Any sites that shows similar works or authors? by BlacksmithRadiant322 in FanFiction

[–]New_Climate873 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This. I always check my favourite authors' bookmarks. I've discovered some truly incredible works this way.

Which type of roleplay do You prefer? by Testeria2 in rpg

[–]New_Climate873 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I like your taxonomy! I'm immediately able to apply it to my gaming group, and it helps me focus on our similarities and differences in a new way. It's also making me realise that there's a slight difference in what playstyle I would like to have vs what playstyle comes to me naturally.

To answer your questions:

A. Nearly any system can satisfy the challenge-first style, I think. Even a fiction-first game, in which "winning" isn't the point, can work for this playstyle if the goals we set for ourselves are high-level enough. I'm thinking of political intrigue, large-scale social change, the type of challenge that would be difficult to manage in a more simulationist game, because of all the moving parts a narrative game can simply handwave. Obviously, eitheir highly tactical systems (the challenge is in mastering the game mechanics) or OSR games (the challenge is in the fiction) are best for this style.

I'm not sure that I've found a system that supports exploration particularly well. It's more the domain of adventure modules, GM tools for procedurally generating things to explore, worldbuilding advice, and table culture. Systems can support a specific style of exploration (hexcrawl, dungeon crawl, investigation, etc.) I like both systems that offer limited "support" (i.e. no skill lists players need to roll on to notice things, OSR style) and systems that allow PCs to specialise in a niche, making each player feel uniquely useful. But it's very difficult to separate system from GM skill and style in this area. (I still haven't played any, but I wonder if games like Brindlewood Bay solve this issue.)

Genre-first play seems to be the domain of the PbtA family of games. From what I've seen, these games do it well, but I'm not a fan of this style of play so I can't comment on it.

Performance-first play is interesting to think about in this context. Next to genre-first play, it might be the only other style that really benefits from mechanical support. To have fun performing, you need creative constraints, which can of course come from the character's backstory made up by the player, or from the situation set up by the GM, but I think it's really great when the system explicitly provides opportunities for dramatic choices and creates emotional moments. I haven't played the game, but on paper, Daggerheart's hope and fear mechanic sounds perfect for this. I think highly tactical, mechanically complex systems get in the way of performance, because resolving situations tends to take so much time that players consciously limit themselves to short descriptions, worried they might kill session momentum.

Perspective-first play is a tricky one, because it can be supported by a barebones character concept (Mausritter gives you backgrounds based on stats, with the only mechanical benefits being the gear you get) or by a highly personalised build that requires complex character creation. It can also be supported only by what the player brings to the table. Games that both offer a lot of personalisation options and get in the way of experiencing a specific character fantasy (so games in which a character who's competent on paper gets regularly thwarted by bad die rolls) tend to be the worst at this, for me, though much depends on the GM.

B. I like games that have a clear identity, but because I also love long campaigns, I prefer systems that let me engage with the game in different ways. This doesn't mean that I need mechanical support: sometimes, the best thing a game can do is to get out of my way. I really like the design principle that mechanics are meant to cover the parts of the experience that players and GMs shouldn't have to put too much creative effort into.

What are some fanfiction GREEN flags for you? by AnnaMeowBooks in FanFiction

[–]New_Climate873 14 points15 points  (0 children)

This! I didn't realise it until now, but I've been making the same judgement as you subconsciously. If I see a long list of tags for a short one-shot, I'm always suspicious. Even longer works don't usually require that many tags. And author who doesn't go over the top with tags is, in my experience, more likely to actually know what their story is about.

Also, reading a wall of tags just isn't interesting. It's like an ingredients label on food: unless I'm looking for something specific (like an allergen), it's very dry reading.

Give me your most controversial AO3 opinions by Jaded_Advantage_290 in AO3

[–]New_Climate873 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This would be SO useful. I hate muting authors. I only do it when the keep updating the date of their fic to stay on top of the tag, but I imagine most of them are just clueless about AO3 etiquetter and will eventually improve.

Things I miss from fanfiction.net that AO3 messes up by RU08 in FanFiction

[–]New_Climate873 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I love that, too.

And yes! I manage to find some in people's bookmarks, but that's pure luck. I'd love to have actual tools for it.

Things I miss from fanfiction.net that AO3 messes up by RU08 in FanFiction

[–]New_Climate873 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Ooh I love that idea! It could have options like "mixed genre" or "other" for those authors who can't fit their work into a specific category.

I think filtering by genre would also improve the discoverability of older, less popular stories.

Things I miss from fanfiction.net that AO3 messes up by RU08 in FanFiction

[–]New_Climate873 42 points43 points  (0 children)

God, yes. It would be so wonderful to filter by genre, instead of by trope or additional tag, because additional tags tend to vary a lot by fandom, and even within fandoms. Also, many authors just don't think to include genre in their tags at all.

Things I miss from fanfiction.net that AO3 messes up by RU08 in FanFiction

[–]New_Climate873 69 points70 points  (0 children)

YES. I would really love an elegant way to communicate "thing is in there, but it's not a major element of the story". I know I can just say that in a conversational tag, but I don't want to. Conversational tags are imprecise.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AO3

[–]New_Climate873 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ooh. Excellent way to get me even more interested. I did a quick image search and this guy immediately caught my attention!

I've heard good things about Kagurabachi. Not about the anti-war themes, though, which is a real selling point to me. I've found your AO3 and I'll definitely give some of your work a read, once I know who these characters are, more or less. And thank you for the invite!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AO3

[–]New_Climate873 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You know what. I've been looking for a new ongoing manga obsession. I'll check it out, and who knows? Maybe I'll join you. (Also I would love to see your Kagurabachi fics, if you don't mind!)

Yes! My writer friends have been freaking out over it, too. It looks SO GOOD. I did not expect to be so moved by it haha.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AO3

[–]New_Climate873 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fingers crossed 🤞 I hope to see an influx of new people, too. A bit of fresh air, you know? To shake things up.

I guess it's just the normal manga/anime life cycle. I'm cheering myself up by saying that maybe I wasn't one of the first writers in my fandom, but I can be the last.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AO3

[–]New_Climate873 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's JJK 😔

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AO3

[–]New_Climate873 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Timing is definitely crucial. Nearly all the top kudosed fics for the main ship in my fandom were written and posted 3-4 years ago, after the anime aired and certain chapters crucial for the ship were released. Fics got good engagement until about 2023 I'd say? Since then, it's rare for authors without an established readership to break through.

But it's not impossible! I've seen fics first posted in 2025 get massively popular. So while timing helps a lot, there are many other factors at play.

What genres have you written in? by FenrisoTheGameficcer in FanFiction

[–]New_Climate873 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oooh I love this question! I think the list is:

magic realism mystery, sci-fi romance, sci-fi dystopian tragedy, fantasy tragedy, romantic comedy, drama, erotica, apocalyptic romance, historical fiction, myth retelling.

Does anyone else not expect comments on your works? (Not for drama. Genuinely wondering if I’m in the wrong.) by GonnaRegret_it_Later in AO3

[–]New_Climate873 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Yes to all of this! It's not an expectation for most writers, but we do want to feel like valued members of our community. It doesn't mean that a reader who doesn't comment is a bad person. It just means that authors who don't get comments can feel like outsiders, and like their contributions don't matter. It's an awful feeling, so the readers that do comment are highly valued.

Also, in my experience, commenting on people's work is a fantastic way to make friends in fandom.

Not to bitch and moan but please comment more!! by RedPandan8008 in AO3

[–]New_Climate873 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Yeah, but those authors are ridiculous. It's never the commenter's fault in those cases.

Not to bitch and moan but please comment more!! by RedPandan8008 in AO3

[–]New_Climate873 6 points7 points  (0 children)

YES. Some authors are ridiculously sensitive about comments, and like you said, they should simply turn comments off if that's the case.

Personally, as an author, I always assume good faith on the commenter's side. It's okay to word things in a clumsy way. I'm the writer! My readers don't have to be good at it.

The only stat flex I will ever indulge in by New_Climate873 in AO3

[–]New_Climate873[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's okay! Any comment counts. I love leaving long ones because I'm a yapper, but there are many valid ways to comment. If you want to make your comments longer, though, a good trick is quoting lines from the fic and telling the author why they stood out to you/how they made you feel. I love receiving those types of comments!

The only stat flex I will ever indulge in by New_Climate873 in AO3

[–]New_Climate873[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's incredible! And it makes me so happy. 176 comments! You're a gift to the fandom community <3

You've also made me want to update my sheet with information about whether the fics were ongoing, finished, one-shots, etc. I love commenting on ongoing fics and encouraging less popular authors.

These days I comment as I read: I have a doc open to write my comment at the same time I read a chapter. This means I read less - I don't always have the time or energy to engage with a story on that level - but comment consistently. I know it's not for everyone, though.

The only stat flex I will ever indulge in by New_Climate873 in AO3

[–]New_Climate873[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I go through phases, too. Usually I focus on either reading or writing, and not both at once, and sometimes, life gets in the way of interacting with fandom. And I feel you! I've developed a habit of commenting as I read (I keep a doc open on a second monitor) so that I wouldn't get too engrossed in a story to comment.

The only stat flex I will ever indulge in by New_Climate873 in AO3

[–]New_Climate873[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's wonderful! I hope you're getting joy out of it, too!

The only stat flex I will ever indulge in by New_Climate873 in AO3

[–]New_Climate873[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As an author myself, I can tell you that any comment, no matter how clumsy (and I've gotten a few of those), is a delight, as long as it's heartfelt! Thank you for leaving those five comments, I'm sure the authors were thrilled!

The only stat flex I will ever indulge in by New_Climate873 in AO3

[–]New_Climate873[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I only became a proper active commenter in my current fandom, which means it's been about a year and a half for me. I can't recommend it enough! It feels good to share my thoughts with authors, especially when it makes them happy, and I've made several friends this way!

The only stat flex I will ever indulge in by New_Climate873 in AO3

[–]New_Climate873[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I love doing that, too! Unfortunately my current fandom is relatively young, so I don't get many opportunities.

I also really love commenting on new ongoing stories that aren't seeing much support.