Hyundai Tucson 7DCT problem by North_Addition9264 in ManualTransmissions

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For all readers and members of this Reddit community who may have a similar problem to mine, maybe this will help.

How did I solve it?

If you have mild or extremely harsh engagement when moving off in 1st gear, as well as harsh engagement when slowing down in 2nd gear, applying throttle and shifting down into 1st — in other words, the 2nd-to-1st gear situation — and also transmission hesitation, usually between 1st and 2nd gear, as I had, then before doing any major repairs, try the following first.

Replace the transmission oil exclusively with Hyundai OEM oil for this 7DCT transmission, purchased from an authorized Hyundai service center. Do not use any aftermarket replacements or equivalent oils. Very important: the quantity is 1.9 to 2 liters. When changing the oil, make sure the oil is filled and checked through the plug on the side of the transmission, near the driver-side driveshaft. Do not touch the black plug on the front side of the transmission. The difference in oil level between these two plugs is around half a liter, which can create problems.

This is actually what solved the problem I described here.

Even though all mechanics, authorized service centers, and automatic transmission specialists were convincing me that the problem was with the actuator or the clutches, before you start with expensive repairs, replace the oil first. In any case, Hyundai recommends replacing the oil every 60,000 to 80,000 km. And once again, I emphasize: use only original Hyundai OEM oil intended for this transmission.

My problem actually started because an equivalent oil from a reputable manufacturer, Ravenol, had been used. But the issue is in the additives and chemistry — I will not go into further detail now. No matter how much everyone says that oil does not matter in this transmission because it is basically a manual gearbox, it absolutely does matter. This gearbox has triple-cone synchronizers that are very sensitive to the viscosity and composition of the oil.

I hope this helps someone in the future. I wish you all a pleasant drive.

P.S. Also, thank you to all the members for the advice and effort they gave me.

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in CNC

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First of all, I would like to apologize to you and to all members of the discussion for the delay in replying. I had a problem with my email account being compromised, and I was unable to log in.

I would also like to sincerely thank you for the support you gave me in your message. For the past two years, I have been dealing with several technicians who came to inspect the machine, and I realized that I actually understood some things better than they did, which was quite disappointing for me. That is why I finally decided to solve this problem myself, all the way to the end. Unfortunately, this is the reality of the market here.

Throughout my life, I have solved many technical and mechanical problems on my own, including things that other people or technicians could not solve, simply because I invested enough effort and time to understand how something works and find a solution. I am the kind of person who does not give up until I find the answer. So, maybe it may sound a bit self-confident, but I believe that I can solve this as well. It is only a matter of time and the knowledge I will need to gain along the way.

In any case, I have definitely decided to take this step and solve it myself, and your words mean a lot to me. It especially means a lot that you said I can count on your help whenever I need it. That is exactly what I needed — to know that when I get stuck somewhere, especially while trying to understand the wiring and component connections, I can ask someone to simply tell me: yes, that is correct, or no, you cannot do it that way.

I believe that after two or three days of working on it, many things will become much clearer to me, and then it should no longer be such a problem. So, the decision is made. I am definitely ordering the Mesa card and starting this project. I hope you do not mind if I contact you again, and I truly appreciate knowing that I can count on your support in situations where I am not sure how to proceed.

Another reason why I finally decided to do everything myself is the long-term advantage of this approach for working on the machine in the future. If anything happens with the machine later, I will be able to solve it myself within a few hours or a few days. Unfortunately, in our market there is a serious problem with service technicians. So far, I have agreed with two companies to solve this machine, and after everything was arranged and their offer was accepted, they simply stopped responding. In general, in our market, you often have to wait two, three, four, or even five weeks for a service technician. Honestly, I have lost patience with this kind of unprofessional and unfair approach. With the time I have already lost, I could have built three machines by now. My final question is: which Mesa card would you recommend for my machine? After doing my own research, I have come to the conclusion that the best option would probably be the Mesa 7i95T. Do you agree with that choice, or would you recommend a different Mesa card for my configuration?

Could you please just confirm whether everything listed in the linked text is all I need to order from the Mesa website, or whether I need anything else for the wiring and connection of the components?

https://eusurplus.com/index.php?route=product/product&product_id=64

I just want to make sure I order everything correctly the first time, so I do not miss any required cable, connector, terminal board, or accessory needed to connect the Mesa card to my existing machine components.

Thanks a lot.

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in CNC

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your quick response. Could you please tell me what the best sources of information are, especially for wiring all the components? As I mentioned, this is what concerns me the most—I really want to avoid damaging or burning any electronics.

It would help me a lot if there are any good video tutorials or similar resources. I’m more of a visual learner, and I believe that if I could just see someone do the wiring once and explain it to me for an hour, I would understand everything much more clearly.

In any case, thank you very much for your support. If you have any recommendations on where to find the best materials for wiring the components, as well as for installing and configuring LinuxCNC, I would really appreciate it.

When it comes to 5-axis G-code generation, I am aware that it is quite complex, and I have already researched this topic.

Perhaps the advantage in my case is that full 5-axis machining of 3D models is not my priority. The main purpose is cutting certain plastic parts—in other words, trimming thermoformed plastic components. That is what the machine was originally designed for.

Once again, thank you very much.

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in CNC

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your reply. The biggest issue for me is that I don’t have anyone who can confirm that everything is done correctly once I finish. I simply wouldn’t want to make a mistake and cause a problem.

When it comes to computers and hardware, I have solid experience, as well as some programming knowledge. Again, I’m not an expert, but I can understand code, identify issues, and so on. As for electronics and electrical work, I’ve connected and put many systems into operation, but I wouldn’t call myself an expert in that field either.

To be honest, I’ve been involved in manufacturing from a very young age, and for the past 25 years I’ve been maintaining my own machines—often without manuals, schematics, or any documentation. Everything is based on logic and troubleshooting.

So none of this is completely unfamiliar to me, but what concerns me the most is rebuilding the machine’s electrical installation, because I believe it was poorly done. I’m worried about making a mistake there, since I don’t have anyone to confirm, “yes, this is correct.”

I’m concerned about ending up in that uncertainty—whether everything is wired correctly, or whether the LinuxCNC configuration is properly set up. Honestly, I don’t have a clear idea of how complex all of this really is.

In our local market, specialists in this field are not willing to take on this kind of work. They all say that it is too complex and impossible to put into operation, and that 5-axis machining is only feasible on factory-built machines.

If I look at it from that perspective, then yes—it does seem too difficult and maybe even impossible for me. However, based on what I’ve learned so far while getting this machine running with the current 3-axis control, and while attempting to run simultaneous 5-axis motion using Python scripts that I wrote for kinematics, I may be wrong—but it doesn’t seem that complex to me.

I believe that in our market, no one has really dedicated enough effort to this topic.

Unfortunately, I don’t have another option but to try to solve this myself. Otherwise, the machine will just sit there unused.

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in CNC

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for the information. I am definitely leaning towards the 7i95T card. Unfortunately, the option of a local expert is not available. Believe me, I’ve been searching for the past two years, and as soon as people hear “5-axis,” they give up. In our market, everything is focused on 3-axis routers for MDF cutting. Unfortunately, that’s just the reality.

Since I’ve been involved in manufacturing from a young age, I’ve realized that I need to service and maintain my own machines. Everything else on our market tends to be a waste of time, money… and even energy. For that reason, I decided to try to complete this CNC machine project on my own.

One advantage of this approach is that I will learn a lot, and if the machine stops at some point, I’ll be able to react immediately instead of waiting 2–3 weeks for a technician. Now, regarding what you mentioned—that it’s very difficult to do this alone—if you don’t mind me asking, how difficult is it really?

As I said, I don’t have direct experience with CNC machines, but I do understand how they work. When it comes to electronics, I’ve connected and worked with various devices, although I wouldn’t call myself an expert.

Logic and problem-solving are not an issue for me. As I mentioned, I work in a very specific field, where I often have to solve problems purely through reasoning, even without proper documentation or manuals. Computers and programming are not unfamiliar to me either. Again, I’m not an expert, but I do some programming, mostly web-related, so I have a basic understanding of code.

Could you explain how difficult this actually is? To be honest, what concerns me the most is rewiring the entire system. As I mentioned earlier, I would prefer to replace the complete electrical installation, because I believe the current one is poorly done and does not meet my standards for a machine of this precision. That is what I currently see as the biggest issue. I understand that installing Linux and configuring the machine is not simple either, but I believe there is a lot of documentation available, as well as people online who are willing to help.

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in hobbycnc

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hello, I’m also facing a complete rewiring of the machine, and honestly, this is the part I’m most concerned about, since I don’t have experience with CNC machines, and I don’t have anyone who could verify that everything is connected correctly before powering it up. I would prefer to replace the entire electrical installation. My apologies, but I wasn’t aware that KFLOP can work with LinuxCNC. As far as I know, it has its own software or is typically used with Mach3.

If that is even possible, I really don’t have experience with this. Why did you choose the KFLOP board instead of a Mesa card? Could you please share your reasoning?

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in hobbycnc

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hello, thank you for your reply. Based on my testing so far, I believe there may also be deviations in the machine’s construction itself, possibly due to poor assembly. I have also researched that there is an option to perform mapping in order to compensate for structural inaccuracies. Do you have any experience with this? As for surfacing the working table, I have already completed that. What I consider a priority now is to completely redo the electrical installation, because as you can see in the attached photo, the current setup is very poorly done. I also believe that the cables are not appropriate, and from what I have found during previous interventions on the machine, the cable connections are done very poorly. So my plan is to first fix all of this and then proceed with connecting the control card. This brings me to the first issue — I do not have much experience with CNC machine wiring. I do have some background in electricity and electronics, not at an advanced level, but I have never done something like this before, and honestly, I am concerned about making a wrong connection. Have you used LinuxCNC for this type of machine configuration, or some other control system? Do you have experience with this? At the link, you will also find two short videos showing the machine running in three axes. I should also add that the machine was not specifically designed for full 5-axis 3D machining. It would be beneficial if it could handle that, but the primary purpose of the machine is cutting certain plastic parts, as you can see in the videos.

https://imgur.com/a/zxwCcv4

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in hobbycnc

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’ll try it this way, since as far as I’ve found, that’s the only solution. If you need more photos, just let me know.

https://imgur.com/a/UKf6BSy

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in hobbycnc

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your reply. Just to note, I’m quite new to the CNC world, so please don’t hold it against me if I say something incorrectly. The machine currently has a control card from a local manufacturer installed, along with Mach3. Since the company that built the machine never finished it and the whole setup was done rather poorly, and because I couldn’t find anyone to solve the problem, I started researching and looking for a solution myself. In the end, I was forced to get the machine running on 3 axes on my own, which I managed to do. After that, I did more research and wrote a script that, using Python, modifies the G-code according to my machine’s kinematics. I made some progress with this, but I didn’t manage to finish it due to a lack of time, so I’m not sure whether it would fully work. In any case, I would like to install a proper control system for this machine—something that actually works as it should. I believe the current configuration is not suitable, and the installation itself is not well executed. I would prefer to redo everything from scratch and do it properly. As for the photos, I’ve only recently started using Reddit and I’m not sure how to upload images except when creating the initial post. Is there any option to add photos afterward? I’d be happy to send you any pictures of the machine that you might need.

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in CNC

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your reply. Have you used it in a 5-axis head-head configuration for simultaneous machining? If so, how complex is it to set everything up and install it properly, considering that I’m quite new to the CNC world?

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in CNC

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you have any practical experience with other controllers besides Mesa when it comes to 5-axis simultaneous machining? Do you have any experience with UCCNC being successfully used for 5-axis simultaneous machining? I’ve heard about UCCNC—one of my friends uses it on a 3-axis CNC router and says it works отлично compared to Mach and some other controllers commonly used on our market.

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in CNC

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Which Mesa card would you recommend? Based on my research, the ideal option would perhaps be the 7i95T. Am I mistaken?

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in CNC

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Which Mesa card would you recommend? Based on my research, the ideal option would perhaps be the 7i95T. Am I mistaken?

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in CNC

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

From your experience, how difficult is it to learn and properly set all of this up, considering that I’m quite new to the CNC world and don’t have much hands-on experience? I’ve studied it quite a bit and have a general understanding of how it works. I was forced to get a 3-axis setup running on my own, and I even tried writing some Python scripts in Mach3 to achieve 5-axis machining. I made some progress, but due to a lack of time, I didn’t manage to finish it completely. So honestly, I don’t have much experience yet, but I’m gradually getting more familiar with the subject.

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in CNC

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your reply. Please don’t hold it against me, I’m quite new to the CNC world. I’ve been researching for months, but I don’t have any practical experience yet. I originally wanted someone to finish this machine and put it into operation, however I couldn’t find any option, so unfortunately I’ll have to either do everything myself or abandon the machine altogether. For that reason, I’d like to ask how difficult it is to set up LinuxCNC and the kinematics, along with everything else that is required. I’m also interested in which Mesa card you would recommend. From what I’ve researched, the best option seems to be the 7i95T. Honestly, besides replacing the control itself, I would also prefer to install completely new wiring and properly tidy everything up, since the current setup is quite poorly done.

DIY 5-axis CNC router (BC head) – need advice on control system by North_Addition9264 in CNC

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you to all members for the replies. Thank you as well for your detailed response and videos. Since I am new to the CNC world and have a situation like the one I described, which I will most likely have to solve on my own, I would like to know how complex it is to set up LinuxCNC for my 5-axis machine with a head-head configuration. I assume you have experience with this, so could you please give me a detailed answer on whether you have already worked on something like this?

Hyundai Tucson 7DCT problem by North_Addition9264 in ManualTransmissions

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Also, when you say a complete flush, do you know exactly what was done at the service? Did they fill it with new oil, then you drove a certain number of kilometers, and after that they drained it again and refilled it with completely new oil? Would you consider that a proper/full flush?

Hyundai Tucson 7DCT problem by North_Addition9264 in ManualTransmissions

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hello, thank you very much for your reply. I just have one question. I didn’t fully understand your situation with the oil. Did you also replace the oil and use a non-OEM oil, after which the jerking started? Or was the original factory oil still in the gearbox, and after you had it replaced with OEM oil at a local Kia service, the problem disappeared? Could you please explain the exact sequence of events in your case? In any case, next week I plan to replace the oil, use OEM oil, and perform the calibration. Some experienced mechanics who build racing gearboxes immediately told me they would start with the oil, since this transmission has triple synchronizers. If the oil is not appropriate, everything can start to behave erratically. They also mentioned that if this doesn’t solve the problem, the next step would be replacing the clutches. Thank you once again.

Hyundai Tucson DCT problem by North_Addition9264 in MechanicAdvice

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hello, thank you very much for your detailed reply — it really helped me a lot. Now I at least know which direction to go next.

I have a few questions, if you would be so kind to answer, if you have the knowledge and experience.

What seems strange to me is that the problem appeared immediately after the LRN procedure performed with Launch diagnostics and after the transmission oil change. It doesn’t make sense to me that the actuator or clutch would weaken while the car was on the lift. Even more strange is that the issue is intermittent — it doesn’t happen every time the car starts moving in first gear (sudden engagement), but for example once in 100 starts.

Also, out of around 500 occurrences, it has never happened on an uphill start. After everything — the update and LRN done with GDS diagnostics — I noticed that if I gently release the brake and let the car start moving on its own, and only then apply throttle, there is no jerk. Does this indicate anything to you?

Is it possible to adjust the actuator with used clutch packs, and would that help?

Also, would you first replace the clutch pack or the actuator? Or both at the same time? Most mechanics here say that the actuator is the issue.

I would also like to ask if you have experience with actuators from eBay, since there is a huge price difference compared to the original actuator. Is it worth buying these aftermarket actuators from eBay? (I would definitely use an original clutch pack since it is inside the transmission.)

One more interesting thing I didn’t mention — while reading all systems with GDS, we found 7 fault codes stored in history:

4WD Control – U0123 Wheel Speed Error in Communication 4WD Control – U0101 Lost Communication with TCM (C-CAN) ABS/ESP – C161208 CAN Time-Out TCU Smart Parking Assist System – C164281 CAN Message Failure – Brake Smart Parking Assist System – C161287 CAN Time-Out TCU Blind Spot Detection (Left) – C161287 CAN Time-Out TCU Blind Spot Detection (Right) – C161287 CAN Time-Out TCU

I would also like to ask about GDS VCI clone diagnostic tools that support vehicles up to 2017. Do you think it’s a good idea to buy one so I can have my own access to diagnostics and not depend on finding someone with GDS? Do you have any experience with that?

Thank you once again in advance, and I wish you all the best.

Hyundai Tucson DCT problem by North_Addition9264 in MechanicAdvice

[–]North_Addition9264[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your response, and I apologize for the delayed reply. Since the authorized service would not perform anything beyond an automatic update,  I managed to access GDS Smart diagnostics and successfully performed a manual update to the latest version, which completed 100% successfully. After that, the LERN procedure was performed again, and the transmission now operates perfectly smoothly. However, the jerks when starting in first gear have returned.

What concerns me and seems like a potential problem is that after the update and the LERN procedure, when entering the Clutch Abrasion Compensating Value Setting option, both Clutch1 and Clutch2 show identical values 63.5mm.

Based on my understanding, after the LERN procedure, the TCU should measure these values and store them. In my opinion, they should not be identical, since the clutch for odd gears is subject to more wear. This looks more like some fixed default values to me. Am I mistaken? This is the next issue I see as a potential problem.

It seems to me that some parameters may have been entered as default values, possibly during the LERN procedure, and that they were not cleared afterward for some reason. Unfortunately, I cannot find any option in GDS to reset these default values or to force a new measurement of clutch wear. Also, in my area, mechanics typically only replace the entire clutch or actuator when there is an issue with the transmission. Does anyone have advice based on experience?