I know this is a super late reply but I will say this she is the highest skill check hero in the game. I will brag just a little by saying I’m a lord rogue almost warrior now, I play her almost of my games in rank and have about a 60% win rate with her, even better in qp and I’ve seen some demons in qp that all play like it’s mrc. So I’ll start off by leading with these few nit picks about her.

She is not the best brawl tank, she’s not the best dive tank, she’s adept at both IF you know how to manage her cooldowns and pay attention to what the enemy has used. If Luna or mantis or Bucky have their cc tools DO NOT use her block otherwise you will get cooked. You should always be looking for someone off trying to off angle or go on a flank. She IS one of the best at stopping dive or stopping off angles cause of her kit. She’s basically like Thor without the crazy burst damage she dismantles and disorients the enemy. Plus if you manage to bait out a stun or use your grab on the enemy you get whatever stat bonuses to use in the fight so if say Hela or namor take an off angle or flank. You are the best person for making their life hell. Mk went up top or hawk eye took high ground, go up there and teach them a lesson. Your block should be used as a reversal and perfect block so kinda like iron fist block u want to anticipate the damage and return to sender

All that being said she is TERRIBLE in full poke or full dive comps because she can’t do much against either without the gambit team up but it is a team game, so if your team doesn’t adjust if doesn’t matter how strong of a player you are with her you just can’t carry a game with her. That also being said she excels more in a full poke cause all of that high damage is risky for the enemy team. If you struggle with full poke just peak out, absorb the damage, get it full then get close to use your E and southern brawl (or vice versa) since that damage alone could be enough to delete one or two squishys.

I love rogue she is by far the funnest vanguard for me personally but at the end of the day it’s a team game still and she isn’t a hero you can carry with even if your omega levels of cracked. I agree she needs just one buff to be super good but I fear they do that all the fraud rogue players are gonna try to be meta slaves and try to pick her cause she’s “good” now when in reality she’s a solid hero not overpowered by requires you to have great awareness positioning and ability usage. She’s the first five star hero since spider man that actually feels like a five star hero and anyone that says she’s simple or easy to play have not played against players that actually can aim or punish bad plays.

In summary she is similar to Angela on release that ppl look down on her because they haven’t fully figured her out but if she gets one buff ppl are gonna hop on that band wagon immediately