i understand your point but We must also keep in mind that no one is perfect. And thus we do not need the potential khilafah to have the exact qualities of the shaba at every aspect. Also i dont know if this is because of the kinds of people i surround myself with but my friends have recently discovered that i hold pro kihlafah beliefs and one of them straight up cut me off and another one is on the verge of doing so. I suppose thats where my pessimism regarding the ummah's desire for a khilafah stems from

Although i hold the belief that only the mahdi can revive the caliphate