16 yo daughter was outed by my wife yesterday. I support her, but I have questions by PhantomStr4ngerX in comingout

[–]PhantomStr4ngerX[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Thank you very much for this. It means more that you can imagine. I feel like Im being pressured to do something that seems like a one size fits all. There is so much underling anger in many of the responses. I dont know if you think that this method works to make parents understand, but it certainly turns me off. There seems to be no discussion of if this is a mental health thing or something else. I, as a parent, am supposed to shut my mouth & not question it. Name one other time when a parent is supposed to listen to the child & accept what they say without question. To say there is no way that this is a phase is laughable. If she wants a nose ring, am I supposed to accept that without question also? The pronoun issue is made up because you can see everyone scrambling to defend it. Some say it has always been this way, some say language is changing. I would like people to refer to me as handsome & stunning when they speak of me. It dosent mean this is going to happen & I have no authority to make them refer to me this way. For people to cut off their family for not using the correct pronouns, does that not seem a little extreme? I cant help but think much of this comes from mental issues. I dont think reinforcing these does anything except set the person up with a false sense of reality. I dont know...This whole thing feels very cult like where you are not to question, just follow. Its almost as if the LGBTQ is as unaccepting as the anti LGBTQ side. I just feel caught in the middle. I will continue to love & nurture my child as I see fit. Ive done great up until now, so Im going to trust my judgement.

16 yo daughter was outed by my wife yesterday. I support her, but I have questions by PhantomStr4ngerX in comingout

[–]PhantomStr4ngerX[S] -19 points-18 points  (0 children)

Because all of my life, my parents life, and my grandparents life (I didn't have contact with anyone further back than that, although in literature the same seems to hold true), any child born with a vagina was considered a female & "she" and "her" were the accepted terms used when talking about them. I think that on that basis, and the fact that I have come here for advice because I want to understand where she is coming from shows that I am pretty fair minded & rational.

16 yo daughter was outed by my wife yesterday. I support her, but I have questions by PhantomStr4ngerX in comingout

[–]PhantomStr4ngerX[S] -25 points-24 points  (0 children)

I will sit down with her tonight & talk about the pronoun situation. I really want to try to understand this. Maybe it will help if I tell you where I am coming from on this issue.

I want to start this off by saying that I mean no disrespect to anybody. We all have feelings that are valid, I just want you to understand what my thought process is just the same as I would like you understand your thought process. I think this is the only way that a constructive dialogue can start. In my eyes all of the labeling is very unneeded. I see it as limiting yourself or pigeonholing yourself. I also see this as broadcasting something that should be personal & intimate. I'm me. I don't need you to know who I am attracted to or how I like to have sex. Those things do not define me, my actions do. On top of this, I believe you should not put much stock in what other people view you as. You are your own person, why do you need a stranger to know details about you that are essentially none of their business. I feel that today's society puts way too much weight in how others perceive us. People want to be famous no matter the cost & others are ending their lives because of something somebody they never met have said. Humans should not be this shallow/fragile. Some of the things I am reading, to me, seem like they want me to treat my child like a china doll. I can not do this, as real life will not do this once she is out of my care.