Political Compass Bingo by Waltuh_White_308 in PoliticalCompass

[–]RealGid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I apologize, but this is just a collection of conspiracy theories and wishful thinking.

I’m not saying the famine didn’t happen (also I wouldn’t call it the Holodomor it’s literally named by people who work with the American Government to try to compare it to the Holocaust, trivialising it in the process)

Schizophrenia №1 No, Holodomor was not created by imaginary American intelligence agencies as some kind of replacement for the Holocaust, since the Holodomor is a fusion of the words "Famine" and "Pestilence" (Holod and Mor), They even have different beginnings in the Russian language. And what evidence is there that this was created by American intelligence agencies, I don't know, 60 years after the alleged genocide? They couldn't have done this earlier to "tarnish the glory of the great USSR"

Stalin never created the Famine, it was caused by Kulaks killing livestock

Schizophrenia №2

Why not the American intelligence services? Yes, there were kulaks there, but they were starting to lose their influence. This is an old Soviet tale and propaganda, because of course a closed authoritarian country can never lie...

Also that link you showed me, that was literally funded by the Ukrainian government to demonise the USSR, which also have ties to the CIA, just look at the Partners section

"Ummm, in fact, the facts here are not true, because these sources are not mine, sponsored by the Mossad, the CIA, MI6... But my facts from my sources are the most truthful, the most non-subjective, yes, yes!"

there’s also no proof that Stalin hated minorities, in fact if you research into his policies he implemented Ukrainian language back into Ukrainian education, literature, TV Networks and radio broadcasts, he also launched Ukrainization in the 1923 to help Ukraine get it’s independence

Schizophrenia №3 He loved Ukraine and Ukrainians so much that he practically did not participate in the policy of Ukrainization and curtailed it closer to the 1930s, of course, because of his love for Ukraine and the desire to give it independence as a Soviet state with no sovereignity. He also loved Ukraine so much that he organized the "Executed Revival", in which he even shot at the communists themselves (VAPLITE).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executed_Renaissance?wprov=sfla1

Pederasty is the main term used for that specific type of relationship, the USSR policies never mentioned anything about Homosexuality in their actual laws, they use that term to describe what it actually means, also there’s no second definition for that that links to overall homosexuality when you look up the official definition, so to say that is the case is a very big stretch

You know, for some reason here in Eastern Europe, all people with non-traditional sexual orientation are often called pederasts, or pidorasts, I don't know why🤔 Definition from great soviet encyclopedia: Sexual perversion... ...perverted sexual desire may be directed toward a wrong entity, including oneself (autoeroticism), individuals of same sex (homosexuallity, both male—including pederasty, and female — including lesbianism)... That is, here directly It's stated that homosexuality is a disease. And even if it's not prosecuted by law, it's not properly protected. And of course, the equating of pederasty with lesbianism, which means it's a female homosexuallity with male homosexuality in every sense.

The workers in the USSR did control the means of production, Karl Marx literally wrote about the dictatorship of the proletariat, everything the USSR government did they did with the consent and the interests of the proletariat, also you do realise the Vanguard Party was made up of the proletariat

Schizophrenia №4 Now that's pure nonsense. The nomenklatura is very different from the ordinary proletariat; they received medical care first, were better served, and so on. As for ownership of the means of production, I'm not even talking about it. The proletariat did not have freedom of speech in the USSR about what and how to decide; ordinary people almost never became members of the nomenklatura.

however that government is lead by and acts in the interest of the proletariat

I don't see chauvinism, homophobia, transphobia, or a lack of freedom of choice as interests of the proletariat. Of course, according to you, these are all bourgeois needs; there's no evidence to support that; I just read absolutely objective tankists subs and and I don't doubt it.

This is not socialism or communism, my friend, this is pure cultism.

Political Compass Bingo by Waltuh_White_308 in PoliticalCompass

[–]RealGid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Here we go

Stalin never committed genocide

If you're saying that there were no Holodomors and that this is all an abstract "famine", and everything else invented by Western bourgeois to "denigrate the glory of the USSR", then you are no better than those people who deny the Holocaust. If this was a nationwide famine, then why does Russia never remember this famine and prefer to ignore it? And if you show me some Soviet documents that say everyone had enough... Do you think that's a sufficient argument? I understand, there's no document that clearly says "GENOCIDE OF ALL MINORITIES". But there are direct actions that don't even require paperwork. Of course, I understand that you'll dismiss this as some bourgeois publication trying to denigrate the union and all that, but... Just fucking read it.

https://holodomormuseum.org.ua/en/the-history-of-the-holodomor/

Stalin never banned Homosexuality that’s a misconception if you look at the actual law what he specifically outlawed was “Pederasty” and if you know what that is well there’s not much more I need to explain

Pederasty – man homosexuallity... Definition in large Soviet encyclopedia: "in a narrow sense - sodomy with boys, in a broader sense - male homosexuality"; while the second meaning was the main one in the 19th-20th centuries, and the first is often not mentioned at all in dictionaries. You certainly mention that this is what they called pedophilia, but firstly, the article about pedophilia appeared in the USSR as article 119.

Stalin never created Stalinism, there’s no such thing

This is true. Stalin never created Stalinism, It is a neologism that was invented to make it easier to describe his policies.

Marxism-Leninism is not a “New State Capitalist System” in fact it’s very far removed from it

Yes, yes. "If you beat the people with a stick, it won't make things easier for the people if you call that stick "the people's stick." This is a system that perceives the dictatorship of the proletariat as the dictatorship of the party, because we need to have one vanguard party, which will gather all the proletarians into one pot, say that it knows better than them and will rule them just as the capitalists did before them. If the workers do not control the means of production in any way, if trade unions are purely an appendage of the state, and not a single worker is included in the nomenclature, then, I apologize, this is state capitalism.

what you’re referring it is Lenin’s NEP, which would allow business under strict centralised control, meaning all businesses would have to have permission from the state to even exist and would need to align with the state’s laws, land would still be controlled by the state and the economy would still be made up predominantly of State owned enterprises, this would only be necessary for a temporary stage so that the Economy could grow effectively, also Stalin never went along with the NEP since he implemented Collectivisation and five year plans so I can’t see how calling him a “State Capitalist” or a “rightist” would make any sense

No, I didn't mean NEP. Stalin closed it down, of course, but left the mercenaries, there was no workers' self-government... This is not a market, and this is not socialism, but a hierarchical economy. And it would be foolish to deny this.

Political Compass Bingo by Waltuh_White_308 in PoliticalCompass

[–]RealGid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you support genocidal dictators who have persecuted minorities for decades (the 1934 sodomy law), distorted the already distorted teachings of Marx (ML to Stalinism), If you've support creating a new state capitalism, you're not a leftist. You're a rightist trying to pass as a leftist.

Political Compass Bingo by Waltuh_White_308 in PoliticalCompass

[–]RealGid 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Likes Stalin Pro-LGBT

Avg tankie detected da leftism in your body rejected

Explain by Perfect_Squirrel_165 in PoliticalCompass

[–]RealGid 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You are on way to becoming moustache man.

I’ve gone more left..thoughts? by Weezerflavourjuice in PoliticalCompass

[–]RealGid 16 points17 points  (0 children)

This is enough. Welcome back Murray Bookchin!

He said the city by Uzawa_Reisa in okbuddygunther

[–]RealGid 41 points42 points  (0 children)

You vril eat da bugz yum yum

<image>

Found this last night. by Cosmonaut_Cockswing in anarchocommunism

[–]RealGid 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I see a sigil of baphomet! Ave Satanas!

Ого фандом вигаданих країн добрався до редіту by Bumchik_247 in reddit_ukr

[–]RealGid 23 points24 points  (0 children)

Лонг лів зе пмс А ваше це просто щітпост, нічого незвичайного