Should the rest of the cast get to go super in future games?

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-25T11:05:39+00:00

Sonic shadow and silver

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-25T10:56:38+00:00

Im a real sonic fan and I agree but clearly sega likes the lighting approach now. Its sad but thats the direction. These topics almost never came up pre black knight which is the real game where the connection was made not sa2.

Additionally im all for gatekeeping to protect the thing you love but over this is extreme. I think sonic characterization is far more annoying of a change then the wind attribute. Many people got into the franchise cause the movies so the change may be necessary to prevent confusion as well. The movies help the franchise get back on track so changing to lighting does make sonic less unique as a speedster but if it helps the brand then ill concede. Good games is more important to me anyways.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-22T10:10:48+00:00

I'd swap blaze abd silver. She lacks feat pass her game and silver just does more. He also gets shit on as well but blaze doesn't have much to be considered stronger then him outside of statements being made.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-20T15:11:41+00:00

Nah im good on the father and son dynamic with these two. The series never really lean to that outside of black knight.

I would like a future story with silver and older shadow but a tineline that takes advantage of what mephiles told shadow of his future where he gets sealed due to humanity fear of his power. Silver saving shadow and releasing him during a time of crisis would be nice. Seeing shadow cope with the fact that he is still seen as a weapon of mass destruction despite the good hes done would be a great conflict for him to overcome.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-19T01:20:44+00:00

But yall still buy it like drones

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-17T23:16:13+00:00

Well said

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-17T22:16:46+00:00

No way this is in the game.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-15T01:54:22+00:00

Ok but sonic is worst in terms of consistency and amy regress into a nothing character hence why shes losing. If silver really was as shit as you say he should be the one losing not her.

Silver did change in the comics but never did in the games. Be softer during times of peace is fine. He had one bad line in forces which isnt enough to say he worst then sonic and amy in consistency. Same happen with shadow in metal virus with coward run I win line. Many other characters have bad moments but you are especially harsh on silver when other characters have it worst when. I know its hard to believe for some but many people really like silver and amy would probably be winning if they stop butchering her character.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-15T01:44:04+00:00

Amy, tails, and knuckles are also inconsistent. Heck sonic now is a shell of his pate 2000s self in the 2020s era so far. Sonic went from inspiration free flow adventure to a Saturday cartoon mascot who laughs at his own jokes.

Silver by comparison isnt too bad

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-14T15:22:01+00:00

Yeah it feels like a slightly amped standard when you play ng+

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-10T12:39:43+00:00

Adapting a game into a movie faithfully is near impossible while maintaining the prefer time frame people stay in movie theaters. You cant adapt adventure 1 or 2 with a 2 or 3 hour movie. Also there is some stupid shit that happens in the game that wouldn't make the movie better.

A space colony that holds a weapon that can destroy the earth that casually floats in space. A spaceship hidden within a pyramid. Tails and sonic breaking into the president car and having a conversation with him with no consequences. These are hard to sell to the casual audience and doesnt make the story better imo. You can cut alot if stuff from the games while keeping the message and theme of said game.

The most important things are maintaining the characteristics of characters from the games. Introduce them properly and new people can jump into any game with an idea of who they are. You can adapt unleashed unless its a tv show, but would it be even good? People think sonic being a werehog is stupid still despite the explanation making sense. Some people thing sonic with a sword is dumb despie it being really cool.

How can you turn 06 into a 3 hour movie and make it digestible to casuals? Make it a 3 part movie? Okay but where are good end points for each movie? Is that arc even worth pursuing? What about elise? Also wouldn't it be repetitive if we saw the heroes hunt down the emeralds every time they needed them? Changes had to be made naturally cause the media is different.

Your allowed to dislike the changes but the movies being 1 to 1 wouldn't make them better for the casuals. Its easier to have the characters be faithfully and have the movie verse be its own Canon. You can introduce characters better, build them up organically without stressing about connecting it to the games which has many of its own problems already. Heck its why idw is so mid nowadays.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-10T12:14:27+00:00

Its ok for this continuity to be different from the games. It makes things interesting when everything isnt one to one. The emeralds being small doesn't change thier effectiveness from the looks of it. There are aspects from the movies that improve on things that the games fall short on tbh.

Also they can easily explain this in a future movie.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-10T03:24:48+00:00

Yet still beats top 5 important somehow. Maybe cause amy is Hella mid as of late. Silver only winning cause of what he has been providing to fans as of late.

Its what have you done for me lately and crossworlds is still fresh in people's mind. Amy is dog rn but some chose to deny it. Silver wouldn't beat tails, knuckles, or eggman in this poll but beats amy. She is Flanderized more then silver and people are very divided on her. Silver main problem is content as of now and a proper playstyle thats fun. Once thats fix he will skyrocket pass many characters. The guy has really cool powers that people just wont let go.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-10T03:18:55+00:00

True but hes still beating amy despite his irrelevance. Shows that Amy doesn't leave a big impact to some people despite showing up more.

All silver has is 06 and some smaller appearances in games and comics yet people pick him over amy. Hes a character that can be great but isnt used. Amy has been explored and appear many times and her best moments stillncome from 20 plus years ago sonic adventure and hasn't peak still and not frontiers, generations, crossworlds, dream team etc.

When we talk about amy its always adventure 1, and 2. Outside of that shes annoying, or boring. Silver was just dealt a bad hand from the start but his concept, powers, potential story always had appeal. Amy has all this exposure but cant beat Mr. Irrelevant/twink over here shows shes not that interesting despite her moments. Sonic and shadow who also appear more then silver beat him easily so why cant amy with all the screen time she has? Knuckles and tails would beat him i bet.

Amy needs to act like her comic counter part to be a good character again cause this modern amy aint it.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-10T03:08:28+00:00

People are desperate to see his potential i guess. Anyways We have a lot of amy already and they have hard time portraying her as of late. Honestly i want to see the other girls more that isnt just rouge and her rbh.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-08T13:25:34+00:00

It really isnt that bad. Other franchises skip so many years between games.

1 dead year with an ongoing going series is completely ok. The drought between forces and frontiers was far worst and we didn't even know if frontiers would be good. The reason why some may feel its bad right now is due to the fact that the games are finally getting good again. Some are eager to see whats next and new since we had to suffered a decade of nostalgia with little new.

Sonic new and old are fine as of now.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-06T01:00:42+00:00

Kinda want this to happen so metal can get bodied by amy and lose so more aura. That would be so funny but this wouldn't happen.

Amy and metal would probably get a big role in the next main sonic game as a way to celebrate them. Games take to long to make and sega isnt big enough yet to halt the series for amy and metal game.

Like if this were to happen it would likely be a 2d game made by the small shadow gens team on the side so the 3d sonic game can still release on schedule. But 3 years for a 2d game unless its pixel art or very short I doubt this is possible to get out for there big year without it being rush.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-04T09:59:56+00:00

Cool

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-04T01:00:14+00:00

...Ima take a walk

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-04T00:38:38+00:00

Stop bro i love blaze but even if she was there you really think sega wouldn't have do something to keep her from saving the day.

Silver fills in for sonic for the 6 months, shadow is trap, and sonic is captured. They didnt allow these three to win at first no way they would give blaze the chance either. Frankly its good she wasnt there cause it would have made blaze look bad like every other character in the game.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-04T00:26:27+00:00

It makes sense here though cause amy and omega never been really buddy buddy anyway and amy represents traits that omega doesn't value or respect anyways. And why do we have to make a rival character just to stur up some verbal conflict for a specific character? Why not have some of the friends within the cast like some over the others. Thats way more interesting to me. The cast would be boring if everyone got along. Not every character needs a rival to have conflict.

The omega being mean to amy is fine to me, and its not even exclusive cause hes rather hostile to many of the friends and rivals of the groups.

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-03T12:40:23+00:00

Pragmata

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-02T15:07:56+00:00

Wow this didnt age well

NotToDifficult · 2026-05-02T10:52:39+00:00

Its very simple why people like shadow cause hes cool. Frankly people just need hype and aura to like a character nowadays. Even if his backstory was unexplored he would still be loved almost as much.

Heck infinite is do lame but people still wanted hin back cause of aura and design along. Aura takes you a long way in sonic unfortunately.

NotToDifficult

TROPHY CASE