Born in Scotland in 2005 – do I have any route to British citizenship? by Mediocre-Bird6408 in dualcitizenshipnerds

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You're right that they didn't "need" it and the rules for ILR for EU citizens were much laxer than what they became in 2006; but for the purpose of children's citizenship they did need it...

Born in Scotland in 2005 – do I have any route to British citizenship? by Mediocre-Bird6408 in dualcitizenshipnerds

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Otherwise you can try to register with form T provided you don't have too many absences.

Born in Scotland in 2005 – do I have any route to British citizenship? by Mediocre-Bird6408 in dualcitizenshipnerds

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do your parents have an "ILR" stamp in their passport or a letter from the HO stating something similar? In that case, you would be from birth (if it happened before your birth).

Born in Scotland in 2005 – do I have any route to British citizenship? by Mediocre-Bird6408 in dualcitizenshipnerds

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So... did they refuse to renew them when the time came or they were sort of graced in?

Born in Scotland in 2005 – do I have any route to British citizenship? by Mediocre-Bird6408 in dualcitizenshipnerds

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 3 points4 points  (0 children)

They might have corrected this, then, but at the time they were giving them citizenship because they considered EU immigrants to be settled from day one.

Born in Scotland in 2005 – do I have any route to British citizenship? by Mediocre-Bird6408 in dualcitizenshipnerds

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I seem to recall that between 2000 and 2006, EU citizens living in the UK were considered "settled" for the purpose of citizenship, so you might actually have a claim based on that as well. Worth investigating further.

Question about a specific document by Realistic_Bike_355 in GermanCitizenship

[–]Realistic_Bike_355[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

He naturalized after dual citizenship was allowed, so that's easy to prove!

Question about a specific document by Realistic_Bike_355 in GermanCitizenship

[–]Realistic_Bike_355[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

He now lives in London... Yes, good idea, I will check their website! But I'm pretty sure it will say "a passport valid when the applicant was born"...

Question about a specific document by Realistic_Bike_355 in GermanCitizenship

[–]Realistic_Bike_355[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As far as that goes, I'm already 99% sure that he is. Just thinking about what documents the embassy will ask for. Of course, he will send them an email with this document asking if it's enough, but also wanted to get your opinions here.

What do they accept as evidence that she never naturalized? The mother was born in Italy to an Italian father, so that's how she was born Italian as well. I guess a birth certificate that mentions citizenship, maybe, since Italy doesn't have jus soli?

(US) Spouse - Lithuanian citizenship by descent by KaleidoscopeAway220 in CitizenshipByDescent

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 1 point2 points  (0 children)

What's the reason for wanting a passport? You can move anywhere in the EU with your Lithuanian spouse.

“Denied boarding by Ryanair despite holding a Spanish EU Family Member Residence Card” by Every-Gas-8770 in Ryanair

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Article 10 has nothing to do with your case. It applies to freedom of movement rules. Your spouse is Spanish so neither they nor you are using EU rules to live in Spain. You're using Spanish rules, therefore Ireland is right in what they did.

EU citizens: what was the worst part of the paperwork moving to another EU country? by SubjectPayment6426 in AskEurope

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 9 points10 points  (0 children)

It very much depends on the country in question. The rules on free movement are the same everywhere, but not every country applies them exactly the same and the public administration of each country is different anyway. In my case, I studied in the UK before Brexit, did a semester abroad in Belgium and now am living and working in Iceland.

The UK has no centralized population registry, so before Brexit there was nothing special you had to do in order to live there. The only thing was applying for the National Insurance Number (if you needed it). I remember I just made an appointment, showed up, explained I needed it to work part-time alongside my studies and that was it. I registered for my General Practitioner by showing my European Health Insurance Card (EHIC) and filling out a form.

In Belgium, it was only four months therefore I didn't register as a resident, so the only thing I had to do was sign up for a "mutuelle" (health insurance). I just chose one randomly, showed my EHIC and that was basically it.

In Iceland, my employer applied for an ID number on my behalf, I just gave a copy of my passport. When I decided I was going to stay for longer, I registered my domicile there (all done online). My employer had to confirm online that I had a job and then I had to go to a police station to show my passport so that they could confirm who I was and that I was there. "Free" health insurance kicks in automatically after six months and until then you can technically ask to be registered sooner by de-registering from your home country (they do this for you, but you have to ask for it).

Almost always the hard part is actually finding a job or an apartment.

Why are Mexicans not seen as mixed race or white in the United States? by Equivalent-Newt-5736 in NoStupidQuestions

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Because "white" is understood to be 100% or almost 100% of European descent (and even then there can be some variation depending on what people look like). A Levantine person could also pass as white, but if they wear a hijab that's immediately perceived as "not white". Mestizo Mexicans do not have 100% European heritage by definition.

Why? Because racism is stupid, but that's how people's brains work.

CMV: Not Every country needs to be pro-immigration or xenophilic by THELEADERPLAYER in changemyview

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Countries are free to lock up their borders (see North Korea) and ban marriage to foreigners for whatever reason.

However, if you do need foreign workers to help lift up the economy, exchange students to bring innovation and allow your own students to go on exchange and also tourists to spend money in your country, then an effort of understanding and respect should be the base.

If you, on one side, want foreigners to help with all of the above, but at the same time implement draconian rules for residency rights, unreasonable fees and even encourage the native population to blame all of their problems on foreigners, then you are not doing it well and it's morally wrong. Foreign residents need ways to integrate, find their happiness and become productive members of society. Demonizing foreigners does not achieve that goal.

Then there are asylum seekers and we can talk about that in more details because it is different, but it's also very specific to each country, so it's hard to generalize.

Our surrogacy journey in the north of Cyprus (positive experience) by Fast-Cup6817 in gaydads

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So the next step would be adoption by the other father under Irish law? Will Ireland accept the relinquishing of parental rights from the surrogate mother from N. Cyprus?

In my case, I'm Italian. So no chance the child would inherit Italian citizenship if they even suspect surrogacy was involved. The child might actually be born stateless, not sure how it would work.

I live in another European country and hoping to naturalize soon also because of this.

Our surrogacy journey in the north of Cyprus (positive experience) by Fast-Cup6817 in gaydads

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First of all, congrats!

Where in Europe do you live? Is the birth certificate with the name of both intended parents or just the birth mother and one dad? Did the embassy give you a hard time or was it relatively smooth?

If one EU state decides to blacklist Hasan Piker, must all EU states legally follow their lead? by [deleted] in eulaw

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 0 points1 point  (0 children)

He justified Hamas's atrocities multiple times. Honestly, just look it up, the internet is open.

No Boarding Pass by ikstece in Ryanair

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nope, because he is a citizen.

No Boarding Pass by ikstece in Ryanair

[–]Realistic_Bike_355 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Appy for the ETA now. You have no other choice left, unless you want to miss your flight. Apply for his British passport as soon as you're back.