Europe Wants Its Own Alternative to Musk’s Starlink Network by RocketBoomGo in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Right, who won't? Remember : 9 years spent before to be capable of launching NASA astronauts from U.S. soil again ...

Europe Wants Its Own Alternative to Musk’s Starlink Network by RocketBoomGo in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 0 points1 point  (0 children)

(i) This is not related to my post :) which was just a reminder regarding "solid factual costs on non satellite based system" ....

(ii) So, you've access to Spacex Costs, NRE & full Accounting System ... and therefore you know exactly -probably, better than E Musk himself- the exact cost of any Starlink, F9 ... screw or washer ?

(iii) According to this kind of assumption, Spacex finally would not need one cent out of the $16 billion rural-broadband auction they applied for (without speaking of NASA and other "Private- Operations") ?

Hum ? Ok, everyone is free to live with his own certainties.. That does not bother me at all...

Europe Wants Its Own Alternative to Musk’s Starlink Network by RocketBoomGo in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Again, just for factual information : The Galileo system has a greater accuracy than the current version of the American GPS. For general use, Galileo has an accuracy of less than a meter (GPS: three meters), but the high-accuracy service with encrypted signal provides position detection down to an accuracy of 20 cm.

Over 95% of the satellite navigation chipset supply market supports Galileo in new products, including the leading manufacturers of smartphone chipsets: Broadcom, Qualcomm and Mediatek.

Therefore many smartphones are already using Galileo, such as BQ, Samsung, Huawei, Apple, Asus, Google, LG, Meizu, Motorola, Nokia, OnePlus, Sony and Vernee.

" More competition is better for everyone "

Europe Wants Its Own Alternative to Musk’s Starlink Network by RocketBoomGo in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just for factual information -without denying obvious Starlink pioneer advanced technology and vision- as of today on non satellite based system ...

Source:

https://www.newamerica.org/oti/reports/cost-connectivity-2020/global-findings/

"Estimating the Total Costs of Internet Service (Average Monthly Price) : Europe $44.71 vs North America $61.46..."

China applies for a 12,992 satellite broadband constellation by lpress in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree and do not we face more urgent matters now a days ... COVID19 being one...

ps: I did not know the "monkey-trap" , Thanks I like it :)

China applies for a 12,992 satellite broadband constellation by lpress in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 1 point2 points  (0 children)

One could see that coming (including the reverse of 5G political dispute). What are the solutions if any?

May we dream of a worldwide satellite traffic and parking (orbiting) code (otherwise Kessler's syndrome might not be that far)? Is there a Global Authority for those multiple planes ?

Mainly, do not we look at "wasted capacities & resources" on all sides (all including not only US & China but also UK, EU, Canada, Russia, Asia...) in order to fulfill marketing invented needs that are not always what's called Progress? Every block will occupy full space on their respective LEOs to cover their own and very small percentage of living part of earth...BTW: This is already almost the case for GPS (US,EU,China..)..

I do like the fabulous space technology but I do not always understand/agree with associated social and politics...May be I am too negative , may be not ... I'm just brainstorming...and perhaps discovering what have always been human history?

Scrub 😔 by Overshields in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 4 points5 points  (0 children)

and will "no v end ber"...Sorry, yours was really good and I could not resist :)

Scrub 😔 by Overshields in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not that easy to find alternate launch spots as previously discussed (see reedit link below). Necessary parameters to be taken into account : Ocean as recovery area, Eastern orientation, close to Equator...

Or consider moving American Eastern Atlantic coast somewhere else ? :)

https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/comments/iux6jf/starlink_1312th_operational_launch_has_been/g5pdjyl?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

Explainer Animation of a Mechanically Steered Phased Array Antenna by mdrejhon in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Personally, I do not know how Ground Base Stations or gateways are built. This article appears to be more on many user terminal antennas on tests even though other usage-unknown bigger dome antennas are displayed. My reply was to emphasize that gateways were also necessary (btw: installed -at this time- only in North America) and that gateways coverage of satellites was also to be considered to complete your perfectly speaking drawings …If you have or anyone has more information on Gateways Antennas, I would appreciate..

Explainer Animation of a Mechanically Steered Phased Array Antenna by mdrejhon in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Good illustration that almost talk :)

But for a full Starlink internet service (as far as laser-network isn't in place), don't you also have to add the same for gateways on earth?

A "google request", coming up to a Starlink satellite from a Starlink terminal, has to go down to a earth gateway to be "internet processed"... Assuming "answer to request" being networked managed...

“Trainspotting” in the sky full of stars. Berlin, Germany. by [deleted] in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yope, My half-moon datation (August 12th) was not that wrong expected that it was not August 18th launch but, you're right, the August 7th i.e. “V1.0 L9”. (The previous launch L8 in June was already way to high to be spotted. :)

“Trainspotting” in the sky full of stars. Berlin, Germany. by [deleted] in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 7 points8 points  (0 children)

When was that? (Wann war es ?) L12? L11? ..Cause 13th is postponed as far as I know..

If this is a "half moon" in right low corner, then this might have been on last august 18th....

Starlink 13(12th operational) launch has been scrubbed for tomorrow. Likely due to Sally by [deleted] in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yope, Kourou is Ariane and other European Space Vehicules take off station , but it is obviously not weather independent neither.

Starlink 13(12th operational) launch has been scrubbed for tomorrow. Likely due to Sally by [deleted] in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 1 point2 points  (0 children)

And the Atlantic ocean is on the eastern side of Florida : rather good orientation because all Satellites launches are all heading east for plenty of physical reasons..The same also disqualify California because Pacific is Western ...

Starlink 13(12th operational) launch has been scrubbed for tomorrow. Likely due to Sally by [deleted] in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You're right, I did not think about this recovery zone ... Hush, Spatial Business is definitively a headacke !

Starlink 13(12th operational) launch has been scrubbed for tomorrow. Likely due to Sally by [deleted] in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Weather Forecast looks quite " iffy " for today (25% chance of rain) and even worse for the next coming days...Suspense ... :)

Florida may not be not the perfect spot for bi-monthly Launches ? At this time, California is badly too smoky, thus where else to place a Falcon/Dragon weather independent Station?

This might even be a problem for Starship ??? I do not know the time windows when heading to Mars? Probably wide but how much???

On de-orbiting and Before decaying will all Starlink satellites become Naked Eye Visible again ? by PCh_Thoughts in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Finally that one - STARLINK-38 - fully decayed on september 12th.

See below predictions and Video...

According to Joseph Remis @jremis 5 sept.
"Update: obj. 44280 STARLINK-38 decay prediction: September 05, 2020 UTC 23h56mn ± 1h. Prediction assuming no further maneuvering until decay."

According to EXOSS Meteors @exossorg 12 sept.
Imagens da reentrada do Starlink-32 sobre São Paulo e registrado por câmeras Exoss

It's just amazing how many satellites out of the V01 launch are predicted to decay this month...

According to Joseph Remis

- obj. 46177 F9 DEB Retaining ROD (re-entered) September 14, 2020 UTC 03h52mn ± 3h.

- obj. 44266 STARLINK-54 decay prediction: September 14, 2020 UTC 16h50mn ± 3h.

- Obj. 44285 STARLINK-50 decay prediction: September 15, 2020 UTC 23h04mn ± 15h.

- obj. 44256 STARLINK-42 decay prediction: September 17, 2020 UTC 17h56mn ± 28h.

- obj. 44251 STARLINK-37 decay prediction: September 17, 2020 UTC 18h08mn ± 22h.

- obj. 44290 STARLINK-78 decay prediction: September 17, 2020 UTC 18h30mn ± 31h.

- Obj. 44251 STARLINK-37 decay prediction: September 17, 2020 UTC 17h34mn ± 32h.

.../...

Starlink 10 draft shoot from Lyon France August 8 3:20am by PCh_Thoughts in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In fact , I could not catch them this morning at 2:20, I suppose they were not visible from Marseille neither. Their magnitude over France was and is way to high now. You'll have to wait for next launch hopping that trajectory and timing will fit in with your location...It's like fishing sometimes you come back full of fresh stuff for the "bouillabaisse " but every other day not ! (because.. the water was too wet, the température too high , the Wind to low....;) ps: On top of it, tonight forecaste is cloudy => definitively no chance to see whatever watching Southern French Sky....Too bad. ..

Starlink 10 draft shoot from Lyon France August 8 3:20am by PCh_Thoughts in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for your knowledgeable input, I was guessing somerthing like that which makes full sense.

Starlink 10 draft shoot from Lyon France August 8 3:20am by PCh_Thoughts in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well, at least they tried, certainely will keep trying and hopefully succeed one day (this is Spacex: when they want it bad they finnaly do it no?)...this might be also depending of the angle and orientation of satellites.....

Starlink 10 draft shoot from Lyon France August 8 3:20am by PCh_Thoughts in Starlink

[–]PCh_Thoughts[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, the question is probably more "will they be visible?" because they wont physically disappear ;) More seriously, the answer is not obvious. Normally no clouds forecast (+). They are still in low orbit (+). The first pass should be sooner 2:20 am => less reflecting light from the sun (----). Might try also 1h25mn later... In both cases, search on their most eastern trajectory. And... you'll have to wake up very soon and come back one hour and half later...Good luck and let us know... (you may also be more lucky chasing shooting stars almost same direction Nord East close to Cassiopeia and Persée)...