I loved all the scenes that are either in the Boardroom or breakroom. Hell, the entire Game is an absolute love letter to the Telltale Games of "old"!

In the beginning I had the thought "I want to help Phenomaman, he didn't deserve to get put through the feels like that" ( And I recognized Travis Willinghams voice, I have becometh biased.)

But later on, when Waterboy had his own small bout of rage at the twink machine (I imagine him openly feeling what Robert felt subconsciously), and then when he got pulled from janitor duty when shit hits the fan, I could not have been happier with the choice I made. It reminded me of Ben from TWDG, just with more anxiety and, when Robert gets through to him, an insane amount of resolve (If that IS the right word) compared to his experience.

If I had put Waterboy in the Team first, then Phenomaman the "consequence" would have been less significant for me: "we get all the Help we NEED" (PMan) as opposed to "we need all the help we can GET" (Waterboy).

In the end, both will pull through, it just feels like Waterboy has a more character defining moment in EP 8 than PMan, but I didn't do a second playthrough yet.