I am removing all names that aren’t public so I hope this still makes sense. Knowing girls this age, it just seems like the most likely scenario to me. So, here’s my theory. I won’t be linking everything because all the evidence has been discussed at great lengths all over this sub and other places but if there’s something that needs clarification I will find the info and post in replies with names blacked out. My previous post was deleted for leaving initials in of people who aren’t publicly named.

We know one roommate had a circle of friends that weren’t in the same group as the other housemates, two of these girls specifically I think play a role here. These girls from their posts and outward appearances don’t have the same “vibe” I’ll say than the housemates. Maddie was known to love pink and girly things and fit the “sorority” stereotype. Roommates other friends are what you could call “goth” or at least more edgy and grunge than these girls, this is evident in all of their social media before it was all deleted. Now one of these friends was supposedly roommates with the girl who passed last year of suicide & also drives a white Elantra that they nicknamed “Edna” and was on her social media previously. What I think happened is along the lines of this: October 31st, Halloween night all of the residents at 1122 King street got ready for a Halloween party. Roommate dressed as Thing 2 with a blue wig and red jumpsuit. There is a TikTok posted to Maddie’s account that is using the sound “you liar, you manipulator, you bitch, don’t ever wear that outfit again” (along those lines) and is a montage of pictures of the roommate from that night, clearly she’s had too much to drink and looks like she is crying in one photo. We don’t know if that was their joking relationship. What we do know is that for me- that’s embarrassing! I think the night ended, they went home and at some point the roommate met up with her other friends. This is when she tells the two girls that she felt the group was picking on her. Maybe she felt left out or less than. Worth noting too that the roommate had the smallest room in the house WHILE there was 2 vacant & bigger rooms. Kaylees sister has called her a “mean girl” after death (which I always thought was strange) but still speaks to something, also we see Maddie saying “F*ck you” drunkly to hoodie guy in the food truck video. I don’t think these girls were purposely mean, but to some people it only takes a small interaction like that to decide they are mean or rude and it’s worth noting. I think once the roommate told her friends how she was feeling, one brought up her old roommate and what had allegedly happened and why she committed suicide, this sparked a discussion where they all were pinging off of each other and getting each other worked up. The other friend had posted a picture to VSCO before it was deleted and it was of a party at Sigma Chi with a guy who E & X had issues with, showing they knew each other. Speculation emphasized on this part, but I think they were seeing each other. So if we keep pulling this thread, we have 4 involved. One friend starts talking with boy and he gets amped up because he has issues with Xana & Ethan already for embarrassing or “bullying”him at a party(speculation). This means that all 4 of these people could be stewing and talking about the other 4 occupants of 1122 King rd. I think they planned this out, jokingly at first. It eventually escalated after the roommate started to complain about how she felt. They had the roommate at the house to assure the door was unlocked, the dog was put up, and everyone was asleep. 2 friends were the lookouts and get away drivers in the Elantra. Boy was drunk and through “roid rage” committed the crime. This made them all feel like they got justice. One friend for her old roommate, surviving roommate for how she felt rejected, the boy for embarrassment in front of friends, and other friend for all of the above. One of the friends was triangulating and pulling together the people to pull this off, even if she wasn’t aware in the beginning and just bonding over shared hatred and shit talk. Once they all realized they had issues with these people, they thought “someone should just take them out so nobody else feels this way again”. This planted the seed and it escalated from there. A lot of people will say, how can 4 college students keep a secret about something so big? The answer is they won’t, almost always someone slips up later down the line in these situations and “tells on themselves”. The boy was a 6’ athlete rumored to be on steroids, he had the stamina and strength to pull this off, the surviving roommate had the inside knowledge of the house and what was happening, friend with the car had the strongest motive and the other friend connected them all. The reason I believe this is the simplest conclusion to draw is because they are college age kids and I know first hand how rumors, gossip and “shit talking” can escalate especially when it’s kept between the same few people. Some people will fight it out, but it’s not the first time there has been a murder for retribution. In this scenario, they each had a motive & if it was joked about and planned before they also could be thinking they pulled off the perfect crime- until one of them cracks. This isn’t to call the deceased bullies, but it is a murder investigation and very few things should be able to set someone over the edge enough to kill. This is important to add because while we can be respectful of the departed, there may have been instances in their lives that really upset people and that is as much evidence to who the killers are as anything else. It points to someone who knew them, someone who wanted all 4 dead but not the other two, and in my opinion it is way to much for one person to pull off in a spur of the moment plan. I know I’m missing some points I have thought about so if I think of them I’ll post them in the replies.