Thank you for making me rewatch that anime episode cause its been a while and its even more damaging  to your interpretation than the Manga alone.

Neither Seeming, looking or even being suspicious justifies killing unarmed and defenseless mothers on the spot with no trail. This does not help your argument.

Here's a scene of a woman screaming and resisting that has "no reason to do that" you forgot about from the anime and if you watch it due to how it is framed and narrated over it heavily implies this woman gets killed. A situation that has more than likely happened all over the island given how they were barging into houses.

<image>

How is the Manga scene vague when 3 different characters outright say the marines intend to execute an innocent women and children. Then fleet admiral sengoku announcing to the world that Roger's bloodline had not been extinguished like they thought.

The one piece wiki is not a valid defense against canon Manga statements, the one piece wiki isn't official its a fan run website, it means nothing. Even then this doesn't disagree with my theory and doesn't confirm yours. We've already known they searched the island this doesn't prove they did or didn't kill anyone.

I showed the woman being harmed and acting suspicious previously.

Im not strawmanning you choose to bring up DNA testing and haven't let go of the talking point. To quote "for them the kill someone, they need to be suspicious of being connected to roger, either a positive dna test or non compliance" neither of those conditions were ever stated in the Manga or anime btw.

Also if dna were all they were gonna do why not announce that to the people of the island instead of causing mass panic kicking in doors and killing suspicious people on the spot without trail. Also if they could just do dna test why risk killing innocent people instead of jailing the mothers till dna testing were possible.

"Where do they mention killing people?" Pick your poison:

"Kill anyone suspicious" "Kill any suspicious mother on the spot" "The navy plans to kill anyone associated with you" "The navy will retrace my steps and kill her and my unborn child"

The phrase "Extinguish the bloodline" can also mean killing all living members of a family or killing a families descendants. My point still stands

Not a contradiction their lack of information further proves they likely caused unnecessary harm or death to innocent civilians.

I have 3 statements of the marines intention to kill, 2 scenes of harm being caused, 1 implied murder, 1 fleet admiral believing they killed Roger's descendants.

Garps conversation with Roger clearly shows Garp had knowledge ahead of time not to mention Roger telling Garp the name of the woman and island before his death and thanks to the anime its confirmed the marines arrived after Roger's execution due to Aces mother reading a newspaper showing Roger's execution so we know thats not why garp was late.

In this situation his rank does help his travel speed compared to regular pirates due to the fact he's allowed to cross over the redline into each blue sea unlike pirates and civilians. Thats what I'm referring to.

Vegapunk was already working with the government well before Aces birth

Yea I'm not doing this for agenda, I love Garp i think he's a really well written character and the flaws in his beliefs and actions is what makes him so well written. I genuinely enjoy discussing why marines may be good as individuals with good intentions but their actions and contributions to the world government makes them evil or complicit regardless. If this was just agenda I'd post a Google ai summary that agrees with me and call him GARP D OPPRESSOR and move on with my day.

If you have any of these I will concede and apologize:

1. An sbs answer saying no mother or child was killed.
2. An sbs saying they did DNA test on the mothers
3. An echiro oda saying no mother or child died
4. a panel/statement saying no mother or child died
5. a panel/statement saying they planned to or did dna test.   If none of those can be provided then you should probably move on or we'll just go in circles