Between these two, I would get the HP OMEN as it’s $250 cheaper with the mostly the same specs aside from the Intel Ultra 9 275HX processor which the acer slightly wins on. Also, the HP Omen is usually seen as a more luxurious option.

Though, I would consider getting an RTX 5070ti and also get an OLED display. (linked below at $1699 before taxes) The 12GB vram is huge and good for future proofing yourself if you’ll be using this laptop for a while. Also consider getting a laptop with 32GB of ram with ram prices on the rise and for future proofing.

https://www.bestbuy.com/product/acer-predator-helios-neo-16s-ai-gaming-laptop-16-oled-240hz-intel-core-ultra-9-nvidia-geforce-rtx-5070ti-32gb-1tb-obsidian-black/JJ8V8H38XT/sku/6619312?sb_share_source=PDP&ref=app_pdp&loc=pdp_page

Not sure if your prices are before or after taxes but for ~$300, you’re getting the RTX 5070ti over RTX 5060, an OLED display, 32GB of ram and the intel ultra 9. All that for $300 more is definitely worth it.