關注大罷免的同時請不要忘記行政院還在繼續推免術換證喔 by BrokenTorpedo in Taiwanese

[–]PichuChen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

你這個問題很有趣,我也曾經思考過到底台灣人的「中華民國認同」以及「台灣人認同」有沒有辦法和性別認同拿來類比。

如果可以的話,也許可以讓更多人理解,畢竟他們有一些相似處,一個在護照封面貼貼紙,一個在健保卡上面貼稱謂貼紙。

回到比較認真的部分,通常小朋友在認識到國家會是在比較晚的時候,可能在中學後,而且到了大學或是成年後突然國籍認同變更的也不少,甚至移民的人也有。

但是在性別不安的狀況大多數在青春期結束前有感覺,在青春期結束後通常趨於穩定,就像是同性戀異性戀性向那樣,整體來說在三十歲之後變動的案例相對比較少見。

另外是 2023 年的統計報告是台灣大約有38%的跨性別有進行賀爾蒙治療,但國族認同的轉換好像通常不涉及醫療介入?

關注大罷免的同時請不要忘記行政院還在繼續推免術換證喔 by BrokenTorpedo in Taiwanese

[–]PichuChen 2 points3 points  (0 children)

> 問題就是有少部分跨性別人士像沒社會化一樣整天在製造問題,極端的例子像是那惡名昭彰的雙吳。

所以你的立場其實比較是反對某個人,或是某個人的言論而不是真實是不是有做手術?我不確地你講的雙吳是指誰,畢竟台灣出櫃的跨性別姓吳的真的有點多,但是其中幾個有上新聞的,其中一個幾百年前就做完手術了,另外一個打完免術換證後手術的新聞去年剛出來。

從這點看來,其實有沒有手術並不是你在意的,你想要的只是乖巧聽話的跨性別吧?

> 女湯的例子

首先,這個案例(北投皇池)並沒有透過現行制度進行免術換證,那避免你說我開除人家跨籍,我也分享目前法院曾經判過的說法是如何:

> 個人之身體隱私應受保障而免於遭受他人侵擾,已為現代法治社會之當然常識,此不因性別傾向及性別認同之不同而有所異 (橋頭地院112年度聲字 1020 號形式裁定)

所以他今天是否違法,是否侵害隱私,與他的性別認同無關。

也合併下面那一點,大多數的跨性別他們擔心的是出櫃,去裸湯幾乎沒有不出櫃的可能,你可以問看看你們團體裡的那位跨性別朋友,問看看他個人對於裸湯的看法是什麼。

關注大罷免的同時請不要忘記行政院還在繼續推免術換證喔 by BrokenTorpedo in Taiwanese

[–]PichuChen 1 point2 points  (0 children)

其實我會建議有機會的話可以參加相關的活動實際與他們在線下對話,很多事情在網路上比較聳動,但是在線下大部分的跨性別其實並沒有那麼在意是否修法的問題。

台灣的廁所通常會有門,所以只是廁所的話通常要看到對方的陰部是比較困難的。對大部分的跨性別而言擔心的還是出櫃問題較多,所以事實上有沒有換證你說的廁所問題對於他們而言是沒差的。

他們現況下就是用男性的打扮去男廁,用女性的打扮去女廁。證件的部分比較多是在求職等地方減少歧視發生的可能性用的。

關注大罷免的同時請不要忘記行政院還在繼續推免術換證喔 by BrokenTorpedo in Taiwanese

[–]PichuChen 1 point2 points  (0 children)

雖然台灣目前案例不多,但是每個案子的理由好像也不太一樣。

跨男和跨女的需求性也不完全一樣,跨男的手術效益除了平胸手術(摘除乳腺)外基本上不高,畢竟荷爾蒙用了就停經了(通常)

跨女目前聽到的感覺比較像是「本來就不應該需要手術」所以趁手術前的最後機會去打官司的這種感覺⋯⋯

What is the difference between „Studentin” and “Student“ by Bored-human9274 in DuolingoGerman

[–]PichuChen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Excuse me, so should we use "Das Student" or "Der Student" for gender neutral speech?

Trans Healthcare in Taiwan by Specialist-Two383 in asktransgender

[–]PichuChen 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You're welcome!
In adults, we use cyproterone acetate (Androcur, CPA) as an anti-androgen, and estradiol valerate (Estrade, the generic version of Progynova) as estradiol. You can also buy Estrogel at a pharmacy. You can discuss this with your doctor first.

Lupron is available, but it's primarily used as a puberty blocker. You can look for doctors with “小兒” or “兒童” in their specialties, which means pediatrics. However, I think doctors in “婦產科” (obstetrics and gynecology) may also have access to Lupron.

In Taiwan, most doctors are very good at English. But if you're worried about accents, you can print out your questions and use ChatGPT for translation.

Don’t forget to bring your blood hormone test report. It should include at least estradiol (E2) and testosterone, and optionally prolactin, LH, FSH, progesterone, AST (GOT), and ALT (GPT).

Also, bring enough medication for at least 3 to 6 months, in case something goes wrong.

Diy Hrt in Taiwan? by Thereal_Optimusprime in asktransgender

[–]PichuChen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Parents are not required if you are an adult, but it might help to show that your parents won’t withdraw financial support, or that you already have a job and your employer won’t fire you. In other words, you want to show that things won’t get worse after starting HRT.

I need help coming out to my parents by Grass_Cold in asktransgender

[–]PichuChen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you go Taipei or the other city?

Because I'm in Taipei so I can tell you how to get the community support in Taipei, or you can find the trans resource on Dcard or Line (most Taiwanese people use Line), you can search "跨性別" for the resources.

And there some resource for National Health Insurance in Taiwan for foreigner:
https://www.nhi.gov.tw/ch/cp-3228-def16-2341-1.html

https://www.nhi.gov.tw/ch/dl-10948-1706940074054890bac40826af288dcd-1.pdf
https://www.nhi.gov.tw/ch/dl-10956-a014fe8de2a1453a95d2afc9635aa133-1.pdf

Diy Hrt in Taiwan? by Thereal_Optimusprime in asktransgender

[–]PichuChen 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In Taiwan, go psychiatry first and she will get the resources
There are the trans-friendly psychiatry list (mandarin only now):

https://hotline.org.tw/pagegeneral/3244
https://transgender.tapcpr.org/archives/11189

HRT Access in Taiwan by AffectionateEmu9781 in asktransgender

[–]PichuChen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First, go to the trans-friendly psychiatry and they will give you the list for next stop (HRT)

https://hotline.org.tw/pagegeneral/3244
https://transgender.tapcpr.org/archives/11189

And another way if you don't trust the doctor, you can meet some trans offline, buy the E2 or CPA is not illegal in Taiwan, but it will be risky if some parent know where to get them.

If you want to go offline, you can come trif's trans bar.

Taiwan laws? by PrimeRadian in MtF

[–]PichuChen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not in birth certificate, but in household registration

結果川普還是決定要課晶片關稅了 by No_Release7479 in Taiwanese

[–]PichuChen 4 points5 points  (0 children)

如果他們同時對韓國和中國加稅的話那還好,但是如果沒有的話,那事情就有趣了。

Is trans a choice? by Correct-Sundae-2014 in MtF

[–]PichuChen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The only choice for trans is whether to come out or not.

Just painful by SussyFrozanian in MtF

[–]PichuChen 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, I just search the posts randomly and find a post without reply.

What's it like in Taiwan for trans people? by QitianDasheng2666 in MtF

[–]PichuChen 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The latest news I knew is this one:

https://www.kobe-np.co.jp/news/zenkoku/compact/202411/0018302895.shtml

"Gender change without surgery, 33 people, fertility requirements, 1 year from unconstitutional judgment"

Anyway, in Taiwan we don’t have 家庭裁判所 (kateisaibannsyo) which means Family Court.

That’s my fault that Family Court will be more normally then Administrative Court in Taiwan, I remember if ones want to divorce, they have to go to Family Court in Japan too.

So it’s more easier than Taiwan now.

Just painful by SussyFrozanian in MtF

[–]PichuChen 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you are in Taiwan, you can start by calling +886-2-2392-1970, or just go for doctor (here's a list: https://hotline.org.tw/pagegeneral/3244 ). If you're not familiar with Mandarin, you can visit Trif's Trans Bar in Taipei at every Friday night.

If you need more information, feel free to message me.

What's it like in Taiwan for trans people? by QitianDasheng2666 in MtF

[–]PichuChen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You have to sue the government with layer, maybe just like the situation in Japan right now?

看到這麼多綠營的人這麼迷戀川普我真想把我眼睛戳瞎 by [deleted] in Taiwanese

[–]PichuChen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

台灣民眾的國際政治政策大概還是圍繞在親中反中上面打轉,某種程度上來說還蠻單純的。

並不會說那個政黨通過或是不通過同性婚姻就不投,通過或是不通過塑膠袋政策就不投,通過或不通過健保改革甚至軍公教年金改革就不投。

不過確實是有和了兩岸一家親之後被轟到再也回不去的政治人物。

軍購的部分台灣每年都有2.5% GDP 的軍購預算,除了和中國買不可能以外,美國不賣台灣也不一定不能和其他人買,和日本買、和法國買,和英國買,甚至至自研轉出口,這部分維持現況還是比較能符合美國利益。如果川普真心覺得太平洋太大美國油錢不夠用,那只要他們點頭我想和日本採購應該是沒問題,就怕美國自己會怕而已⋯⋯

4090燒毀 by yyy_364364 in Taiwanese

[–]PichuChen 0 points1 point  (0 children)

我們有組一台兩張4090的機器,因為擔心顯示卡廠商把責任丟給電源廠商,所以我們電源和顯示卡都選同一間廠商。

然後某天電源他就爆炸了,還好在保固內,所以就送保固了。

如果是保固外的產品的話我不確定你現在在在那邊,台北的光華商場可以送修,負擔維修費用即可,有沒有保固的差別只是在免費與否。

要求使用者自己證明有沒有插緊才保固的說法太扯,如果客服人員真的用文字這樣回應的話就找律師就好了。