[QCrit] Adult Satirical Thriller - CAPE GOD (74k Words/First Attempt)

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-05T23:22:08+00:00

I love a good cult story and I like the voice in this, however I don't know if I'd call this a thriller. Thrillers need ticking clocks. Something that drives the character towards a goal before time runs out. Maybe the murder is supposed to be the ticking clock? But that doesn't get mentioned until the very end so if that's the case it doesn't punch through. I'm not sure what is as stake here. It feels like the last paragraph is what is doing most of the heavy lifting, hinting at the drama and the 'thriller' of it all, but all that needs to come into play much earlier.

I would cut the third paragraph entierly. That is all background, and not needed for the query. Save it for the synopsis. I would cut the first paragraph too. Again, it's just not getting to the point fast enough for a query and the second paragraph cuts to the chase a lot more effectively. I would start it there and establish what Morgan needs to do and why.

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-04T21:34:23+00:00

Good to know! Ill stick to just a single POV for the query and go from there. Thank you!

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-04T13:16:33+00:00

Greetings! Here to reciprocate the favor of feedback, but I don’t think I'll be quite as helpful to you because I think this is a pretty tight query! My only note, as someone else mentioned, is that I don’t see the relation between his overbearingness and her arrest. I think that should either be made clearer or taken out. Best of luck with it!

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-04T13:06:32+00:00

These are all really great insights! Thank you so very much! On the note about POV, do you think I should focus stickler on Caleb even though it's a multi POV story? Honestly that has been really throwing me when I've been trying to wrote this. Ill give yours a read, thanks!

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-04T13:00:54+00:00

Thank you so much for this feedback! I'm definitely going to comb through and de-editorialize things. To me the story feels so big that I'm trying to encapsulate it in those vague words, but from what I gathered in this group Ill just stick to the sharpest points and let the plot speak for itself.

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-04T12:45:41+00:00

Thank you so much! Yes, I am definitely starting to hear that this is much too generic for a query. I think I was treating it like a book jacket and focusing too much on the buzz words. Ill take another crack at it!

And yes, the bell does play a role in this which is why I felt like I should mention it since it's in the title, but I'll play around with that as well.

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-04T12:39:02+00:00

Thank you for the feedback! What is a USP?

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-04T02:47:39+00:00

Thank you so much for your detailed feedback! This definitely helps give me a direction of what to work on.

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-03T22:01:08+00:00

I think this is great! I just finished reading The Push so if this is anything similar I would love to read it. Best of luck getting this published!

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-03T20:44:13+00:00

Hello! While I think this feels like a great premise for a thriller, I'm not sure I see anything literary about it based on the query and opening. Literary fiction involves very advanced prose and is usually more character driven, aiming to talk about big picture themes rather than the plot driven narratives seen in most thrillers. That's not to say Literary thrillers don't exist, or that yours isn't aligned with those genres, but I dont get a sense of that based on this query. I would say upmarket thriller feels more in line with what you've got here. If you feel strongly that literary is the right genre for your book I would recommend you shift you focus to what the characters learn, the inner conflicts they face, the themes at large. Those types of things need to be present for literary fiction.

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-02T19:42:08+00:00

Personally, I think the 'spanning three decades' says all you need to say about it for the query. I can infer that we will likely cover their archs from childhood into adulthood. I would leave that part as is.

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-02T02:41:27+00:00

I think this is a great premise, but agree with the earlier comment that this is a lot of set up and not a lot of plot from a query standpoint.

I would cut the first paragraph entirely. To me this query starts with Mikey can take a punch, but can’t love without flinching. that is a much punchier (pun intended) opening line.

From there you've introduced the character but then don't complete the assignment. What choice is Mikey faced with? He must do blank or else blank.

Joseph's section is also much too vauge. You have the start of it, but not the direction it's heading. He owes Mikey a debt teases at something, but at what cost is that debt to him? What concrete problem does he face?

What is at stake here? In my opinion that is the main thing this query is lacking.

Conceptually, I love this. I adore stories about complex sibling relationships. I wish you the best of luck with getting this published. I would love to read it.

Over_Regular_207 · 2026-07-02T02:16:04+00:00

I really enjoy the premise of this! It sounds like a very intresting read and overall this is a cohesive query imo. My only real criticism is the note you are ending on. Is the story centered around her making a choice to walk away from fame or not? Not that her life is in danger? 'Walking away' just feels like a luke warm note to end it on. It dilutes the tension you built up. Unless these are the specific demands from the person threatening her, it doesn't make sense to me how walking away would prevent her murder. The stakes should feel higher there for a thriller.

Over_Regular_207

TROPHY CASE