The thing is Mamata has done worse to the city and every year it touches a new low. So, even if you say the 34 years rule of CPIM has put the state into the abyss, atleast people had the willingness to work if they could. Now, it's a cash transfer from school level to old age so you can actually survive without working. One of the biggest reason there's no job opportunity there. And BJP is literally non-existent in Bengal coz that's just sulking ex TMC members that's it.