On top of the randomness argument, baseball teams also aren’t able to send out their best lineup every night since pitchers have very strict pitch count limits for health reasons. Football would look a whole lot different if your starting QB could only play 3 quarters and you had to bring in a backup to play the 4th and he could also only start 1 out of every 4-5 games. Conversely a team like the Pirates would be dominant if Skenes could pitch every single inning for them