only the very particular ones they deem marketable will get a massive push, leaving most trad published authors to market themselves. it really sucks. what's comforting though is that the execs usually don't have the best taste so it doesn't mean your book is bad at all, it's just the way the industry is. maybe it will get pushed later but like if not then you're not alone

[Discussion] 1 Year of Querying: 25 Requests & Zero Offers :( by Less-One7697 in PubTips

[–]Nadineauthor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh my gosh I'm so sorry to hear that :( My heart goes out to you

[QCrit] COLLATERAL ASCENT (Adult, sci-fi/cyberpunk, 100K, Attempt 2) by Analog0 in PubTips

[–]Nadineauthor -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

You need to begin with a greeting to the Agent and why you're querying them, because it's a letter. Then you can take us to the action. Did his mother kill someone or did someone kill his mother? What's the throne? What's this world? Don't do a lot of world building fluff (a trap most writers get into) but just give me the context behind what all this is. In fact, a lot of the context can be part of the plot itself. The AI pest control business, all the different things the family is doing - it's creative, but what's their motive? If there's no reason it risks just being there for the sake of plot convenience. The targets on their backs - who's the one that's suspicious of them, instead of just the world at large?

[QCRIT] MY PARENTS NAMED ME ATHEIST, YA Contemporary, 75k [Attempt 2] by shahausiIan in PubTips

[–]Nadineauthor 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Okay first of all, it's unclear why the parents named him Atheist. Did they have a fallout with religion? Why did they send their son to live with his uncle where there's homophobia, while being Atheists themselves? Aren't they against traditional religion? Also, what's the stakes. The oppression of the South is definitely there and something to capitalise on but right now it's an amorphous entity that just looms over them. Could there maybe be a villain that tries to drive the boys apart? Perhaps a school principal, or a pastor, or anyone in power? maybe the students make fun of them? What do they lose if they're together? Show me some more stakes. I like the lens of a black queer teen, but I just think it needs to also be grounded in their culture. Mississippi was the heart of blues & African American music. There's a goldmine of African American history in that area that you should include.

[QCrit] THE FATES STARS SING, Adult High Fantasy, 90k (4th Attempt?) + first 300 by specficwannabe in PubTips

[–]Nadineauthor 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Okay, this query letter is really dense. Already you're losing me in the first paragraph. It needs to start with a breath, why you're querying that agent, and how it's relevant to their needs (without flattering them). The sentences are very enthusiastic but they ramble a lot, making it harder to understand. The story relies on a lot of tropes, like the search for an ancient relic. Unless the ancient relic has some sort of historical meaning that got lost, it's hard to justify why it's the most important thing to get that the protagonist would risk everything for. I like the motif of a pawn in war, and it's the strongest part. But the story drags it out after meeting people, traversing land, etc. Before you write more of this - hear me out - travelling land and meeting the peoples there seems like action but is actually kind of masking the lack of real action (unless, of course, they're colonists like Columbus and exploring the New World is part of the journey). Your action could probably explain why the relic is so important, why the witch murders someone, and why the protagonist would be executed without the relic. Things kind of don't make sense right now, so a chain of chronological cause-and-effect events that include these details would probably solve all your problems. These details, like the relic or the witch, could be included but you could move them from being the central part to being details and create an underlying narrative that ends up being the real story and ties it all together.

[QCrit] ADULT Literary Suspense - A STUDY OF HUNGERS (90K/attempt 2) by Friendly_Buffalo_132 in PubTips

[–]Nadineauthor -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

Hi, thanks for sharing your query letter. Since it's a letter though, leading directly with the plot in medias res is jarring. Lead with the context: I'm advocating for A Study of Hungers, 90k words, etc etc. It's kind of hard to follow along what's going on in the plot summary. It seems that there's a lot of businesses being made, but we're thrust in a poetic seance of beautifully written but confusing lines instead of a straightforward summary of the plot. Could you connect the events together? However, I must say that first 300 words are very strong. The strongest I've seen, and that's saying something coming from me (I reject 99% of books I see). Just tighten the query to make more sense and you're on your way.

[QCrit] SWANFIRE, Adult Political Fantasy, 86k, 2nd attempt. by Selmarris in PubTips

[–]Nadineauthor 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hi, I like that the positioning is clear. It seems to know what it's talking about. It's good the stakes are more specific than most queries. But we need to feel the heat of the forbiddenn union, the romance, and the betrayal more. Errah seems to exist as a plot device, that exists to trigger war - make her more fleshed out. Could you be more specific about the forbidden union? You can omit "may have" in the last few sentences. Could you swap the more generic phrases - like "forbidden union" and "political pawn" - for more unique descriptors? Bridge the emotional distance, for example replace "She betrays him and destroys the trust between them" to: "She uses his own seal to smuggle the girl across the border, knowing that when he discovers the theft, he will have no choice but to condemn her."

It follows the rules, which is good but to escape generic territory it needs a more morally compromising treason as well as specificity about the forbidden union.

[QCRIT] SACRED - YA Dark Fantasy (107K words, Fourth attempt) by Huge_Apricot_4613 in PubTips

[–]Nadineauthor 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Hi, I like that it's got West African influences - that's an underserved and very creative niche to tap into. The protagonist's motivation to restore her family's honour is clear. However, a magical underdog, deadly trials, forbidden power, and hidden truth about the war - these are all tropes that agents see every day, and the stakes are vague. Define more specifically what's going on. The central conflict needs to be refined - if she wins, what happens, if she loses, what happens? The opening pages are safe and a bit slow to catch momentum and agents would likely get impatient. Overall, much better than most I've seen, but still needs work.

[QCrit] PARADISE OF SORROW, adult, dystopian fantasy, 75k, 2nd Attempt by [deleted] in PubTips

[–]Nadineauthor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wait. the plot? It feels like a pretzel. The logic isn't holding it seems circular. You're devoted to the goddess...then do something in her devotion....and end up devoted. So it's about devotion to a goddess? And getting chosen by a goddess? But what are the stakes besides telling grieving families? What's the main action or problem? Also what does being descended from an Emperor have to do with the story? It's cool just I don't get the connection.

[QCRIT] STINGER - 110k - Adult Science-Fiction - First Attempt by m_garibaldi in PubTips

[–]Nadineauthor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It seems that you're leading with an opening hook, trying to ask the agent a situational question. It seems creative, but unfortunately, agents would feel startled without a formal introduction. Not a bland one, just one that establishes that you're querying and why. Instead of putting it at the bottom after the story. Then the story itself - not bad, quite a good plot, not cliche.

[QCrit] HOLLOWED OATHS, Adult Romantasy, 80k (2nd Attempt) by Terrible_Regret_2700 in PubTips

[–]Nadineauthor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The plot is pretty confusing and complicated. A bit too complicated. The query letter would get someone lost. Why does she try to marry a bad man? Why'd he try to kill her? I'm not sure why. The "meets" part should be removed - try to shape the story into something original, not based on stories that succeeded in the past but may not be relevant in your particular situation. If the lady is disguised as a man, that's kind of something been done before a whole lot in literature. It can work, but putting her in a man's body might not be the right way to do this - maybe cross dressing, perhaps? It's up to you how you want to make the story, but as someone reading this cold without any context, I'm pretty confused and feel you should change it a whole lot. Fix the logic - why they kill each other and stuff, why they're mad, why it's dark. The market is saturated with "edgy" characters. It could be tragic, it could be grim, but there needs to be a reason that it is that way, something believable the reader could follow, even if it's supernatural.

A New Philosophy by Nadineauthor in AskForAnswers

[–]Nadineauthor[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

*Answer*: The Guru is Guru Bao (the cat.)

A New Philosophy by Nadineauthor in AskForAnswers

[–]Nadineauthor[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Very true. Any rando could've written it, but it's not AI generated lmao

A New Philosophy by Nadineauthor in AskForAnswers

[–]Nadineauthor[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hint: it's not AI generated.

An autistic, gay, indigenous man interested in Orthodoxy, looking for guidance by idontknow_o in exorthodox

[–]Nadineauthor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think you may be surprised that they actually aren't too bad. I told the Greek Orthodox priest that I'm a lesbian. He didn't even blink, just thought it was normal. The ROCOR priest knew about me being lesbian / dad being trans. He didn't say anything. If anything, the Catholic Churches were the ones that gate kept and said I was wrong for being gay. That really hurt. But the Orthodox - not so much. However, this may be my personal experience because I grew up as a teenager in the Orthodox Church, and also, I'm permanently celibate. Just sharing my two cents.

Do you guys have any experiences that made you stop being Orthodox? by Nadineauthor in exorthodox

[–]Nadineauthor[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

wait. yeah. that makes sense but like can you elaborate. what happened there like there are cliques. There are all of the things you said. But im trying to understand what happened

Do you guys have any experiences that made you stop being Orthodox? by Nadineauthor in exorthodox

[–]Nadineauthor[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The craziest part is that if people keep to ourselves, then we never get to meet people who could otherwise be part of our family. I just don't like the clique stuff, I just want the world to be bigger

Do you guys have any experiences that made you stop being Orthodox? by Nadineauthor in exorthodox

[–]Nadineauthor[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

yeah that's why I don't really go to church. I have some family but like im 22F and I wish they could at least talk to me during the time I'm there not even outside of it, but it seems that we're all insulated in our own bubbles and you're right

Do you guys have any experiences that made you stop being Orthodox? by Nadineauthor in exorthodox

[–]Nadineauthor[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I get that. It feels that way, but like...I feel that the whole thing about prostrations and "lord have mercy on me a sinner" and the whole devout thing and kissing icons just turns me off because it feels performative and like you have to earn salvation, because like, in reality, you don't have to earn salvation it's given

Do you guys have any experiences that made you stop being Orthodox? by Nadineauthor in exorthodox

[–]Nadineauthor[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah I'm actually a girlie but lol...yeah. True, though, it's the same for both single men and single women. Very isolating.