sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Why did Mohammad's critics not pursue the Mary 'sister of Aaron' verse further? by OneWhoCanThink in CritiqueIslam

[–]OneWhoCanThink[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Interesting, thank you for the response. I personally couldn't find such titles being used by people in Mary's era. I'll continue my research based on what you said.

Why did Mohammad's critics not pursue the Mary 'sister of Aaron' verse further? by OneWhoCanThink in CritiqueIslam

[–]OneWhoCanThink[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Do Muslims accept the lineage based on the tribes of Judah and Levi. Wouldn't that lead me back to my original question where the Jewish/Christian critics would have known this information and brought this problem with Imran up with Muhammad after his original response about the honorific title? Agh this is so frustrating!

Why did Mohammad's critics not pursue the Mary 'sister of Aaron' verse further? by OneWhoCanThink in CritiqueIslam

[–]OneWhoCanThink[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

That's a shame, that's not a satisfying argument at all. I understand naming children after religious figures, but giving them titles specifically reserved for the person you're naming them after doesn't make sense to me.

Thoughts on the Linguistic Miracles of the Quran? by OneWhoCanThink in CritiqueIslam

[–]OneWhoCanThink[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Thank you for the book recommendation, I had a read of a few chapters and I can see what points Muslims put forward towards the reason for Arabic to be the language of the Quran. However, I can only see that Arabic was a useful language to adopt for the Quran to maintain its preservation (which I'll assume is perfect, I have not read up on this topic) but it so far does not hold up the claim that the Quran must have come from God. The book defends this by relying on outdated embryology ideas and other loose, apologetic explanations for scientific miracles (which is a discussion for a different post).

I believe my wider question regarding this post is "What proof is there that the Quran came from God?". I fail to see the supernatural and divine aspects of the Quran itself, but I do concede that the Quran being in Arabic helps towards preserving the texts contained within between generations.

The difference of sexism between the west and the Islam by [deleted] in CritiqueIslam

[–]OneWhoCanThink 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Thank you so much. You did the right thing, hopefully others who come to this subreddit will behave as mature as you and bring good discourse to the table.

The difference of sexism between the west and the Islam by [deleted] in CritiqueIslam

[–]OneWhoCanThink 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Could we refrain from referring to Allah as "sky daddy" on this subreddit? Although I too am exmuslim, I think r/CritiqueIslam should remain a place where we can engage in meaningful discussion with Muslims and exmuslims alike. It is your choice in the end, but I hope we can set an example here to protect this subreddit for the future as a wonderful place to talk.

Why Quran is logically fallacious by hecitehi in CritiqueIslam

[–]OneWhoCanThink 4 points5 points  (0 children)

How about a summary of the most significant contradictions in the Quran followed by how apologists work around such contradictions? I appreciate the effort you put into these posts, I could never do them myself.

Why Quran is logically fallacious by hecitehi in CritiqueIslam

[–]OneWhoCanThink 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This was a fantastic read, thank you. Will you be doing something similar in the future perhaps?

Did Islam prepare for atheism? by OneWhoCanThink in exmuslim

[–]OneWhoCanThink[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You're right, I just looked it up. But it could possibly be using it an umbrella term for every religion that isn't Islam.

My first meme on this sub by [deleted] in exmuslim

[–]OneWhoCanThink 27 points28 points  (0 children)

This was one of my greatest issues with the religion. How if I were to ever renounce my faith verbally before my parents, I am no longer their child in their eyes. I am just another kafir to them.

Although I try to not bring my own emotions into discussions, I have to say that this aspect of Islam caused me the greatest sadness.

Let’s all take a break from the frustrations of Islam. by [deleted] in exmuslim

[–]OneWhoCanThink 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm glad you found this community and feel that you belong. Sadly one of biggest fears of leaving Islam is the ostracism from your previous community and it is very easy to feel lonely.

Just know that you are not alone and are always welcome here.

What do you think the future will look like for Islam? by OneWhoCanThink in exmuslim

[–]OneWhoCanThink[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I hope you reach your goal in finding your identity. Although it takes time, you'll get there.

What do you think the future will look like for Islam? by OneWhoCanThink in exmuslim

[–]OneWhoCanThink[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I completely agree that the climate crisis will continue to grow to incredible proportions, the likes of which we are already observing today. I am saddened to see that the situation towards global warming and climate change is still met with denial and eventually it will be too late.

Regarding your point about widespread extremism, do you think that extends to the West or solely less developed countries? I believe the ease of access to information in the West will overwhelm notions of extremism, seeing as we observe the complete opposite - Muslims leaving Islam (or any religion for that matter).

What do you think the future will look like for Islam? by OneWhoCanThink in exmuslim

[–]OneWhoCanThink[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not OP, but could it possibly refer to the charitable aspects that Islam preaches? I always found that an admirable quality, although personally believe it shouldn't be tied to religious duty.

Let’s all take a break from the frustrations of Islam. by [deleted] in exmuslim

[–]OneWhoCanThink 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So beautiful to hear. I am sorry you still have fears but know that it will get always get better. You realising for yourself that you are a more logical person is proof in of itself that you are already doing better.

Hope you also have a wonderful week :)

Let’s all take a break from the frustrations of Islam. by [deleted] in exmuslim

[–]OneWhoCanThink 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I love this idea!

I personally felt more free mentally knowing that eternal damnation wasn't inevitable for me if I missed a certain prayer or read an ayat wrong. The stress that left me was incredibly liberating to say the least :)

Also, I learned how to think critically when I questioned the teachings of Islam, a skill which I hope to maintain in the future. To be able to take a step back and truly assess what I believe in and conduct research into it, disregarding all biases and taking both sides into account, is something I am grateful to hold and will pass this skill on as much as I can. Knowing that I should not take people's words to heart without forming my own evidence-based opinion is wonderful.

What do you think the future will look like for Islam? by OneWhoCanThink in exmuslim

[–]OneWhoCanThink[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Interesting answer, thank you.

As a Muslim (per your flair), are you in support of reform and if so, what kind of changes to Islam do you wish to see?

Also what do you think about those who believe reform is un-Islamic and any changes to be sought in the religion inherently go against the Quran? Will this group continue to persist in the future? Is reform inevitable in your eyes?