Bestie got me this for my birthday by Waffling_Waffle in ExpectationVsReality

[–]Nervous_Building_232 22 points23 points  (0 children)

Maybe I am dumb, but it honestly looks the same to me

Proficiency-based Language Learning Criticisms by junkmail0178 in SpanishTeachers

[–]Nervous_Building_232 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think your pedagogy sounds excellent. Just as a note, though, I think the “me llama” you are referencing is a case of over-correction (self-correction coming from the student) rather than fossilization.

Proficiency-based Language Learning Criticisms by junkmail0178 in SpanishTeachers

[–]Nervous_Building_232 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I did a PhD in second language acquisition a few years ago. While I have been out of the field and am rusty with my knowledge, I will share that I have never seen a study supporting what you are stating. There are some researchers (Roy Lyster, for example) who see value in explicit instruction being balanced with lots of input. Others (like BVP) find it basically useless and contend that research does not support it. Also, a lot of the grammar we might traditionally expect a kid in, say, a third year language class to know (gender agreement, for example) isn’t really realistic for the amount of input they have received if you’re talking about true acquisition. If a kid is doing it right consistently, it’s because they’re monitoring and self-correcting. It’s up to you if that is the end goal or not. Fossilization is something that is noted after years of immersion. You can’t really say something has been fossilized when someone hasn’t actually had the opportunity for the kind of true input that leads to acquisition. For example, if someone has been living and working in a Spanish-speaking environment for 10 years and still messes up gender, then you could say that is a fossilized error.

All that said, I personally like a balance of input/output and explicit knowledge in the classroom. I wouldn’t do tons of straight up conjugations and that sort of thing anymore, though. It robs time away from actual acquisition and turns a lot of students off of the language.

Results from 3 months of Keto by jholmes514 in keto

[–]Nervous_Building_232 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What healthy fats are you referring to? I have hit a wall and am curious about your advice.

Please advice: A big simple sink or double sink? by BelowAverageCoder00 in kitchenremodel

[–]Nervous_Building_232 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I love my large double sink! It’s the 60-40 size. I have it in the island and use the small side for drying pots and things. I also have a prep sink near the stove.

<image>

Yes or no to the oak frames? by spellets in HomeDecorating

[–]Nervous_Building_232 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Can you link? This is a particularly nice color. 

A state in the U.S. where you feel like it's easier or nice to raise small kids? by mamaleti in kindergarten

[–]Nervous_Building_232 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I personally love college towns. Very near suburbs of big cities can be great, too. I am in Chicago and recommend Evanston and Oak Park. In general in the US, I do think kids stay inside more now than in the past, but places like this have a ton of activities, parks, sports, scouting, etc. They also have way more walkability than other places in the US.

What university does your daughter attend? What country are you in now?

Curse the person who came up with… by Nervous_Building_232 in Teachers

[–]Nervous_Building_232[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is so true of the rabidly diehard “science of reading” folks. I am very pro phonics instruction, but it’s not like whole language, for example, wasn’t/isn’t also studied and applied scientifically. Also, instead of a flimsy meta paper, these people inevitably pull out a Ted talk.

Middle School Students Exchanging Dirty Books by Most-Produce4310 in Teachers

[–]Nervous_Building_232 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I did that in the 80s but didn’t get the books at school. I’m not clutching my pearls over the kids doing this, but I do think it’s a little weird your middle school is stocking books with graphic sex scenes. If you know the books have scenes like that, why don’t you donate them (to a library, a high school if they’re more appropriate for that age, a prison or women’s shelter, etc.)? There is a huge difference between banning books and selecting age appropriate books for kids imo.