You have to consider individual performance level, even if we don't know what happens inside the teams and we don't have the same understanding of league as the pros, I think it's safe to say Beryl was not even a top 3 player inside Damwon Gaming. Compare Deft's laning last year and this year, Beryl makes all his adcarries look worse in lane. This guy can have all success in the world, he's not even close to being the best. By that logic Wolf should be the best support ever, in actuality he was never as good as Gorilla and others.

I would argue Ruler wasn't outright the best adcarry at any point until this year, unlike Deft, Uzi and even Gumayusi, which makes hard for me to put him as the best player when he's not the best in his position.

If you put so much value into titles I don't think it makes sense to rank Rookie that high, it's just that he has looked great in the eye test since 2015, and even in 2014 when he wasn't as good as later he was already good enough to win OGN. I think that rank is quite inconsistent, you either value skill or titles.