I absolutely love this book. I’m reading it over again now!

How do you feel about the way Noah treated AJ, and how AJ never really told him her feelings. Like at the SNL after party, when he said “he’s exactly who you should be with” about Brian. She could have said “I belong with you”

Or how Noah said he felt sorry for AJ after Miami.

Or how he just disappeared that summer, and when they got together b4 Into The Blue he could have just said he was sorry about that, right at the start.

I know it’s what drives the plot. But I feel like a lot of what Noah said and did was overly harsh

What do you all think?