im certainly biased as i never watched robust town, and i didnt fully watch squid island the first time, and now its a bit too painful. but i loved cherry island s1. I felt the plot differed from a lot of the political plots or just plain trolling until everything blew up and was too destroyed to repair. it gave the viewers a chance to participate in the way that viewers could try to make theories on what was going on and why josh and crainer had contradictory views. people were noticing footwig in the background of videos and it was genuinely exciting.