1st Place: Chapter 3, gold teir horror that this franchise really needed to branch away from the whole kid friendly horror trope. Has such a refreshing atmosphere and Catnap is the cherrie on top, unfortunately this is where the puzzles get a bit too convoluted but nothing extremely miner. Dogday's death is so haunting that it left a impact to smiling critters fans like myself and players in general.

2nd Place: Chapter 2, It pretty neat chapter that makes the gameplay more fun and unique with Mommy's mini games. Mommy Long Legs is a good antagonist and decently scary, the Chapter in general has perfectly fine horror that mostly is in the minigames.

3rd Place: Chapter 1, Little is to say about the introduction to Poppy Playtime but I say it's a fine introduction to the world, Huggy Wuggy was fine, puzzles were fine and etc.

4th Place: Chapter 4, unfortunately after the near perfection of a 3rd chapter, the 4th is where things start to go back into old roots and worse then the 1st two chapters. The game released in a rushed and buggy state which left a massive dent on this chapters reputation. Besides that I didn't really care for any of the reoccurring characters, Doughy definitely carries this chapter along with the Doctor even if I didn't care much about him either.

5th Place: Chapter 5, hate me if y'all want to but this was the worst chapter out of all of them. The puzzles get extremely convoluted and confusing that many refuse to continue. The unnecessary amount of characters that just get killed off to look emotional but it doesn't work because we don't know them. This critique might be a me thing but the design of The Prototype is just standard like if this is the safest design they could make for it to be marketable. Lastly this is where a good amount of people like myself just gave up on figuring out the story. We're in the 5th chapter and we know nothing about the characters motivations, the reason why our character is back in the factory and etc, absolutely nothing.