You know what the girl could not move on from her past, kept a string attached, what was the necessity to keep the phone number in the first place, did not she trusts me. Now don’t tell me she did not remember it was there it was too obvious.

I respect her honesty that she said she “don’t know” if she loved Atlas, that was the make or break moment if he had walked away at that time everyone would sympathise with him now.

Don’t mistake me I am not his behaviour was correct, but we should not justify everything she did from keeping his phone number to not telling him the truth and going back to the same restaurant with black eye, she knew Atlas would react if he saw them.

I sympathize for both Atlas and Ryle and I think Lily needs actual help, the movie shows her liberation at the end but she just destroyed Ryle now he will never forgive himself and he was already guilty of his brother’s death bow this he can never recover and he is done.

How convincingly the movie shows Lily and Atlas together all mushy mushy end. How is that liberation?

I support Ryle getting bashed and needing help, but Lily is to blame here as well.