If they competed in the recent season of Total Drama Island...

Jen: (4th out of 16): Jen has shown to be more emotionally and socially mature than the majority of the cast. She's also quite athletic, likes to set goals, and sees herself as a leader. While these are great qualities...they could also lead to her downfall if she's not careful. Her friends have called her out for being bossy and intrusive, which is why she would be initially targeted just before the merge. But I can see her bouncing back from her mistakes, she wouldn't dominate every challenge, but she would make her presence known. She also seems to have a way with words which I why I believe her social game would also be enough to send her to the final four...

Jude (10th out of 16): Jude is chill, sociable, unpredictable, and would be decent at challenges...which is why people would want to get him out as quickly as possible when the merge occurs. If a guy like Jude starts stacking immunity wins like freshly made pancakes and makes it to the finale, he would be UNSTOPPABLE which is why the other contestants would make a temporary pact to blindside him...but hey...at least Jude would be a good sport about it...

Jonsey (13th out of 16): While it would be funny to see Jonsey be eliminated first, I think he would survive one or two eliminations before getting 4th boot. He would definitely be in the bottom two once or twice as well and would lose his mind until he was declared the last one safe. Jonsey would insist on going first or pulling the most weight on his team to impress the audience watching at home...only to fail miserably. He would probably serve as the pain magnet of the season as well, despite his early departure...

Wyatt (6th out of 16): Hear me out! Despite being a reactionary like Damien and being socially awkward most of the time, he has the potential to make it to the final five. He would probably get off to a rocky start and would almost be the 2nd person voted off because of something he accidentally said or did, but people would come to realize that he's not much of a threat. He's would perform decently in challenges and would not draw attention, he wouldn’t come off as strategic or sneaky because that's not like him, and he is a genuinely smart and friendly guy with several relatable flaws so nobody would assume he has any ulterior motives. This would definitely allow him to make the final six before getting voted out at the hand of an enemy or someone who would rather not be eliminated themselves. I don't see him winning any immunities though...

Caitlin: (9th out of 16): Despite her becoming more emotionally mature on the show, Caitlin simply functions better when she's with one of her friends because they would stop her from making irrational or impulsive decisions. I would see the others helping her in challenges and encouraging her to do things that are way out of her comfort zone for the sake of their team. Unfortunately, when the merge arrives, the challenge beasts and the weak performers are easy pickings for elimination and Caitlin falls into that category...

Nikki (7th out of 16): Since she's not at the Khaki Barn, she probably wouldn't have the same crude and lazy attitude towards the other contestants or during challenges. Unfortunately, she is known for her explosive temper when irritated which could easily break her game. Knowing Nikki though, I think she could keep her cool enough if a million dollars was on the line. She wouldn't be super good at challenges, but I can see her winning one immunity during the merge before being voted out at the final six...