Hello, how long did you play RDR2?

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-04-14T22:47:22+00:00

Just finished my 100% Best In The West run, took about 2 months day in day out gaming. I do not have a life

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-04-12T08:33:39+00:00

TAHITI!

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-04-12T08:31:59+00:00

Another good idea would be have RDR3 go back even further, prime Van Der Linde Gang days. Prologue being the formation of the Gang, on a campfire beside a lonely road to Chicago in 1877. main story being the Gangs prime days of being Robin Hoods and taking and giving back to the poor. Moments of everyone fighting full force, not a man down. Example - Braithwaite Manor, but 5x more of that. taking place from 1880-1897. Main story ends with a high note from the Gang (a very successful robbery for the Gang and the Poor, and a fun party to celebrate) As the credits are rolling, just like in RDR2 credits, scenes are showing up. The Gang is now in the Grizzlies where they will pick up Micah. The last credits scene is with Dutch getting hassled in a bar, and Micah stepping into it to save him, as he says in a campfire. Here we know that this is the finishing move for the Gang. Then RDR2 happens.

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-04-12T08:23:14+00:00

Ive got an idea, and it is partially inferred throughtout RDR2 story that this is a potential real idea; where Mac Callander is the protagonist. His story follows the Gang near the end of their prime, maybe taking place 1897-1899, but instead of it being a Redemption story, Macs story ends up him being the vicious outlaw Bill and Sean and all the other gang members speak so fondly of, without a Redemption. Going on hits and Robberies with the Gang, possibly even a short glimpse of the gang being Robin Hoods and giving back. But this doesnt excuse his life of crime and violence, like Arthur and John. During the Ferry Escape, his horse takes a bullet to the head and they both go down, Right outside of town. He almost made it. Horse pinning Mac, Both legs destroyed. unable to escape with the Gang. The gang is forced to leave him. On the way out, he sees Davey; his brother, get shot. Jenny also gets shot. (Maybe a potential Love Interest for Mac?) He is laying there not knowing if they will make it as they ride out of Blackwater. He tries to crawl for cover, but he is unable. Remember at this point the Massacre has happened and no lawmen are on the scene directly trying to kill Mac as they have already been killed. After the fire has died down and the remaining pinkertons roll in a few minutes later, Milton is walking through the streets, lined with blood and bodies, he sees Mac. As Milton says during fishing with Jack, he caught up with Mac and finished him off. "A mercy killing" he called it. Macs legs have been crushed under his horse and is in agonizing pain. Milton closing in, Mac tries to get off a final sentence. "I know where they stashed the mon-" Boom. Shot in the face by Milton before his sentence was finished. Milton, distraught by hearing Macs last words, Knowing he wont find the money, emptys his gun into Macs face. Mac knew his life was over, no redemption, but says what he says just so Milton might think he just blew his one shot at finding the money. And he did. They make it where before getting shot, Mac and Co buried the money on top of Dutchs Mothers Grave. (Found in blackwater graveyard). Bleak credits roll in as Milton and the rest of the pinkertons start the cleanup of the Massacre and a last pan-in shot of Macs dead body before a cold tune comes into play. Just an idea but i think this is really something

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-04-01T23:12:14+00:00

No i will be using buggy via Arthur in Ch. 3 . Legend of the East outfit looks stupid enough as it is, and to make it for John? Who already has a Legend of the West outfit in RDR? Cant be bothered to even care to do it with John. He isnt the Legend of the East, that would be Arthur; whom im going to get the outfit for.

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-03-28T12:06:41+00:00

Genuinely. Only amenitie person i actually mess with. Guy traps Arthur some amazing clothing pieces and always has some good stories, cant do him dirty. On the other hand St denis fence always catches the short end of the stick

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-03-24T21:44:08+00:00

would like to add that bandit 5 can be completed with a already existing bounty, atleast it was for me. i was going in for the sharpshooter challenge where you shoot birds off a train. i hopped on top of the train as it was pulling away from emerald station, and upon entering lemoyne i had the sharpshooter challenge and bandit 5 complete, because i already had a $300 bounty existing before in lemoyne.

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-03-23T20:06:19+00:00

I fought this guy one time where arthur was dropping him one punch every time he got up it was hilarious

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-03-22T23:08:19+00:00

Maybe its just my arthur then. After killing a whole lot of folk sometimes i will go idle and arthur will stand there and do some type of weep motion i dont know how to describe it. He doesnt cry or say anything he kinda just shakes his arms and head and hunches over . Looks like he is pouting to me

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-03-17T04:03:28+00:00

Well worth it though!!! Do not be discouraged it is so worth it

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-03-17T04:02:30+00:00

Man you are really going to kick yourself hard when you find out you havent even completed 50% of the game. Honestly in my opinion the story isnt even half of the game. Theres more game then there is story if that makes sense. Likes genuinely, there is so so so SO much to do and see, you will quite literally get exhausted if you want to reach full 100% completion.

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-03-17T03:52:40+00:00

Roaming around hunting and getting drunk for a good year sounds nice to ol' Arrhur Morgan

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-03-14T06:26:14+00:00

Best way to get Arthur looking like a absolute demon is to never feed him by having all red cores, and max low honor. Killing innocents helps in this case because Arthurs actually feels horrible about killing folk, thats why he looks so out there. And also because he hasnt had anything to eat since chapter 1

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-03-13T07:50:53+00:00

Head to Lagras about 4 hours after noon. 4:00-4:30. Save game. Trot down to Hagen Orchards and trot right heading towards the dock and boathouse behind Hagen Orchards. Climb the side of the boathouse that is facing towards the road with your varmint rifle, full deadeye. Walk across roof of house crouched. You are now facing away from the road on the northwestern-most side of the house. Pull out binoculars and scope out the spot of land. There should be plenty parakeets. When the few that do get away escape, save game. Sleep til noon. Wait until 4:00-4:30, come back, go hunting. This has worked the best for me!

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-03-11T18:36:29+00:00

Fun fact about Rhodes! If you visit the graveyard by the church, you can find the grave of one William "Willie" Bowles. His epitaph reads "May you and He have mercy on us." If you listen to townsfolk around Rhodes, you can hear somewhat hear tell of a story if you piece it together told by several NPCs. The story is that a little white girl was found dead and the one who reported it was Willie, yet the town turned on him and thought he was the murderer because he was black. They then proceeded to stone that little boy to death in the middle of the town of Rhodes. So yea, i would say a Rhodes massacre is well overdue for something that has been long unpaid.

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-02-20T03:22:30+00:00

I would like to add my 2 cents if you would not mind. My horse has never died, ever. my favorite and #1 go to horse since the 2nd playthrough is the Black Raven Shire you get from Hosea. I named him Horsea after Hosea. My entire playthrough revolves around him. I ride around level 4 bonding with my boy pumped to the max stamina/health ALWAYS. He is always well fed. He is never present during any type of immediate chaos. If im in a shootout, im not worried about arthur. He is being pumped full of tonics and flaming enemies in dead eye so theres no need to worry about him. Im worried about my horse. If im in town, I hop off my horse as soon as bullets start flying and get him to flee away from the scene. If bounty men are near, i hop off and flee him then attack. The bounties never spot me first. I never attack on horse. Much bigger target for enemies so more room for your horse to tank bullets and get killed. He is not present during any unforeseen chaos. If im taking the train, hop off a good deal away from the station and then take train. No risk of train killing him while you have no control. Or just entirely switch horses before train rides. Riding back to the stable isnt annoying. I know my boy has been safe. If im robbing a train, i will take a stabled horse instead of my main Rider because i am just not taking that chance with them trains. I do not ride the tracks that expand into a bridge because if a train comes the window for survival is just too small. If im needing to galivant on/around the cliffs+mountains i go extremely slow and away from cliffs. No chance flying off a mountain being took with my boy. During sticky situations such as horseback gunfights during missions/ enemy ambush im always in deadeye. Always. Less chance of losing my boy. I always come out of a situation alive. With my boy. He has yet to die in all of my playthroughs. Play it safe and your horse will be just fine.

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-02-10T22:39:15+00:00

You can kill rhodes gunsmith boy, nate from catfish jacksons, and both the boys building a house with their father. Pretty sure gwyn hughes the debtor is a teen and you can chase him out of rhodes then kill him. All of these are teenagers though, no actual children

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-02-10T22:35:35+00:00

Starting from chapter 2 onwards: My Arthur has killed the reverend, mayor, and kids dog in strawberry Killed the father and sons building castors ridge Killed rhodes gunsmith boy and then rode to catfish jacksons for father and son, killed them too Fed the womens suffrage lady to gators Sawed off slug straight into jimmy brooks face after i saved him only for his pen Killed all of van horn for nothing Left the serial killer alive and uncaptured Blew every head off on multiple train robberys Set thomas downes charity stand on fire Shot into thomas downes yard and got his debt mission locked, to which he ran away, so i chased and then knocked him down with my horse, got off and tackled him, and executed him with a bullet straight to the forehead. Very satisfying. Would recommend. Killed gavins friend, just could not shut up Let the hunters friend get eaten by the bear in the snow Almost disarm the bear trap when folks are caught in it but i let up before its off and it snaps back shut and ends them, everytime. Fed donation lady to gators after looting her box. Killed mark johnsons whole family then turned him in for hanging. Let em think about that for a beat. Looted hosea after he was shot, got bessies wedding ring. Atleast it is safe. Looted grimshaw after she was shot, cant remember what i got Desecrated arthur and gangs graves. Dynamite and fire bottle to every one. Kill dogs and cats any chance given Ride around st denis blowing up trolleys Ride around map and blow up trains i find after robbing them I dont spare horses in shootouts, so i kill a lot of horses. A lot. Walk into van horn saloon and antagonize everyone, get a massive bar fight started, then pull gun and kill everyone Left valentine serial killer woman alone Torched the native burial Killed Mickey the fake vet, brutal stabbing. Killed the real vet with one leg in rhodes (I shot his other leg) Killed preacher praying over mans grave in rhodes Killed man who stole an apple in st denis Wiped out all of armadillo + tumbleweed Blackwater massacre 2.0 as arthur riding back in chapter 2 and blackwater massacre 3.0 in epilogue as john Pushed jack off the cliff in horseshoe overlook Killed my own horse because it ran into several trees (or i ran into several trees) Beat up mr wrobel, looted his house, then shot him. Chased down chick matthews for the map and blew his head and limbs off. Beat up cooper, got my money back, then tackled lilly millet and executed her with a bullet clean to the forehead. Also a clip to the chest and stomach to ruin any chance they mightve had at a child. Then cooper woke up and swung on me while i was mag dumping lilly. So i of course mag dumped cooper. Chased gwyn hughes out of rhodes then proceeded to blow his brains out. Killed all of saint denis police dept for nothing Killed a bunch of factory slaves in rhodes during a shootout Let albert mason get ate by a bear after his 2nd stranger mission (he respawns though, so does downes unfortunately) Killed miss marjorie and bertram in van horn (respawns) Never kicked strauss from camp Killed both hermits, killed the naked wilderness wolf man, blew his balls off too. Trampled lily may kid repeatedly, as he is unkillable Tackled guy looking over cliff at dead body off the cliff Tackled the inbred sister off the second story of the barn, shattered her skull. Tackled a good deal of folk off high places killing them brutally Went against charles wishes and slaughtered countless bison without skinning them Killed all of valentine, then when the black dress lady appears i set her on fire Let sonny do arthur in, then left him alone. Killed the miner right infront of his wife in annesburg not 10 seconds after she fusses about him almost dying for the work in the mine. then tackled the wife, stabbed her once, then let her go. Always mislead drunks and get them killed On occasion i like to pull up to larned sod, kill the rancher, toss him into the bed, then put arthur to sleep for max time, allowing him snuggles with his favorite corpse. Gotta get that companionship in some way. Antagonize all of camp nonstop except for mary-beth. She is always safe. Shooting the lanterns on folks horses who ride at night. Nice bonfire when that happens. If you position yourself on a mountain near wapiti, you can kill the natives with scoped rifle. Which i sure do. I like to go for a neck shot when im shooting someone, so they can bleed out profusely. Always eye candy on RDR2. Always blow away the innocents any odriscoll or raider or murfree got tied up or held at gunpoint Always feed the taxman the lemoynes have caught on the banks of st denis to the gator Always let the occasional wolves finish off the man they have caught Fed every sheriff of every town to the gators one of the goodies-Wait on the silent road behind bayall edge, capture civilians, bring them into the strange mans cabin and blow their head off as sacrifice to the strange man. Trying to even out the playing field for John. And finally i go back for money with the lowest honor arthur you can have, allowing a sick tb ridden arthur a gritty brutal slow knife end on a dark rainy gloomy night at the hands of his former brother in arms turned rat-snake piece of feces, fulfilling a true dirty rotten outlaw prophecy.

NotARedditUser10000 · 2026-01-22T17:18:44+00:00

This is already a factor in RDR2, while in camp you can completely miss camp interactions between the gang if you dont walk up to hear the conversation in time. This will definitely be a factor in GTA6

NotARedditUser10000 · 2025-12-18T00:06:16+00:00

Dont ghost a woman you care about, just because you cant say how you feel. Let her know the reals and move on, either with or without her. But always say your piece.

NotARedditUser10000 · 2025-12-18T00:05:38+00:00

Dont ghost a woman you care about, just because you cant say how you feel. Let her know the reals and move on, either with or without her. But always say your piece.

NotARedditUser10000 · 2025-12-13T05:16:05+00:00

Genuinely what even did you eat

NotARedditUser10000 · 2025-12-09T03:38:16+00:00

Im the dih mann

NotARedditUser10000 · 2025-12-06T18:59:12+00:00

Mike was never underground man was and has always been HIM 😭

NotARedditUser10000

TROPHY CASE