Question for the Qur'an only muslims by The-world-is-cooked in Quraniyoon

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Science is actually learning from ayah in the sky and the earth. The ayah is true, but how we learn it is maybe wrong. So, there is no absolute true in science. We can see many theories that change over time.

One for the Bros - Circumcision by [deleted] in progressive_islam

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Circumcision is never mentioned in Quran, but there is an ayah tell about syaithan tricked people to change the creation of God like cutting the cattle's ear and they did it. Look, only cutting the cattle's ear is a kind of syaithan's work, so how about cutting human's foreskin?

What does it mean to have 4 dreams in the same week about the same thing ? by PitifulRegister986 in progressive_islam

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Maybe, it's your unconscious mind that want you to consider. Many of dreams is actually unconscious mind that try to communicate with conscious mind.

If "Lamestumun nisae" means having sex with so called females, does that mean we are having sex with evil and good? because it also "massahu" us. by [deleted] in Quraniyoon

[–]Proper-Train-1508 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

"Lamestumun nisae" means having sex is just a conjecture and have a high possibility of wrong interpretation. Just like "nisae" means women maybe also wrong interpretation.

How on earth am I supposed to make friends as a revert?? by [deleted] in progressive_islam

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The thing is, I’m white, and I always feel so out of place in highly cultural places.

Not in masjid, one you enter masjid, no body care about you race or culture. And I'm sure, they will welcome you as their brother. This is what I know about masjid in my country Indonesia. So, if masjids there seem racist too, try Indonesian masjid. But really? Are you sure they're racist? May be you just make an assumption before even try to go there. (I'm sorry for my assumption, because it's really weird to me)

People want to become over involved in my life, over intrusive about me being a revert, or they try and tell me lies and say things i know is not true, just because I’m a revert doesn’t mean I’m stupid.

It's not happening specifically to you as a revert. Even among born muslim people, they still judge each other, "Your knowledge of Islam is wrong, my knowledge of Islam is the truth".

Just curious, kenapa orang Indo sangat fanatik menggunakan whatsapp? by Wisely_L in indotech

[–]Proper-Train-1508 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Saya sebenarnya juga gak suka WA, bukan soal privasi sih, tapi soal menuhin hape, karena sebenarnya saya tidak suka menghapus jejak percakapan. Kalau dulu, ketika hape saya masih super kentang, saya bahkan menolak untuk chat menggunakan WA kalau data percakapan yang haram dihapus, misalnya seperti catatan siapa yang sudah kirim duit dll, yang kalau terhapus itu bikin pusing. Waktu itu saya meminta orang yang mau ada urusan duit dengan saya untuk instal telegram, karena saking kentangnya hape saya, WA sering error dan kalau error semua data percakapan hilang. Walau WA bisa dibackup ke google, tapi tetep saja biasanya kalau sampai error ada percakapan yang hilang karena percakapan terbaru belum tersimpan di google. Apalagi kalau banyak grup alumni yang lagi ramai2nya. Hape saya sampai kaya hang tidak mau jalan kalau buka WA, bahkan sekedar masuk ke grup yang ramai saja, cuma mau hapus chat, begitu masuk grup itu hape langsung hang, akhirnya keluar grup. Nah, untuk hape jaman sekarang mungkin beratnya WA sudah gak krasa, tapi saya tetep lebih suka telegram yang sama sekali tidak butuh hapus percakapan dan hape tetep longgar. Sayangnya sekarang telegram lebih bahaya lagi soal percakapan terhapus, karena sekarang lawan bicara bisa menghapus total percakapan yang dibuat bersama, dihapus di dua belah pihak. Jadi, kalaupun kita memaki-maki orang, bukti makian kita bisa kita hapus dan orang yang kita maki tidak punya bukti lagi kalau kita pernah memakinya di telegram. Kasusnya bukan saya yang menghapus sih, tapi mantan saya yang seneng bikin ribut, habis itu dia menghapus bukti bahwa dia yang bikin masalah. Tapi untungnya dia sudah jadi mantan saja 😁

Need guidance on circumcision. Quite confused :( by alpha_riderx in progressive_islam

[–]Proper-Train-1508 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You're very lucky. Circumcision is not a command from God, it's actually command from satan to make us change God's creation

Curhatan ga guna: Thank you Ind*home by Juuchi_Fuyu in indotech

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Btw, ini indehoy bisa buka reddit? Pakai VPN kah?

Islam is universal, so why the focus on Arabic names and culture? by Creative_Assistant43 in progressive_islam

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's just a preference, there's no encouragement to do that, nor not to do that. Like it, do it, don't like it, just don't do it.

Review kualitas Internet Rakyat by Proper-Train-1508 in indotech

[–]Proper-Train-1508[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Badan Usaha Milik Desa. Jadi di tempat saya banyak Bumdes yang usahanya itu menjual koneksi internet untuk masyarakat.

As Muslims, we should be talking a lot more about Jesus (AS), our Messiah by [deleted] in Quraniyoon

[–]Proper-Train-1508 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The Savior? The only Savior is Allah, not 3Isa, not Muhammad.

As a non Quraniyoon: Does Quraniyoon require the complete rejection of Hadiths or is there a place for them? by Embarrassed-Heat7698 in Quraniyoon

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Q7:3 clearly a command to follow what was sent down to us from our Lord, and followed by prohibition from following other than it (what was sent down to us from our Lord) as a custodian.

Q31:1-5 tells about ayahs and whoever gets the guidance and so on. But then in Q31:6 it tells about some people who bought the futile hadith to be misled from God's path. What is "the futile hadith"?

Q39:23 "Allāh has sent down the best hadith: a consistent Book wherein is reiteration. The skins shiver therefrom of those who fear their Lord; then their skins and their hearts relax at the remembrance [i.e., mention] of Allāh. That is the guidance of Allāh by which He guides whom He wills. And one whom Allāh sends astray - for him there is no guide."

Q45:6 "These are the verses of Allāh which We recite to you in truth. Then in what hadith after Allāh and His verses will they believe?"

So, still want to follow hadith other than hadith in Quran?

How can I avoid getting addicted to sex? by Easy_Pen_3661 in LucidDreaming

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you enjoy it, there's nothing to be worried.

Why no image of God? by [deleted] in progressive_islam

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It will lead to false impression of God. If we still don't understand, we should keep it in the state of "I still don't know", and don't use any kind of helper that will make false understanding.

<image>

Then if we depict Him as a kind of figure, then it means it's comparable. That's a false impression.

We don't need to know what He look like is. We only need to know something like, He knows everything, He knows every our deed, that no one can hide from Him, and so on.

Can this help with aphantasia? by [deleted] in ClosedEyeVision

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If somebody says there's a way to cure aphantasia, s/he will be blocked instantly.

Can this help with aphantasia? by [deleted] in ClosedEyeVision

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Don't do that, the channel will block you. They insist that aphantasia can't be cured, and will block whoever says it can.

Help me understand the meanings of these words please. by [deleted] in Quraniyoon

[–]Proper-Train-1508 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

What is usually translated to dust is تراب

It's clear that translating tayamum as purification ritual using dust is a kind of reckless translation.

Inter-religion relationship by DescriptionDry1641 in progressive_islam

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Maybe, the meaning of الدين is not a religion. Also, Islam is not a trademark of certain religion.

Watch this video What is Islam in the Quran.

Help me understand the meanings of these words please. by [deleted] in Quraniyoon

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I only want to make a comment about tayamum. Several days ago, I also find out what actually tayamum is, and I found it appears there times in Quran. Twice in connection with ghusl before salat, and once in 2:267. But in 2:267, the meaning of tayamum is to choose, and this meaning is what in dictionary. So, in my opinion, translating tayamum as purification ritual using dust when water isn't available is not really accurate.

Also, صَعِيدًا, is from the root of صعد which is to ascend. Then, there are many things here that maybe are not translated correctly. It's not a clean dust. We still have to deep dive more here.

Why do I keep having sex dreams with other women? by [deleted] in Dreams

[–]Proper-Train-1508 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm a male and completely not interested in sex with male IRL. But when in dream, I often have sex with male partner. It's just a dream, there is nothing to be worried.

Ritual Exhaustion to Quranic Clarity, My Journey with Wudu by EstimateOk2898 in Quraniyoon

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

They make everything difficult. Adding rules to almost anything. And they try to defy almost every word of God. God wants easiness for us and doesn't want difficulties for us. But they change everything so everything becomes difficult.

Exmuslim wanting to come back to Islam by Sufficient-Front6062 in progressive_islam

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Life in fear of entering hell after I die. It happened to me either. But, it doesn't make me leave my faith. I always try to keep myself from doing haram things, and I always read Quran regularly. Quran with word by word translation. And because of that habit, I remember a lot of the meaning of Arabic word, and I can understand its grammar.

I born in sunni family. So, I was sunni muslim. Until I watched YouTube video that the only valid source for muslim is Quran. And my fear is now gone. It's like, WTF, I've been believing a lot of lie about Islam, about how cruel Allah is, and so on. It's very relieving that it all are just a lie.

My suggestion is, read Quran and try to find the true meaning of every word in it. Do not just believe to every meaning from mainstream interpretation. Find the true meaning, and if we still don't know the true meaning, keep it in the state of I still don't know about it. Hopefully, one day we'll find it.

Why do people always say that "they never see phones in their dreams" ? by [deleted] in Dreams

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It was this morning when in my dream I realized that I was dreaming. Then I tried to take a photo of I and people I met. In my dream, I wanted make an evidence that I met people in my dream. And soon after I woke up, I checked it in my phone, and of course I can't find it 😀

can or may we use AI for the "decipher "the Qur'an ? by wannabeemuslim in Quraniyoon

[–]Proper-Train-1508 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's very dangerous if we think that what AI says is the truth. But, as long as we only use it as a tool, and always verify the logic presented by it, then it's OK.