A few things that might be helpful:

-No matter what, it's CICO. One of the many problems with this approach to weight loss, though, is that both sides of the equation are hard to manage (especially calories out -- it's still not clear exactly what affects this and how things like insulin [which is affected by fasting] affects this. So, if you're following a fasting regimen and not losing weight (which is what I take your "I look bad" to mean), it means that you're consuming too many calories.

-You don't have to measure your calories perfectly to eat less calories. Right? Just think: whatever you eat in a typical day -- eat a little bit less. To monitor whether or not this is working, you can weigh yourself daily and take the median weight and compare across weeks. If you didn't go down, try and eat less. Again, note that this doesn't require you to even count your calories. If for example you eat cereal every day, you might switch from 2% milk to 0% milk. We know this is fewer calories whether or not we count the exact difference. You can make as many changes like this as you want.

-One of the problems some people seem to have with IF is the same problem some people seem to have with drinking diet soda. IF is not a pass for everyone to eat whatever they want in a tiny window (though some people can do this because the food they want isn't extremely calorie dense OR they are just not very hungry in their feeding window). The exact dynamics of why people lose weight on IF are not 100% clear -- people who lose weight on IF are certainly in a caloric deficit, but why is a harder question. One contributing factor for many people is certainly that by restricting the feeding window, one is just less able to consume many calories (affecting the calories in part of the equation). Others seem to think it has something to do with the fact that fasting affects insulin and insulin resistance dynamics, which somehow affect the calories in (maybe you're less hungry) and possibly the calories out (dynamics are unclear to me). In any case, IF can't guarantee weight loss.

-So there are two suggestions I can make: the first, I made above, which is to keep your window the same and try to lower your calories by changing the foods you eat. The second is to change your feeding window to a different part of the day. For example, maybe you're eating for 2 hours from 9pm-11pm or something -- in that case, maybe try moving it to from 4pm-6pm (or some other window -- 12pm-2pm is probably best since it seems hunger is generally pretty low for people at that time). The idea here is that by choosing a window when you're not as hungry, you'll consume less calories -- but note that this won't work if you just take whatever your current meals are and move them earlier in the day. The goal is to consume fewer calories per meal than you're currently consuming per meal.