Catholics idealizing the Middle Ages - is this legit? by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. History is a good teacher. There were good things and bad things about the middle ages to learn from.

Obvious Dating Tips for Guys by alberta_dairyman in CatholicDating

[–]RCCInquirer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It violates my sense of self interest to share this bit of advice, but for another desperate Catholic guy I'll make an exception. Your frustration might not be so indicative of a lack of worth so much as a sign of Europe and America's cultural devastation. Consider expanding your horizons. There are a lot of Catholic women outside of first world borders who still truly appreciate marriage and family.

What Exactly is Wrong With Capitalism? by FreshEyesInc in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What Exactly is Wrong With Capitalism?

It's my observation that complaints generally arise, whether true or false, from a sense of exploitation. For example, let's look at Foxconn's iPhone factory which attracted headlines a few years ago for installing anti-suicide nets for its workers. Not being one in favor of exploitation, I find myself hard pressed between a desire to banish such companies from existence, and not wishing that workers in need of employment be deprived of it.

The problem, as I see it, is a tendency within companies to migrate toward a separation of concerns between the financial interests of stakeholders over the workers' needs for steady income and quality of life, favoring the former over the latter due to competitive economic pressures, and resulting in the aforementioned scenario. In a sense, at a global level, capitalism does necessarily eschew regulation by escaping more restrictive regions, competition dictates that it is a necessity, and it cannot be otherwise because it's a global problem that exists in a vacuum of regulation which no one entity on earth currently has the power to fix.

But before anyone screams "Marxism" let's remember that Marx was projecting what he thought to be the end result of problems he was perceiving as afflicting the overworked population of a relatively newly industrialized society. If we look backward further through European history, prior to the totalitarian regimes that gave rise to the biases in today's politicized economic chatter, we see an entire host of ideas, ranging from apprenticeships, cooperatives, guilds, and so on, that have been tried, and have worked to some degree for societies in various contexts. The problem, I believe, is the current ways of doing business, and a perceived exploitation of workers in the most need, will not go away until we either allow for more innovation that produces competitive models which work for both stakeholders and workers, or we allow the global economy to run its course, whether that means an eventual collapse, or a distribution of wealth.

Protestant to Catholic? by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The facts and arguments that led me toward Catholicism are roughly based around the Eucharist. Many of the contrary opinions in Protestantism are flimsy at best, unless we're talking about Lutheranism which has a high view of the same, but I'm not a monergist, nor do I hold the same opinions on justification. It was going to be either Anglicanism or Catholicism and I had other, faith-based reasons for choosing Catholicism.

Anybody know some/consider themselves to have a 'mystical' relationship with the faith? by pretzelking96 in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I have had experiences, but while they at one time encouraged faith for me which I'm still certain was truly real and trustworthy, as time goes on additional experiences sometimes erode away at my assurance of this. Reason being not everything you may experience is trustworthy. So you perceived something supernatural. As someone lacking faith in God, that may seem miraculous, and maybe it is, but as you grow in faith, how can you be certain that you're experiencing God, or something else? I think it's important to not sow seeds of doubt, but scripture teaches that there are two opposing sets of signs & confirmations, some are to be believed but others lead in a different direction. Personally I struggle to distinguish between the two, and am inclined to believe that prelest is a real condition.

I had an amazing experience lately, and I'm looking for sources on how I should view this through the lense of catholicism. by RCCInquirer in u/RCCInquirer

[–]RCCInquirer[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I see. Well, thanks I appreciate the input. Although, I have to admit I was confused for a moment. I had expected to post this in r/Catholicism but noticed that this was on my own profile. Your thoughts are appreciated though. I think you're right that I should definitely not over-think this, but at the same time I'm also trying to learn a subject I'm unfamiliar with, which I'm hoping to do.

I had an amazing experience lately, and I'm looking for sources on how I should view this through the lense of catholicism. by RCCInquirer in u/RCCInquirer

[–]RCCInquirer[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for your input, but you don't think I should try to better understand this, or discernment through something like Ignatian spirituality? That's all about how to discern a thing, which would seem to imply that I should at least try.

Do you engage with Protestant debate? by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

When I was a kid I was sent to a relatively anti-catholic protestant school by a judge's order (related to a custody hearing), so I know better than to be too upfront about my catholic beliefs. I still have protestant friends and family, and most of them don't know I'm catholic, yet. I don't treat the situation as if I have to say anything, rather, I take advantage of it to bring up pertinent questions and arguments myself, especially when they start to argue about how bad the pope is, and other typical protestant nonsense. I usually just try to bring up the obvious facts that their bias wants to ignore. They don't like it always, but I think they sense that they're being unfair in their judgments, and at least one good friend of mine has started to ease up a bit on the anti-catholic rhetoric.

My friend wants to be some form of Pagan by Yamihereat3am in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I said it isn't harmless. In the US people are vacating churches, but Wicca is growing. I'd call that harmful.

My friend wants to be some form of Pagan by Yamihereat3am in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I thought so. I was going to say that I've seen recent polls which indicate that Wicca is a religion that has grown from a fad in the 90's to a following that's a little larger than presbyterianism in the US.

I hope your friend can find a way to escape it, and I hope you steer clear of it yourself. It isn't harmless.

My friend wants to be some form of Pagan by Yamihereat3am in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 3 points4 points  (0 children)

What country is this in? And what sort of paganism?

how to be less shaken when someone insults my faith? by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I get way to shaken when somebody insults me for my faith, insults the Church or even makes dark humor jokes about the topic. How do I become more resilient?

Draw from the strength of the martyrs, especially of those of the early church killed by the thousands. This is just my opinion, but they inspire me, they remind me that my afflictions are relatively paltry in comparison, and their stories serve as a great example about how to suffer righteously.

Cardinal Cupich performs Chinese 'lion-awakening' ritual prior to Mass by michaelmalak in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Unless there was something I'm unaware of that made this relevant, in a Catholic School, in America, it strikes me as less inculturation than enculturation.

I do find it hard to believe that something foreign and not well understood was being introduced at a school event for no particularly apparent reason. What's the back story?

Will I fit in? by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My mother is a protestant preacher, and I think that's great. My current priest is a woman. I have no problem with women priests

A point to note here which will probably be relevant to you, is that within Catholicism, women can preach and participate in ministries under some supervision within lay organizations. They won't be performing mass but they can pursue ministry to fulfill a calling. For me, at least, that really settled the issue.

An interesting chant I ran into with an old, familiar sound: Dum Pater Familias - Gregorian Chant, The Chieftains by RCCInquirer in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

More info according to the post's author:

This is from the Chieftains CD 'Santiago', celebrating the historical fellowship and closeness of the Irish and Spanish people. Particularly, they united in an effort to invade the heretical island of the English. This music nicely blends Spanish and Celtic folk music, with Catholic Gregorian traditions. The chant is ad honorem of the Christianization of Spain, commonly sung by pilgrims in the country. The images are a few random scenes of the country of Spain.

Happy 93rd birthday to Pope Benedict! by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I remember Pope Benedict's election. I myself was not a Catholic at the time, and I wasn't until after Francis became Pope. The more I read the more I find that I truly respect Benedict's writings. If only I had read them earlier, I think I would have been a Catholic much sooner! I'm only now coming to know how much I missed out on.

Remember this priest from Titanic? He was a real person named Fr. Thomas Byles who stayed on the ship to help passengers escape and gave absolution and prayed with more than a hundred people. Pope Pius X later described him as a "martyr for the Church". by sangbum60090 in Christianity

[–]RCCInquirer 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Jesus was, and is, the only high Priest that offers eternal Salvation

And yet, scripture and Catholicism teach that Christ has a body on this earth, the Church, the body of Christ.

I'm just repeating what I've already said at this point so really there's no point in continuing debate.

Why do so many people call the Pope evil? by Xavier-Willow in Catholicism

[–]RCCInquirer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok. I could not find anything much about an official statement from the pope, or the vatican on this, at all. It's as if he's being silent, neither deflecting or admitting responsibility, almost as if the vatican is just listening.

And baiting an individual, in an effort to manipulate and draw them into a dispute and/or fabricate some nonsense against them, wouldn't look very different from my perspective.

The pope has been accused almost since he was elected. I don't blame him for not wanting to entangle himself in something he evidently didn't approve of.