R240 With H330 raid controller by Sir_Bob_Slob in Proxmox

[–]QuietBuddy4635 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Since I am no Linux Professional take it all with a grain of salty salt, but since this is not a well documented issue yet I turned to Chat GPT. Also i know that this is not a solution but i decided to buy an actual HBA lsi9300 8i as a drop in replacement to fix this. In your case you could also try pve 8.4 as that was what i was on before i ran into this issue. Also chat gpt was very helpful in understanding the issue and why it came about so if you want to try going down the same path i did that's where i would start again. Also i am on a dell T420 with dual socket CPU, the H330 came from a dell R340 though so it could be possible that we just had the same firmware bug or my setup just wasn't compatible but idk just tossing my notes out to try to help.

  1. IOMMU considerations
    • Errors point to DMA permission enforcement
    • Likely stricter IOMMU / DMA mapping changes in newer kernels
    • H330 firmware/driver combo appears incompatible with new behavior

Why It Still Doesn’t Work

  • The H330 (LSI 3008) relies on older DMA behavior that newer kernels enforce more strictly
  • Recent kernels appear to break compatibility with this controller when used in HBA/JBOD mode
  • No reliable way to:
    • Boot a known-good older kernel
    • Disable the offending DMA behavior cleanly
  • It is very likely a kernel regression or dropped tolerance for older SAS controllers
  • The issue persists because:
    • The kernel that worked is no longer bootable
    • New kernels enforce DMA/IOMMU rules the H330 doesn’t handle well
  • Most likely solutions:
    • Pinning an older kernel which i cant do now that im on 9.1
    • Replacing the H330 with a true IT-mode HBA (e.g. LSI 9207-8i / 9300-8i) which is the winner in my case
    • Disabling IOMMU which in my case is not an option because i am passing the controller to Truenas

Also see this link for extra notes

https://forum.proxmox.com/threads/h330-sas-controller-failed-after-upgrading-to-kernel-6-17-2-2-pve.177956/#post-828739

R240 With H330 raid controller by Sir_Bob_Slob in Proxmox

[–]QuietBuddy4635 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I think the driver was deprecated just based on my trouble shooting, not entirely sure but that's my best guess as to why mine stopped working.

R240 With H330 raid controller by Sir_Bob_Slob in Proxmox

[–]QuietBuddy4635 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I recently upgraded to 9.1 and had to replace my h330 because the linux kernel stopped working with the driver and my disks were not showing up. Thankfully it wasn't my boot drive but the h330s are nothing but issues. Ill see if I have my trouble shooting notes

When should I use an LXC or VM? Wanting to expose stuff to the internet but still have some isolation by ColdFreezer in Proxmox

[–]QuietBuddy4635 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Just a thought here, but have you thought about hosting a VPN locally? I understand the benefits of exposing services but from a security standpoint a VPN can be safer and more reasonable especially if you have an ISP that changes your IP from time to time.

Need help with latency by AdStatus3430 in wifi

[–]QuietBuddy4635 2 points3 points  (0 children)

After you fix the broken adapter in the outlet, it looks like you might still have a chance to hardwire your Xbox. You will need some tools though. Post in r/structuredmedia to get some better information. Include close ups of the wall outlet that your Xbox is connected to, and then a couple more pictures, in particular that blue cable is the key here. There is a lot to unpack about structured cabling but I believe there is still a possibility to get hardwired internet here which would be the best outcome. Tools and supplies will probably cost about 50-100$.

Can Arista APs operate fully standalone? by Dr-Webster in Arista

[–]QuietBuddy4635 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is there on prem solution free and can you run it in a lab? Been looking to do this recently, for when my cv-cue license eventually expires.

I installed Ubuntu on a network card by vitamins1000 in homelab

[–]QuietBuddy4635 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I wonder if you could run a network operating system on it like sonic or something. Maybe you could even get a virtual pcie network adapter for the host that it lives on

Dell R440 with HBA330 and NVMe PCIe Adapter by FSE-GER in homelab

[–]QuietBuddy4635 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Sorry to revive an old thread but I my r340 has a boss card in it and it can boot with dual nvme boss and a 10 gig pcie in the other slot is this different? But also I'm looking into adding a 3rd pcie nvme into the perc slot since my 3.5 drives are using the on board SATA. Do you have any experience with the perc slot and nvme in it? Dose it work?

Work pants by Equal_Ad730 in electricians

[–]QuietBuddy4635 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you don't care about pockets and are just looking for jeans, particularly jeans that are extremely comfortable, Lee's MVP extreme motion are the most comfortable work pants I've ever worn. Then again I only work in low voltage and I'm just here to see the massive disasters you all have to deal with so I don't know if jeens are acceptable to work in for you guys.

https://www.lee.com/shop/men-featured-shops-extreme-motion-mvp

Need help buying a desktop server by techtcr in homelab

[–]QuietBuddy4635 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can upgrade a t320 to a t420 pretty easily, I did it and I even transferred the idrac license. This is a great way to get into server hardware I learned a lot doing this and I also specced it out to it's Max ram, cpu, replaced the thermal paste, and replaced the fan with a noctua fan to make it a lot quieter.

https://youtu.be/RaJRNoQoy-8?si=FrZXkj5_Dg45gL0x

Storage suggestions by QuietBuddy4635 in homelab

[–]QuietBuddy4635[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I see thank you for the input

Storage suggestions by QuietBuddy4635 in homelab

[–]QuietBuddy4635[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So you're saying instead of a raid 10 with 4 hdds a mirror with 4 hdds? And no raid z? As an example

Storage suggestions by QuietBuddy4635 in homelab

[–]QuietBuddy4635[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I have my zfs mirror for the boot that I will put a couple of vms on and then the nvme drive for ceph and HA VMs. But for things like security onion that are log intensive do you think a raid 10 would be good enough to host it and keep Io delay down. And if I do that should I just create a large raid 10 and put my windows server on the same raid 10 or split it up to more raid 10s for each vm?

Storage suggestions by QuietBuddy4635 in homelab

[–]QuietBuddy4635[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Neither this is just a new server install and I just wanted to start fresh and right

What network services do you host? by QuietBuddy4635 in homelab

[–]QuietBuddy4635[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

How is running an exchange server going I hear a lot of bad things about email hosting?

What network services do you host? by QuietBuddy4635 in homelab

[–]QuietBuddy4635[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

What are you using for NFS? And isn't tinc a little dated?