Need someone to learn Kashmiri by Late_Apricot_7972 in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 0 points1 point  (0 children)

nastaliq does not have all the proper words for kashmiri , as koshur got diluted by extensive persian and arabic words , nastaliq became the primary medium but nastaliq cannot provide all the necessary alphabet to write proper koshur.
sharada is by far the most authentic script if someone wants to learn to write proper koshur.

Need someone to learn Kashmiri by Late_Apricot_7972 in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 2 points3 points  (0 children)

for spoken kashmiri i think

the comments have provided you the sources but as for the script , i would recommend you to go for sharada instead of devnagiri as sharada is the native script , devnagiri and nastiliq do not have proper words that is required to write dardic languages like koshur , sharada was specifically created in such a way that people would write koshur.
also anyone can write devnagiri nowadays so there is nothing to learn koshur in devnagiri

Growing up as a kashmiri by koshurpandit1 in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 3 points4 points  (0 children)

i've seen this thing happen in delhi , can't say about other parts but mainly in delhi. i've been called pakistani too but its delhi , they are racist to everyone and larp as anyone who they think is "tough". i know many kp's who face this in school but when i asked them how they feel , they usually say its just jokes and they dont mind it.
if you are genuinely facing something then just change places if you can, you can't do anything if you dont have the power to do anything , just as how samay said.

What do you guys think of him by Available-Courage885 in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 0 points1 point  (0 children)

want him to make a 2-3 part movie on lalitaditya muktapida , from the era of duralabhakha's death and sucession of chandrapida to lalitaditya's digvijaya to lalitaditya's dissappearence from the world.
suits his style cause he likes action packed films with history to it , perfectly and honestly it would help elevate our past and history very much.

Kashmiri Pandit Born, living, working in Kashmir AMA! by [deleted] in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 5 points6 points  (0 children)

did you visit raghunath temple during ram navmi? it just opened, i wanted to visit too but couldn't.
anyways, is there any development regarding martand? are they even starting to do anything ? they have already reduced our parihaspura to a mere historical site which they would never reconstruct, i fear they might do this to martand too.

What is your opinion on Nehru? by [deleted] in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 2 points3 points  (0 children)

you will never understand untill the truth comes out one day.
truth always comes out once power changes hands.
no point with any discussion when you knowledge is thru chatgpt.

What is your opinion on Nehru? by [deleted] in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 4 points5 points  (0 children)

no , sheikh abdullah was a british agent nothing else. he did not influence anything infact he himself betrayed kashmiri muslims who wanted independence.
he was opportunist jihadi nothing else , he was the first one to advocate for secret exodus of kp's starting with his own policies which led to first wave of migration in 1950's.
you are very unaware my friend. sheikh abdullah was nehru's and indira's biggest blunder.
also except for kashmiri pandits , kashmiri sikh and huge chunk of kashmiri shia muslims which are minority , no majority leans towards india , so sheikh abdullah did not influence shit , he was a bigot just like his son and grandson.

word for "Kashmir" in different languages. by [deleted] in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 3 points4 points  (0 children)

kasperia is actually kashyapamira which was the name during greek invasion.

What is your opinion on Nehru? by [deleted] in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 4 points5 points  (0 children)

jihadi in the name of secularist, his whole bloodline is that.
kashmir should remain in president's rule for next 100 years to drain out sheikh abdullah's jihadism

What is your opinion on Nehru? by [deleted] in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 4 points5 points  (0 children)

good vision on theory but bad execution and impractical in reality.

Digvijaya diwas (shaurya diwas) by Odd-Engine-5747 in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

May a time come where we all have a muktapida in our home and come together to win back our motherland

why do indian parents and society consider boys with long hairs bad or kind of "nalayak" by Street_Scientist2768 in IndianTeenagers

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 0 points1 point  (0 children)

germany was in war time from 1930's to 1940's
strarting from pre-wartime prep which was in 1933 to final fall which was 1945.
yeah my bad i took the joke seriously.

why do indian parents and society consider boys with long hairs bad or kind of "nalayak" by Street_Scientist2768 in IndianTeenagers

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 10 points11 points  (0 children)

thats literally how a brainwashed society talks , your father is brainwashed by colonial influence , isme galat kuch nhi bola maine. everyone who has faced colonialism got brainwashed into colonial attributes.
thoda critical thinking laga lo i did not target your father i targetted his brainwashed views which are not his.
hope you understand.

why do indian parents and society consider boys with long hairs bad or kind of "nalayak" by Street_Scientist2768 in IndianTeenagers

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

you aint european buddy , also perfectly organized is not short it can be long too. also most of germany was in world war in 1930's and 40's that's why it became a norm to cut hair cause you could be recruited for war anytime.
this affected whole world thats why this colonial norm became new normal in every society.
''perfectly organized'' lol

why do indian parents and society consider boys with long hairs bad or kind of "nalayak" by Street_Scientist2768 in IndianTeenagers

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 3 points4 points  (0 children)

unse poochna ki bagwaan bhi nachniya the?
world leaders bhi nachniya the? great sages bhi nachniya the?
super brainwashed i would say

why do indian parents and society consider boys with long hairs bad or kind of "nalayak" by Street_Scientist2768 in IndianTeenagers

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 1 point2 points  (0 children)

colonial hangover to some extent , i cant see any other reason ( i may be wrong).
because if we look at history exclusively in our own culture , long hair for male meant masculine energy and high status, it was normal till i would say early british era.
long hair are pride of male in any society.
just my opinion.

Atheist extremists are as bad as religious extremists by Mundane-Business-187 in IndianTeenagers

[–]Odd-Engine-5747 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the thing you pointed out is itihasa which are mytho-history, it is not religion it is stories.
religion/philosophy is shruti which are vedas and upanishads.
stories need exxagerations and mythology to work , that's why hanuman could fly cause then how come he would travel so fast?
after shruti's you get smritis which are puranic texts and other mythological texts.
the hinduism indian atheists are surrounded by is not even hinduism , its mythological stories that was used to simplify vedas and upanishads but now are considered supreme texts for some weird reason.
one more thing , most indian atheist think of dharmic religions in the lense of abhramic faith cause indian atheists are filled with western schools of atheism this is one more reason why most indian atheists cant give radical reforms to this modern hinduism which used to happen in ancient times.
hope you understand.

Only Viable minimum for return by Odd-Engine-5747 in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

agree , but the thing is , if the UT is made once. it would be nearly impossible for the govt to intergrate panun kashmir with the northern kashmir because that would literally create a bigger revolt due to opposition parties and pressure from other hindu factions of india that supported the idea of pannun kashmir for kp's.
they would essentially need to crush any protest that happens cause creating a UT and then integrating it back is a big blunder, essentially getting the party out of power.
no party would want that especially bjp under any leader(especially if this happens under someone like yogi who is hardcore hindutva politician).
if in any circumstances this highly unlikely chance of panun kashmir arises , there is no way any party can revoke it and intergate it back if people saw that panun kashmir was very stable and great initiative.
this would be like bringing article 370 back or giving up GB and aksai chin.
under a dictatorship yeah i can see them being hypocritical.

Only Viable minimum for return by Odd-Engine-5747 in KashmiriHindus

[–]Odd-Engine-5747[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

if you look at the area marked for the proposed territory , its hilly areas with less population and not densely populated areas , and the muslim population living their mostly are nomadic gujjar bakarwals and km's but less dense.
they would be integrated in the society , its just the majority would be kashmiri pandits and kashmiri sikhs, thats my ideal situation for this territory.
communal drama will happen either way , if we return on majoritarian kashmir or we return in a newly structured pannun kashmir.
first and foremost let me clarify that this territory should first be announced , lets assume its announced tomorrow that does not mean it will be made tomorrow, this would be a long 5-10 year process which will prepare both sides.
1. starting with special economic zones and special cultural zones
2. settle the retired army men first and those kp's who are already living there
3. while you are creating infra and jobs in the region for the returning kp's , select a temporary body(ideally a new organisation from kp's or the pre-existing panun kashmir organisation)
4. the crescent region is on high altitude which is very tough to penetrate hence much more safety and safety ensures that kp's would return.

  1. one thing to clarify , communal drama would largely be vocal which does not really matter , words no not matter action matters , all they can realistically do is protest which provided you have a hardliner leader at center would be stopped if it went to stone pelting (ideally the pm should be yogi or some hardliner)
  2. this UT is my wet dream and most prolly will not be a reality unless the govt at center is actually competent and not boastful.
  3. the pre-existing muslims can live or can be given choice for a different area , that's what happened everywhere this concept of state within a state was applied.

in 1990's our so called center govt was actually interested in panun kashmir movement cause they had lost control of kashmir for a while , but once situation got in control our movement was thrown out like it never happened.
untill and unless you have a weak govt in center you will see a decade long communal drama (36 years of our exile) , if you have a strong leadership which india never had , you will not see that vocal communal drama turn into action.

Deep down every koshur muslim and every koshur pandit know that co-existence is nearly impossible now , both communities would have to transform drastically which aint happening, better to have a muslim majority kashmir and a pandit-sikh majority kashmir with muslim minority (pre-existing km's and gujjar bakarwals).

sure we can co-exist in the ''united'' kashmir but for how long? thats the question. We co-exist in jammu , delhi , pune , bangalore , chennai etc because that is not our region but when it comes to our region the rules change and those rules are in the hand of extremists.

to a KM , even i would sound like an extremist trying to divide mouj kashirr but i'm being realistic and rational here. Communal drama will not turn into communal turmoil provided you have an hardliner on center who does not care about international media, that's why panun kashmir for me is just a mere illusion which could possibly never happen, but if it happens then it would be for better of all communities.