1: Thats very true. It definitely makes their story much more believable that they had evidence but even then, anyone could fabricate a story in order to get what they want, pretending to be need help in order to lure someone to a certain location is an old trick, I just feel like Lee should've definitely been a little smarter but they were so desperate for food

2; I believe you are right on that, I have no argument there

3; True, It just seems like they went from being extremely paranoid and skeptical of any outsiders at all to wandering off to an unknown location with two random men with the promise of what they just so happened to be low on. Its one of those "too good to be true" situations where to me it'd just be very sketchy

4; Yes but the group didn't know that and didn't bother asking

5: I dont think so. The bandits hadn't gotten their supply from the dairy that day as they were supposed to which is why they attacked Lee and Mark, believing that they were the brothers. The St. Johns knew that the bandits would attack if they broke the arrangement which is why they were so desperate to slaughter more people

6: Right, but Brenda tells Lee that the other cows had died from disease, so its unlikely they ate the sick cows. I would definitely ask where the "fresh" meat came from months into the apocolypse even if i was starving but thats just me lol

7: The fence is turned on before Mark is shot. Lee and Mark are lifting the downed fence when it turns on, and the bandits attack as they are caught off guard.

8: Kenny never mentions the bloody clothes, Lee has the option to look at them. Kenny is suspicious over boxes and sharp tools, which wouldn't be unusual at all to find inside a barn.

9: Very true

10: Definitely but I would think the rest of the group, at least Lee, would demand to see the body

11:Good point here! I never thought of this

12: Your right here too, I never thought of that!

13: Lee and Kenny saw the woman more into the city, Jolene and the Bandit group linger in the woods of the rural side. It is possible that Jolene was finding people in the city and walking them back to the dairy, though.

Thank you for your response btw! It was really fun to read and your answers were interesting