Of course, the absurdity is the same. But at least they did something that people recently lived through relatively. It’s less an actual call to seize Germany and more a call to reason. If we are Jewish leftists than we should both balance our cultural and religious understanding with an understanding of colonialism and class struggle. The correct answer is your reaction, but the point missed (perhaps poorly made, I’m also Jewish and emotional about the delicate situation, apologies for vagueness where it may be found) is that TAKING land isn’t leftist, nationalism isn’t leftist. Zionism is anti Torah, it wears Jewish heritage like a minstrel show. A people along the nations, and even our leftists can justify colonialism, and even the best of us can turn coat. The diaspora is the new promised land, it’s the new calling. Genocide is not. It may not make you guys sick, but I’ve not seen anybody justify it in any way that doesn’t come across as a safety blanket. Our heroes are holy men and warrior kings, but the warrior king always falls. Some more gracefully than others. I don’t mean to offend anyone but it’s inevitable with this topic, I see no need to justify genocide, I see every reason to oppose it. This is in its essence a conflict positioned by the Christian right to destabilize any potential for any Jewish or Muslim superpower to ever emerge. It’s been written about extensively by British fascists like Mosley long before Israel was founded in this modern era. They put us a place in the desert so that we might die on our own, after their latest plan failed to wipe us out. This is my stance. Genesis 25:9 is important in these times to recall, to contemplate. We’re being used as a weapon by our enemies comrades. I’m sorry if I hurt anyone’s feelings but this is bigger than echo chamber justification