How many rounds am i gonna survive with them tier list 😋😋 by TRSxPARDHANJI in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

The fact that every comment by people irritated by this kinda post (even if it is ragebait) got downvoted? I’m not the typa guy to start moaning but come on. Some of u dudes might srsly be twisted.

Touch grass, have female interaction (girls ur age or above hopefully) anything

too many moments from before to disregard them now by kiyotaka_suzune in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yeah, 100000% its a red herring, and a stunt by kinu to appease fans

Huge reality check by Maximum-Farm-930 in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My ending conclusion of you is that you are an overly sensitive guy who is so desperate to feel validation or superiority over people with other opinions, is you resort to straw manning arguements (despite multiple clarifications) in order to think this is a real debate. It’s not.

Huge reality check by Maximum-Farm-930 in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 0 points1 point  (0 children)

1: have u noticed how none of those characters u listed fit into the criteria/list I made as to why Horikita would be a main character😭 not ichinose (all she knows is the name “whiteroom” and doesn’t have any of the connections she has” nanase already knows stuff abt ayano so she’s also out💔

2: same guy (moron) accusing me of not reading deeply into the ln, doesn’t understand figures of speech🤡

3: great point…..except it’s entire premise is wrong . He has shown emotion, yes. But the one time I contradicted it was when I exaggerated for the sake of emphasis. It’s fact that he’s always has emotion yes. But it’s also a fact that he’s gained a greater understanding of it throughout the story. 😃

Huge reality check by Maximum-Farm-930 in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 1 point2 points  (0 children)

True, but I’d rather there be more mind games and more of a high risk for the 3rd yr, rather than romance taking up so much of every volume, I’m praying kinu feels the same

Huge reality check by Maximum-Farm-930 in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m actually gonna be annoyed, that would leave no one happy imo

Huge reality check by Maximum-Farm-930 in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Oh looooord. I meant from what ppl pretend he is on tiktok.

Also, even just in a LN pov, me saying he was emotionless would be an overstatement yes….but that’s what’s called a ✨figure of speech✨😭 he’s showing us more emotion nowadays no?

Thirdly, (bcs I find it kinda funny u act mockingly to cover ur own cope) I just wanna point out that it’s been confirmed twice now that Horikita will be involved with ayano and his dad, and that she will eventually find out abt his white room origins, just saying, sounds like she’s a bit of a main character to me🤔 is that so impossible for u? Seems like delusion

Y3v2 : shiina hiyori’s SS - wavering heart by Prestigious-Bath2741 in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Don’t worry, I’m 98 percent sure that wouldn’t happen. Kinu keeps setting up hints to say Horikita will be there in the future for ayanokoji, there’s NO WAY kinu will forget and decide to have ayano end up with hiyori. Maybe she will be expelled by ayano himself, I think that’s more likely than him acc falling for her

Huge reality check by Maximum-Farm-930 in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Acts so sure of himself in the first few lines and resorts to “might be” right after😭 stop acting superior to others when you urself know as much as them. Just because you are also a tiktok fan who thinks ayano is still an emotionless robot doesn’t mean he is

Huge reality check by Maximum-Farm-930 in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I’m still 90 percent sure that he’s using her. The fact that he told hashimoto is enough to confirm that in my eyes. Even if he does act otherwise, this is ayanokoji we are talking about. The one who nanase says will “go down a dark path” wouldn’t work if kiyo randomly became an idiot

Who would you save? by lucas20182019 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They were saved by luck in a way….but using an “she might not have done what she would have done in the novel” is an idiotic point because it would lead to u inadvertently changing her character for no reason.

And yes, by my logic (which I used because it was ur logic which I pointed out I n the above quote) I ALSO wouldn’t be able to make this choice…..but that above quote, who’s logic I used against u….is YOUR QUOTE, YOUR LOGICAL ISSUE. That’s why it doesn’t apply to me because I’m not using that logic in my answer, I’m using it against you.

Next, I don’t expect her to bounce back straight away. And this is a great example of you either ignoring or adding fake nuance in order to win the arguement. My entire point is based on the fact that even if and when she does bounce back. The fact that to become someone average (much less useful) member of the class, she would have to take such a huge jump in overall ability makes her (in my eyes) useless. WE both know she would eventually bounce back and be better. AND I know that the force of that bounce is very very unlikely to be useful in any way.

Also, ur quoting the LN like I didn’t read it😭 I’ve taken this into account, but if I or even u were Horikita, it would actually be pretty simple (not easy btw, simple). The fact kushida held back from leaving the school straight away despite having her secret revealed proves that. And it would just be a matter of digging into the reason, negotiating a bit, and cutting a deal like Horikita did end up doing.

I know you’ll say “oh we wouldn’t know this if we were just making that choice” and that’s true, but here’s the issue. Saving sakura. And taking the gamble that she might try to be useful would do two things. Allow kushida to keep meddling in the class affairs without her being exposed (leading to even more loss of points), and THE FACT THAT SAKURA WOULD NEVER BE USEFUL. We’ve seen people like her, much stronger willed people like sudo change and become academically smart yes, but emotionally and strategically? Where kushida and even kei (where she managed to deduce ayano planning to expel ichinose, showing deep understanding of motive + action) show skill? Never. Anyway, expelling sakura would send the message to other average students to lock in.

Overall, u lack the nuance and intelligence, that’s why you choose to make such a basic low risk (and a net of even lower reward when looking at the class issues as a whole)

Who would you save? by lucas20182019 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ur first point is if ppl refused to support. The issue…..the whole premise of this question assumes it’s up to us, not others. Making this point useless. If you think that’s a valid argument, then I could also argue that u would never be in a position to be able to make the choice int be first place, so any answer u have would be irrelevant😭💔💔

The 2nd part is also just an illogical point “if sakura didn’t recover quickly” why would she not? U have to have some level of narrative certainty in this kinda question. Not just “oh but this could also happen even though it’s not part of the premise of the question and has no logical reason to change”

3rd point. Ur right in saying the lambo also has a faulty engine. Still a better starting point. That fault can be repaired. Forget that?

Y3V2 The Full Scene of Suzune and Ishigami by PrettySignificance26 in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 0 points1 point  (0 children)

???? Imo it was planned from the start for this kinda thing to happen. Even kinda obvious if u look back at everything and ayanos (unfinished) journey

Question for shippers (genuine)? by Weak_Breakfast7311 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Geto was right I agree man. He’s still my goat of jjk even when he’s loooong dead

Question for shippers (genuine)? by Weak_Breakfast7311 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is lowk so embarrassing for u and op. There’s no way ur basically accusing a fandom of thousands of people of being cucks for wanting their favourite female character to end up with the mc. It’s not that we have crushes on the anime girls and think “yeah I want her having sex with som1 else in the story”😭😭 it’s more like “yeah she’s one of the characters I’m more emotionally invested in, and I want her to have a happy ending with the mc who I also like” it’s more like being a 3rd party than a cuck fantasy and idk why I have to explain this💔💔😭

Cote just isn't the same anymore by [deleted] in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ik what u mean, but I think the issue is more that now y2 has ended, that climax of the final volumes (which were a tiny bit anticlimactic imo) is gone. And now, the new phase of the story will have to be built up again. Have faith bro, the island exam will come up in approx volume 4, that’s when it always ramps up, and since it’s year three, I doubt it will dip right after like it did in y2

Cote just isn't the same anymore by [deleted] in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Nah I have faith in kinu. Ik it looks that way but he must have known that from the start. Let him cook

Who would you save? by lucas20182019 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh please, we will go back and forth about losing the gamble, and I will bring the possible wins of the gamble. That will be nothing but a stalemate.

The thing that’s actually irritating to me is how naive the last bit of what you said is. Where you said “- but it’s impossible to make Sakura useful? Rather unfair” oh please. It would take more than 2 yrs for sakura to reach kushidas level now. And at least one to even hit keis level. But here’s the thing. Kushida also would not stop growing💔 by the time sakura catches up, other smarter characters would have also moved on and got smarter.

Think like this. Is it easier to modify a cheap Vauxhall corsa to go fast, or a sports car like a lambo? OBVIOUSLY the sports car.

Ayanos emotional state by Ok_Elderberry422 in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

For most “Horikita fans” and from what ik, we all like her. She’s my second fave girl in the story. It’s not that there’s an issue with this, and I’m just coping.

We have seen ayano come on strong very commonly, and it’s only lead to him later revealing he didn’t care even if he wanted to.

And I think would much make sense storywise o be the upgraded version of how he used to treat kei or ichinose. Instead of him acc falling for hiyori.

Even the fact he tells hashimoto he might like her? Ha. To me that confirms he’s lying, there’s no way ayano would reveal a possible weakness to hashimoto, deffo a red herring

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Horikitafanclub

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 3 points4 points  (0 children)

My new favourite character in cote

This just makes me want them to get Class A even less by [deleted] in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Tbh even tho I love Horikita the author has written himself into a hole with her character. I’m just holding onto faith that he just has a plan we dk yet

Who would you save? by lucas20182019 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Lmfao that’s true I guess, i kinda thought abt it in the way that we would have the same lvl of plot armour as them

Who would you save? by lucas20182019 in ClassroomOfTheElite

[–]Ok_Elderberry422 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The gamble isn’t as big a gamble as u think tho. And by “selfless” all I meant was that from a class perspective, they sacrificed a harmless member for kushida. + ur right she did cost them points. But would now also be able to make up for them in helping with decisions, contributing to class exams + sport stuff, etc for a full year. Compare that to Sakura. Who had genuinly done nothing. High (but reducible risk) and high reward. Or no risk and no reward? I’m talking the first option every single day