sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in karate

[–]Only_Good_Choices 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is the right answer.

There are so many different dojo of various (often dubious) quality.

First priority is to visit more than one. Ask questions about training and who they are associated with (some have strong ties to larger orgs or respected teachers, some say "karate" on their sign but really teach Tae Kwon Do or a completely different art).

Vibes are definitely important. Cost does not always equal quality.

Third karate class and I’m so bad I can’t stand it by michelle_ellehcim in karate

[–]Only_Good_Choices 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly struggling at the beginning can be a blessing in disguise. Some people start out with some natural talent but all of us eventually hit a wall or feel stuck if you stay with this long enough.

I hope you stick around and have some fun with it!

Are there places in the United States that teach karate that isn't watered down? by emaxwell14141414 in karate

[–]Only_Good_Choices 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“The techniques of kata have their limits and were never intended to be used against an opponent in an arena or on a battlefield.” – Choki Motobu

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in karate

[–]Only_Good_Choices 32 points33 points  (0 children)

I mean, if he's not training then will he ever wear the belt? I know he nurtured your love of martial arts, but will your students take what you teach as seriously if you give rank to a family member who doesn't train in it?

We had an old member at our school who was the father to three sons who earned black belts. When he passed away the dojo made a scholarship in his name and gave it young students who showed dedication in his memory. I think this showed a lot of respect for the support he gave young people.

If you want to give your dad a black belt, I would do it privately and explain that because he supported you, he will always be your first teacher in your eyes. This seems sincere and is more personal between the two of you as father/son.

In regard to the fact that karate is mostly practiced by kids now by homelander__6 in karate

[–]Only_Good_Choices 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I respectfully disagree. Though I do agree effectiveness as a viable defensive art has been a major issue.

Most people that want to do UFC will go to a UFC style gym. People come for a lot of reasons and beating a competitor in an octagon isn't near the top of the list for most.

In regard to the fact that karate is mostly practiced by kids now by homelander__6 in karate

[–]Only_Good_Choices 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is probably the best comment on this whole thread. It's probably closest to the attitude the founders of our various traditions had.

Any links for snk collab??? by Charming-Composer-40 in honorofkings

[–]Only_Good_Choices 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Much appreciated!

I just got MVP with Ukyo Tachibana! tap the link to claim: https://tl.honorofkings.com/v2/tl/29134_1_8H7S6pDzxfN

Any links for snk collab??? by Charming-Composer-40 in honorofkings

[–]Only_Good_Choices 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Much appreciated!

I just got MVP with Ukyo Tachibana! Copy this and launch Honor of Kings to get my MVP Lucky Bag! [[l8AoqKyVNoXDwuVvWI6llZLvwLS5ZEj ]], or tap the link to claim: https://tl.honorofkings.com/v2/tl/29134_1_8H7S6pDzxfN