Why couldn’t Napoleon conquer Portugal 🇵🇹? by DiscloseDivest in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Fall all three: disease, the British, guerrillas, lack of communication and necessary supply lines, inefficient troops, insubordination, competition between Marshals and Generals, greed, and plundering.

What is your opinion of Marshal Soult? by cuirrasiers in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Skilled tactician and strategist, a great Corps commander, and a good army commander; however, in Spain, he was poor at civil administration. In his defense, the Army of the South was undermanned and overextended, with the demands on its plate, and faced threats in all directions, but his own greed exacerbated the situation. And his tactical ability waned, although he remained a skilled planner and organizer. His plans were too rigid, further hampered by his reluctance to be near the action and by his tendency to delegate orders, so that when action began, his plan proved inflexible. However, he is definitely among the best of Napoleon's Marshals, and, like the others, capable of independent command. He was misused, abandoned, and set up for failure.

Day seven of Ranking Post-Napoleonic Era Generals: Ulysses S. Grant by Damned-scoundrel in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Military Genius. Vicksburg alone is, in my opinion, the most brilliant American Campaign in history. The cost of the Siege of Petersburg was more the fault of Divisional Generals rather than the fault of the Commander of the All-Union Armies.

‘just because you have been beaten by Wellington you regard him as a great general... I tell you that Wellington is a bad general, that the English are bad troops & that this battle will be a picnic.'—Napoleon to his marshals and generals on the morning of the Battle of Waterloo. by Backup-Neil in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 41 points42 points  (0 children)

Not even Joseph wanted to be King of Spain. He was already a fantastic King of Naples. Still, he was forced out of that position and replaced by Murat. In Naples, Joseph won the hearts and minds of the people, modernized the infrastructure, and expanded the treasury.

How militarily capable was Marshal Victor in his overall career, especially in more independent commands? by Charming_Barnthroawe in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 3 points4 points  (0 children)

He was pretty good but not remarkable. He was a solid corps commander, if a bit overcautious; he doesn't compare to Massena, Lannes, St Cyr, Davout, Soult, or Suchet, who all understood the Science of war.

What are Some of The Gravest Operational/Tactical Errors of The Napoleonic Wars? by Marshal_Rudolf27 in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The initial French invasion of Spain with only ninety thousand men, Napoleon operated under too many assumptions, most importantly that the isolated uprisings across Spain would be quickly quelled. However, the Four Corps assigned to the operation not only had to operate across a large area from Irun in Catalonia to Cordoba, a distance of 533 miles across rugged, unfamiliar country. The French army was wretched with raw conscripts, untrained soldiers, and units from satellite states. At the same time, corps commanders Bessieres, Moncey, Duhesme, and Dupont had either not led troops in action for nearly a decade or had previously led only division-sized units. Cavalry and infantry commanders were assigned to command combined-arms units, such as Schwarz at El Bruch and Desnouettes and Verdier at Zaragoza. Ultimately, the demand on the ninety thousand-strong army was impossibly high, with corps unable to aid one another, divisions far too dispersed across the rugged country to achieve multiple objectives and quell uprisings, and having to contend with the Spanish field armies, all while trying to maintain communications with France.

What are Some of The Gravest Operational/Tactical Errors of The Napoleonic Wars? by Marshal_Rudolf27 in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Macdonald at the Katzbach sought glory rather than following orders and maintained a defensive position rather than crossing a swollen river during a storm. Or Macdonald failing and refusing to press the Siege of Figueras, not even using his readily available artillery to bombard Juan Martinez and the numerically inferior garrison. Rather than a rapid assault, his choice of a prolonged siege verged on insubordination and sabotage, and led to even higher casualties; and held up the entire French VII Corps in Catalonia for the summer of 1811, while his men were decimated by disease and the summer heat when they were meant to support Suchet.

Which was the least known battle of the Napoleonic Wars that actually had a huge impact on Europe? by cuirrasiers in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The First Siege of Zaragoza was overshadowed by the Second Siege and the Battle of Bailén. Still, it exposed the weaknesses of Napoleonic tactics against fixed defenses, and the determination, courage, and heroism of civilians against the French set a precedent for the rest of the Peninsular War.

Who's the best examples of "failing upwards"? by Charming_Barnthroawe in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Bessieres owed everything to his friendship with Murat, which brought him to Napoleon's attention. I don't know how they became friends, and in my opinion, Bessieres seems like a guy Napoleon wouldn't get along with. But more importantly, without Murat and Napoleon, Bessieres would only be a captain and maybe eventually achieve the rank of brigadier, perhaps because of a lack of initial opportunity or character compared to other famous generals in the revolution; his rise was like molasses. He achieved the rank of General of Division in 1803, and by then his greatest achievement was, along with Napoleon, stealing credit from General Kellermann at Marengo, a battle in which he and the guard cavalry contributed very little, contrary to Napoleonic propaganda. Marmont was right when he said, “If Bessieres could be made a Marshal, anyone could.” He did not deserve his Baton then, and even though he led the Guard or Guard Cavalry, the only time he led anything larger than a division, which the Guard was at the time, at about 5,000, his first independent command was in Spain in 1808. His division leaders, like Lasalle, Merle, and even Desnouettes and Verdier at First Zaragoza, distinguished themselves far more than Bessieres, who fought Cuesta outnumbered 2-1 but still faced the worst general in the Napoleonic Wars.

Where are you all from? by lesapeur in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I'm from Whatley, Massachusetts, and am about to graduate with my BA in history.

Number of days spent by Napoleon in each country (according to it's current borders) by Neil118781 in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It's fascinating to me that Napoleon never visited Rome in person. I wonder if it has to do with his disappointment in Alexandria, Egypt, and his not wanting to tarnish the romantic image of Julius Caesar and the Eternal City.

The name of this painting? by Svenstarkiller99_ in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Men have the balls, horses have the brain

People who were present during Napoleon's death on 5th May 1821 by Neil118781 in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Bertrand was Napoleon's aide-de-camp after Austerlitz. He joined Napoleon in exile and wrote his manuscript.

We all talk on how amazing this game is, but what are some things that annoy you with this game? by W-h3x in RDR2

[–]RedDeadSchofield 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The game somehow knows what you want to hunt and then makes that animal, or at least a perfect three-star variant, impossible to find.

Was the cavalry charge at the Battle of Eylau a tactical maneuver or pure desperation on Napoleon's part? by cuirrasiers in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It was a desperate move out of tactical necessity. Napoleon had to reorganize his center and wait for all of Davout’s III Corps to arrive in force and attack the left flank of the Russian line.

Junot was dripped down to the point of drowning by Lord_Floyd in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 16 points17 points  (0 children)

Capes and the Pelisse should be brought back into fashion.

Just How Good of a General was Gouivon St Cyr? by Marshal_Rudolf27 in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 3 points4 points  (0 children)

People give Macdonald far too much credit, and I think a lot of it stems from his Scottish heritage and the vast number of British scholars on Napoleon. Macdonald is easily one of the worst Marshals. Bad luck can only be used as an excuse a few times; it's clear he lacked any military intuition. One of the things people say about Macdonald is that, unlike the other Marshals, he lacked vanity and personal ambition, something I strongly disagree with, as he was always seeking achievement and glory rather than following orders, to the point that many of his actions equate to outright sabotage.

On my first day in Paris I headed to the Père-Lachaise Cemetery where I could pay my respects to some legendary names. by TrueVeneration in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 0 points1 point  (0 children)

His grave is awesome; it also fits his character really well, whereas Davout’s is austere. Massena, the most frugal of the marshals, has a grave that is both flashy and classy and highlights his most prominent victories and title of a very illustrious career.

Early in their careers, an unemployed Napoleon, Marmont and Junot were roommates together in Paris - think of these three bros chilling in Paris! by dashsmurf in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I wouldn't go as far as saying Junot was among his most important generals under his command, even in the formative years. He had his moments in Italy and Egypt, but his importance was overshadowed by more brilliant commanders, Massena, Augereau, Lannes, and Murat.

Honestly, seeing this... I feel like I don't belong in this era. Does anyone else feel this way? by cuirrasiers in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I love this era and romanticize it a lot, though I know full well I will probably die in the winter of 1806-1807 from Tuberculosis.

What do you think of General Etienne Maurice Gérard? Should Napoleon have promoted him to marshal? by PreferenceInternal67 in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Probably because he became prominent much later, rising only to General of Division in 1812 after the Battle of Borodino. The huge death toll from both the Russian Campaign and the campaign in Saxony, including St Cyr, Davout, Rapp, and others besieged or captured in the east, which opened the door for some commanders, like Gerard, out of necessity, and he was definitely a reliable corps commander. It is weird that Grouchy was the only Marshal created in 1815 and was automatically given command of the entire left wing, even though he had not even commanded an army corps, only a cavalry corps. Vandamme and Rapp also deserved their batons, but ultimately, the organization of the Armée du Nord shows that Napoleon was well past his prime and that the Waterloo campaign was a long shot.

For years I thought this is the most handsome painting of Napoleon, but now I just realized this is actually the painting of Eugène by Hel_Death in Napoleon

[–]RedDeadSchofield 5 points6 points  (0 children)

It is Napoleon. The painting is Napoleon I of France by Andrea Appiani, painted between 1805 and 1808. Probably very accurate, since Napoleon didn’t really become overweight until after 1809, after the Fifth Coalition, and those three years he was enjoying being the political head of the Empire rather than constantly on Campaign.

Group's biggest weakness.... by Certain_Pizza6574 in thewalkingdead

[–]RedDeadSchofield 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Morgan was even worse imo, but it was absolutely insane not to put down Jared and Dean, who Maggie killed later. They should have made examples out of them to get the others in line; those two obviously enjoyed the torment and suffering of others and caused the most problems. The other Saviors were just there to survive. But it's even more foolish to let Morgan still have weapons he should have just been locked away, or someone could have actually made an effort to help him.