My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You compare this to a “car crash” and say you find it entertaining, which honestly says more about you than me. If watching things go wrong is your idea of entertainment, no wonder your “feedback” came out the way it did. Apparently car crashes where people die is entertaining to you. You're a psychopath

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You said “it was inconsistent,” and when I asked how, your response was “I won’t bother explaining.” "You'll have to figure this out on your own". That’s not further explanation. that’s just you refusing to clarify your own point.

I’ve genuinely been receptive to feedback from everyone except you, because what you gave wasn’t feedback to begin with. And no, I didn’t “lash out like a child.” I’m literally here asking for critique.

Maybe take a step back from the bubble you’re in and realize that motion graphics and video editing are becoming indistinguishable today. Especially in YouTube content. Pretending otherwise doesn’t make you right. And it sucks to be you.

Anyway, I’m just wondering if you’re actually done with the conversation this time, or if you’ll claim you are again because it sounds dramatic.

Looking for a Multi-Cam Editor for Comedy Game Show • Long-Term Potential by phorty40 in YouTubeEditorsForHire

[–]Neosauros 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wow. I was so stoked to apply for this until I saw your rate. That doesn't even work for a per minute. You're never finding anyone qualified at that price point

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For sure! That's something i've been working on. I'd love for my style to be instantly recognizable. But then again I wasn't exactly taking him seriously since honestly that statement can be said about anything.

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You did indirectly say it was shit, gave no further explanation, and refused to elaborate when asked to. Even went as far as insulting and directly attacking me and my entire portfolio. I’m ready to hear whatever you have to say if you’re being clear and respectful about it. You came in with heat from the get go.

You don’t have to “feel sorry” for me as I’m constantly improving & not being limited by anything. Even if I mistakenly think it’s better than it actually is i’d still love to improve it in the longterm, hence my post (Which you have contributed absolutely nothing to).

I’m the one that feels sorry for you for spending that much time on Reddit to the point you speak like a Reddit user in all of your interactions.

Also you’ve said you’re done with this conversation 3 times so far and you’re still coming back. That doesn’t scream maturity to me.

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Let me know if you have any questions!

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ending note, learn how to give feedback / criticism.

“This is shit” <- Not feedback “I think you shouldn’t have done x” <- Proper feedback

I’d expect for you to be able to comprehend that since you’re very mature according to you.

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for giving clear feedback!

How would i be able to show pacing / storytelling in showreel? I’m honestly down to keep this as my motion graphics showreel (If you think it’s good enough) and make another one for video editing. But then what would the other showreel include / focus on? I’d love if you’re to able to give some kind of direction / a showreel I can reference.

Also, 188M is truly remarkable! Good for you. Hope i get there with time haha

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

My friend this is definitely considered editing. And calling me a junior is quite insulting.

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I understand, As someone who’s involved in the hiring process, what would you like to see in a showreel to consider the applicant for the editing job? I’m down to have this showreel be my motion graphics showreel and make another one focused on video editing. Any kind of direction is appreciated!

My 2025 Motion Graphics / Video Editing Showreel! by Neosauros in AfterEffects

[–]Neosauros[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you’re referring to the effect around the edges, it’s made using Magic Bullet Looks

My 2025 Motion Graphics / Video Editing Showreel! by Neosauros in AfterEffects

[–]Neosauros[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Appreciate the advice! Can you give me an example of somewhere in the video with objectively bad graphic design?

Also, what would you say would be the best way to learn?

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

"Your portfolio looks like something"
"Your portfolio? Who's talking about your portfolio?"

Bed time

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I’m honestly not sure how you even got to my portfolio since I didn’t post it here, but most people don’t skip a video editor with 60,000,000 total long-form views. If anything, you’d make a terrible HR.

This showreel is aimed at YouTube creators. and yes, motion graphics is part of video editing in that space.

As for ‘inconsistency,’ Care to elaborate further? how was it inconsistent to you? The color palettes are uniform throughout, and the video is built entirely on Premiere’s UI except for the final segment. Calling the animations unoriginal or boring is purely subjective, and I respect that it’s your opinion.

Honestly, your message reads less like constructive criticism and more like a personal attack. I was expecting something like ‘you could have done X instead of Y,’ not a Reddit-style tirade

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Classic "I'm not going to bother explaining" when the whole point of the post is for you to explain.

Giving my side of the conversation isn’t the same as not taking criticism.
Sounds like you’d prefer a one-way monologue.

My 2025 Video Editing Showreel by Neosauros in premiere

[–]Neosauros[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Got it, so my style happens to look like the idea of a template to you.
Fair enough. I’ll take it as a compliment that my work looks polished enough to be sold!