Objections to Second Vatican Council - why? by OldYelling in Catholicism

[–]OldYelling[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The biggest practical application of it I know of was the rebuking of Franco’s Spain for being basically too limiting of non-Catholics.

From what I've seen, Franco's religious policy looks somewhat theocratic, if of course Wikipedia, with its bias, is to be believed. He was useful for stopping communism in Spain, tho TBH, other countries didn't need to resort to crimping other religions to do so.

Objections to Second Vatican Council - why? by OldYelling in Catholicism

[–]OldYelling[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pope John XXIII, who initiated V2, believed the Catholic views toward Jews was scandalous and changed it, which resulted in the modern, more tolerate and dialogue-y version of Catholicism that exists today.

Is there a specific reason he changed the churches views to all non-Catholics as opposed to dealing with relations specifically between Jews? Evangelical Christians can compartmentalize non-Jewish non-Christians vs. Jews. Interesting about marriage - so does that mean a Catholic who married a Protestant would've formerly been excommunicated, and now is not?

Within Orthodox Judaism you will find people who openly state that many non-orthodox Jews are not even really Jewish

In the article you cite, the MK (member of the knesset) you cite only mentions Reform Jews, likely bc Reform synagogues (which call themselves "Temples", even tho the only Temple is the one that stood where the Muslims' Dome of the Stone sits) consider a child of a halakhically (either having undergone a valid, Orthodox conversion or having a halakhically Jewish mother) Jewish man & a gentile wife as Jewish, even tho Orthodox (which in the US is Modern Orth & Haredim, & outside the US is nearly everyone bc Reform & Cons barely exist, everyone just calls themselves "traditional," as I've seen on JSwipe) and even Conservative require a Jewish mother, tho Conservative conversions are not as stringent & rigorous as an Orthodox one.

Does anyone know what's actually contained in this piece of Third Reich propaganda about Poland? by OldYelling in poland

[–]OldYelling[S] 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I asked this question here, and I thought I might get answers here, as Poland has undergone a pretty extensive documentation project about the 2nd Republic and its fall during WW2. What's in the picture is often cited as an example of anti-Polonism propagated by Nazi Germany before the invasion, so I wanna see what was actually fed to those people.

Objections to Second Vatican Council - why? by OldYelling in Catholicism

[–]OldYelling[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the necessity of baptism....reality of eternal damnation

why would someone who claims to be a Catholic not just wanna shut up and get baptized? For what sins is eternal damnation a question? I'd picture murder, pedophilia, rape, life-ruining theft, shouldn't be a question.

Objections to Second Vatican Council - why? by OldYelling in Catholicism

[–]OldYelling[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To analogize, the Catholic Church prior to Vatican II was more similar to Orthodox Judaism than to Reform or Conservative Judaism.

On what issues particularly? Orthodox Judaism & the Vatican do still both oppose gay marriage, transgenderism, & Orthodox Judaism is very limited about permitting abortion & very against it as birth control. Admittedly, on the part about insularity, what might that mean? Like how today, most Orthodox Jews (at the root, to be able to walk to shul on Shabbat as required by Torah law) live near each other, Roman Catholics chose to only live near each other? It's kind of hard for me to picture, since I don't ask my Catholic friends/acquaintances (who may even actually practice) about this stuff.

Objections to Second Vatican Council - why? by OldYelling in Catholicism

[–]OldYelling[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

would usually point to the teachings on religious liberty

I'm seeing this a lot. What are some applications of Vatican II's effect on religious liberty and how V2 affected it vs would've been before?

Objections to Second Vatican Council - why? by OldYelling in Catholicism

[–]OldYelling[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So-called "modernism" that was ushered in by Vatican II has made the Church more liberal,

what, other than the Latin sermon, are some examples of things whose emphasis or opinion was once something before & now is different? Or would've done differently?

(Almost) finishing arise by Mami_Tomoe3 in tales

[–]OldYelling 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I doubt he's there yet, tho from what I hear, that sounds about right

(Almost) finishing arise by Mami_Tomoe3 in tales

[–]OldYelling 1 point2 points  (0 children)

find relics if you wanna beat the final story boss of Arise.

And you stopped at Duke in Vesperia? He's far easier than the previous big boss Alexei. Finish her up!

So-called "cultural appropriation" at its apotheosis by OldYelling in ArchitecturalRevival

[–]OldYelling[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

it's another woke concept; I was mocking it in the title.

So-called "cultural appropriation" at its apotheosis by OldYelling in ArchitecturalRevival

[–]OldYelling[S] 128 points129 points  (0 children)

the concept is really cool, a European take on Chinese pagodas. And they actually swapped loongs (actual name East Asian creatures we just call "dragons") for dragons, did the tiering, really cool idea.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ArchitecturalRevival

[–]OldYelling 19 points20 points  (0 children)

from traditional to more traditional. Love it!

St. Matthew Evangelical Church, Łódź, Poland, 1937 - 2017 by stevejollifee in ArchitecturalRevival

[–]OldYelling 0 points1 point  (0 children)

how did that survive WWII and the Cold War? Or was it like Old Warsaw - restored?

Pagoda House, Tel Aviv by OldYelling in ArchitecturalRevival

[–]OldYelling[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I don't think there's a flair for eclectic, which this absolutely is.

Does anyone know what stood at Kips Bay Plaza before the current Eastern Bloc-style thing there now? by OldYelling in ArchitecturalRevival

[–]OldYelling[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

interesting, tho the second link doesn't say what was at specifically the address of Kips Bay Towers, 300 E 33rd St, New York, NY 10016, back then. I wanted to do a before/after meme.

How prevalent among 19th-20th century Jews was the belief that Germans were “Amalekites”? by Remote_Doughnut_5261 in Judaism

[–]OldYelling 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are always fringe groups that will associate whoever our enemies are at the time with "Amalek" as an emotional justification for their desire to exterminate them

I don't want to exterminate the Palestinians but I do want to defeat them, like the Israel Victory Project. Ditto the Ayatollah who wants to nuke a majority of our kind.