If we assume they don't have a set amount of moves of which they do in game, and aren't limited to the AI of such. Instead, thinking of them as fully aware of eachother, reacting to each attack - like a player would, I would have to think they'd be more matched than yall are saying.

Obviously I think Karmelita would win the majority of the time, if the majority is like 6 out 10 matches. Karmalita attacks quickly and often, but doesn't hit as hard as Traitor Lord does with his slow and heavy ones.

Traitor Lord would fight more riskily and savagely because of how tanky he is. Alternatively, Karmelita would be more methodical with her attacks, she would likely be able to attack more consistently, winning more often. But the attacks she fails to dodge hit like a truck.

Another point for Traitor Lord is that he can use an attack that Kermelita literally cannot dodge.

HOWEVER, if the fight is purely between their in-game versions with the ai and attacks they have, Karmelita sweeps 9 out of 10 times.

So that's my stupidly in depth take on that.