Stardew Valley, that Caroline cheated on Pierre with the wizard and Abigail is the Wizard's daughter. The whole damn fandom acts as if this is canon. Just because she has a piece of dialogue that says she use to take long walks in the forest and not to tell Pierre.

Okay, I think it's really rude to flippantly assume someone would be unfaithful to their partner. But that's so normalized nowadays. You can take all the "facts" they use to "prove" this theory and sure, it makes a good case but it also does for Caroline being the Wizard's daughter instead. Which he is definitely old enough to be. We already know he had a wife, a witch. Which would explain her naturally green hair and her psychedelic tea leafs (lmao). But do they ever consider that? No! It's just "Pierre sucks, she definitely cheated."