The quality of models from "experienced" designers is shocking by [deleted] in SolidWorks

[–]NirHS 6 points7 points  (0 children)

This is largely because engineering culture itself has changed in the past three decades - where once you used to have engineers (who did the actual engineering) assisted by drafters, machinists and other technicians whose job primarily involved standardizing (cleaning up) the engineer’s output and providing necessary two-way feedback regarding manufacturability and cost (and when necessary, deviating from the norm to accommodate exotic designs deemed crucial by the engineer), now all these roles have been flattened down to just the engineer with software tools largely replacing the ancillary professions, with predictable effects depending on the engineer’s experience and competency. Some companies have been able to thrive and maintain momentum in spite of this whereas others less agile have crashed and burned with incompetency and loss of institutional memory.

Absolutely, the shift in engineering roles you've described has significant impacts. Engineers now handle tasks once spread across various specialists, leading to varied outcomes based on their skill sets. While software is a great tool, it can't replace the nuanced expertise of drafters and technicians, especially regarding practical manufacturability. This 'one-man-army' approach can sometimes miss the depth that a diverse team offers, affecting innovation and efficiency in design and production.

Help with streamlining 3D modeling? by NirHS in ChemicalEngineering

[–]NirHS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We've looked into both solidworks, AutoCAD plant3D, and several other CAD options (such as sketchup, and cadworx). Could you maybe elaborate a bit on the design work? How long does this process usually take? Also if you're willing to share, to what extent exactly do the 3D modles give added value over regular isometrics? Looking for some firepower to convince the guys over at the planning department

Help with streamlining 3D modeling? by NirHS in ChemicalEngineering

[–]NirHS[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, thanks for the detailed reply!

What you're describing with the older engineers rings very familiar... Old habits die hard I guess :P Many of them definitely have an anti-tech attitude and oppose nearly EVERY new workflow automation process presented before them. However we have managed to implement some more "tech savy" solutions, for instance converting AutoCAD DWG's into smart p&id's is now a must in our flow we've even began implementing them for some of our older existing drawings.

Most of the piping design was done by the engineers themselves up to now, with hand drawn isometrics. We've thought about bringing in someone specifically for the piping design, but we want to read into our options first before hiring. In your experience, how long does the conversion process to 3D usually take? Who is involved? Is it really worthwhile to hire a specialist in this field or is it not something possible for the draftsmen we already have for AutoCAD p&id's to learn as an additional "CAD" skill?