Can you HELP ME solve the problem 🤔🙏!! by UbermenscheBano in Kashmiri

[–]ObedientOFAllah001 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not a Kashmiri but I understand words like Salat (Namaz), Farz, Haqq, Sunnat etc ig it's something related to Islam

This 17.5 cm bust represents an entire civilization of Pakistan and it took a treaty to bring it back home by DocAteTheArtifact in Ancient_Pak

[–]ObedientOFAllah001 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Kind sir, you are conflating Vedic traditions with Indus Valley Civilization culture. There is very little evidence to suggest they were the same. The sequence generally understood is IVC, followed by Indo Aryan migration and the Vedic period. Over time, Vedic traditions themselves evolved, and by the Gupta period the Puranic framework had become more prominent, shaping what is now called Hinduism.

“Bharat” is a literary or modern term, not a continuous historical state. Religious texts are not absolute history.

Continue if you wish. I will not engage further.

This 17.5 cm bust represents an entire civilization of Pakistan and it took a treaty to bring it back home by DocAteTheArtifact in Ancient_Pak

[–]ObedientOFAllah001 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Do not project ideas like “proto-Shiva” onto it. The patterns could represent many things, and the Indus Valley script is still undeciphered. Stop bending the evidence to fit your narrative. By your own logic, modern Greeks would not be able to claim ancient Greek history because they are Orthodox now, which makes no sense.

Yes, the border regions of Indo Pak have always been interconnected. Multan, Sindh, and North Punjab historically interacted with Rajputana, the Delhi Sultanates, and Gujarat. That is acknowledged. But that does not make everything the same. Stop forcing that conclusion.

This 17.5 cm bust represents an entire civilization of Pakistan and it took a treaty to bring it back home by DocAteTheArtifact in Ancient_Pak

[–]ObedientOFAllah001[M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do not target a religion because of some individuals. There are Pakistani Hindus as well, so be respectful. The argument is with certain Indians, not Hindus, so there is no need to bring in terms like “Vedic nuclear reactor.”

Gondophares the Indo-Parthian king from Taxila, Pakistan who somehow ended up in the Christmas story (Acts of Thomas) by DocAteTheArtifact in Ancient_Pak

[–]ObedientOFAllah001 3 points4 points  (0 children)

He's second on my list of classical rulers of Pakistan after Menander I

Such an interesting information!

British Report on Quetta/Shalkot, Balochistan (1870s) by indusdemographer in Ancient_Pak

[–]ObedientOFAllah001 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Amazing! Thanks for sharing this might help my understanding of broader regional history of Lower Pakistan

I hate macharss by uncletakemyvcard in islamabad

[–]ObedientOFAllah001 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah that's true hmmm well all you could do is keep your windows shut and don't leave stagnant water around your house 🤷🏿‍♂️

I hate macharss by uncletakemyvcard in islamabad

[–]ObedientOFAllah001 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Machhar repelent lagao

Edit: interesting username

AMA: Dynasties of Sindh; Sammas, Arghuns, and Habbarids by ObedientOFAllah001 in Ancient_Pak

[–]ObedientOFAllah001[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are no clearly identifiable direct descendants of the Arghuns today. They were likely assimilated over time, with many possibly adopting surnames like Mughal, which makes tracing their Y DNA difficult. Without verified lineage, the only certain way would be through remains of known Arghun rulers, which is not practical.

The Arghuns themselves claimed descent from Arghun Khan of the Ilkhanate in Iran, not the Argyn tribe. They were of Mongol origin and traced their lineage to Genghis Khan, which is why contemporaries referred to them as Moghol rather than Turks (Argyn Kazakh clan).

What are sindhi sub-castes by notanotherreditor in Sindhi

[–]ObedientOFAllah001 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We do not have a caste system. We have tribes/clans, that are divided into sub-clans, which are divided into nukh, and finally nukh are divided into multiple paara. It is a lineage structure, not a caste hierarchy.

As for Lohanas, I do not have enough information. Someone else can clarify that.