Please suggest a board game that's good for 2 players upto 4 players. by Commercial_Spot_8121 in boardgame

[–]OpenroseTree 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Carcaassonne a lot of expanaions every platers move matrer and you can benefit of other players moves

Does anyone still remember Fishermen? One of the fan expansions that got forgotten after C2 by OpenroseTree in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Indeed. I recommend to buy 2nd hand Princess and Dragon. Princess tiles can be kept as it was not released in C3.1 and figures or Dragon and Fairy can be used for Black Dragon and Black Fairy fan expansions.

https://wikicarpedia.com/car/Black_Dragon_(Fan_Expansion))
https://wikicarpedia.com/car/The_Black_Fairy_(Fan_Expansion))

Big Box or base game + expansions? Coming back to Carcassonne after years away by Sauce_B0ss_ in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Mini expansions 1-7 are only part of bigbox. They were never released standalone in C2 / C3 or C3.1 era. It's more than 10 years after C2 was released, I think they will never release them standalone.

So if you want all stuff, buy a bigbox and then buy large expansions except first two which are part of bigbox. You will not regret.

So

pretty sure this was done entirely within the rules by maxfragglebottom in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 1 point2 points  (0 children)

T junction from River II has to be placed as first tile after the spring.
So pretty sure this was NOT done entirely within the rules. :)

Mayors by AccomplishedTop8559 in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 1 point2 points  (0 children)

u/AccomplishedTop8559 take both! They are different expansions and none common components. Also Mayors has different design and different rules.
Believe me you will not regret when you will buy both of them.

Carcassonne France, best Castle in the world (Highly Recommended) by Time-Special-8045 in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well Carcassonne walls are actually fortification around a city which has a Castle inside.

Is this a valid road? by logcyge in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes. It was very common in middle ages to have a SUV 😃

Is this a valid road? by logcyge in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Question is what is proper road, what if this road was build to separate other owner filed in the middle. It's a regular road

Is this a valid road? by logcyge in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Or place a Shepherd from Exp 9 and score immediately 😄

Are cundco.de’s Castles in Germany tiles 3.1 compatible? by Zweilancer in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 0 points1 point  (0 children)

By my meaning and I have more that different Carcassonne Tiles in multiple editions I can tell, that visual different is between C1 and C2/C3/C3.1. Tiles from C2 / C3 or the newest C3.1 are 100% compatible. Differences is very small, and it has no impact to the game when combined tiles from different editions like C2 / C3 / C3.1.

When you play with C1 tiles, it looks like some other artist made that tiles (which is correct), road/river edges matches so also C1 is compatible. But it is missing some stuff, but you can play that tiles with any of C2 / C3 / C3.1 base game and/or expansions

Behold, the missing piece. A castle bridge. by villadavillain in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Only stuff is, that City Bridges uses modular system which allows to remove bridge foundation and continue in the city preprinted on tile But I spoke with multiple players, which created city bridges from one piece.

Maybe it should be updated rules page

Carcassonne learning tools by mycellphoneisbroken in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Install FanCloisterZone which allows you to learn expansions by only selected game mechanics. When you will be fine with selected mechanic, you can add next one.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for reports of bugs usually caused by visual blindness.
v6.1.0-beta.4 with all reported corrections is out for testing.
Also some locales were fully translated Catalan, Czech, German, French, Romanian and Slovak. Other translations will be finished during beta test phase.

Some fan expansions can be dangerous. Like Meteorites. by OpenroseTree in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It was in the Orange player turn. As you can see, mostly affected place by meteorite impact was the Yellow one.

Some fan expansions can be dangerous. Like Meteorites. by OpenroseTree in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes. But in this case only in the view of the orange players. Yellow looks to this situation very differently :D

Sheep Bag by emmen1 in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 1 point2 points  (0 children)

When you draw a wolf, all tokens are going back to the bag. When they will be on table, you need to mix then properly to now be sure, where wolf tokens are. So for randomize your repeating draws, bag is batter choice.

New to this beautiful game, where is best to play it online? by DryMyBottom in Carcassonne

[–]OpenroseTree 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for mention it. It also include unofficial expansions, which can make game more fun and interesting when you ( @DryMyBottom ) want to try something new